Town Hall 10 "The Compartment"

Printable View

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page

October 1st, 2014
Shadowslayer3120

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jdoggxx123xx

yea ive checked it over..its absolutely sh*t

See? That wasn't so hard!
Kudos for not dragging this on longer.
October 1st, 2014
Jdoggxx123xx

yea np

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shadowslayer3120

See? That wasn't so hard!
Kudos for not dragging this on longer.

might come out with a newish design. need to gather up some high level troop replays first :)
October 1st, 2014
lukedaman27

Interesting Base...

Yes, you've made a new base already, and yes this old one may look like a piece of ♥♥♥♥... But I'd still like to give some feedback... I don't know, might probably have a chance... with a lot of alterations. Ideas are meant to be shared, ya know?

So, although this goes against the general rule of "X-junctions are a no-no," it has just a bit of potential... Stagger the walls a bit, make it much more robust. If anything, this must be a practice/test base.
Here are a bit of suggestions to make it better:

The Base: The title says it all. The "Compartment." The base doesn't need to live up to it's name. Being a mid-th9, compact compartments have brought me bad experiences. Space out the walls a bit more, and maybe 2/3 buildings per compartment...?

Defenses: Major defenses are exposed. Your bottom x bow could be switched with the inner mortar, in my opinion. Make the base a bit more spread out, as I'll explain later on.

Walls: See those bottom air defenses? Now take a look to the line of walls covering the top half of it. Swing that part w/ the walls covering AQ and BK outwards, compartmentalizing now three buildings. I'd suggest bringing in a point defense. Try this with the rest of the walls, and maybe... just maybe... compartmentalizing may be a success.

Storages: Very susceptible. Too close together for my liking. Gobs with Jump spells/heal can wipe 'em out quick, faster than your infernos can fry them. As said, stagger walls and make bigger spaces. By doing so, you can include trap giant bombs or other traps.

Traps: As said earlier, traps could be useful. What use are they when placed in predictable spots? I mean, of course they could be predictable when 2x2 spaces are in your base, but it'll be a bit harder for players to guess if it's a tesla or not. Use your imagination! If you can create bases like these, you should know trap placements!

Overall, it's a start. If you make the changes I've suggested, you may not want to call it "The Compartment" any more, lol. Without doubt, it's definitely not anti-hog, anti-dragon, or anti-GoWiWi. Try to improve this by bringing in AD closer, and wizard towers in more optimum places. This is meant to be a farming base, but people can attack you using these army compositions.

Anyways, I hope there will be a Version 2 of this, you have unique designs, they may be a bit weird, but at least they can inspire. Try incorporating your compartment idea to another famous anti-hog or anti-____ th10 base. Could be a success!
October 2nd, 2014
Jdoggxx123xx

woah lukedaman27!

Quote:

Originally Posted by lukedaman27

Yes, you've made a new base already, and yes this old one may look like a piece of ♥♥♥♥... But I'd still like to give some feedback... I don't know, might probably have a chance... with a lot of alterations. Ideas are meant to be shared, ya know?

So, although this goes against the general rule of "X-junctions are a no-no," it has just a bit of potential... Stagger the walls a bit, make it much more robust. If anything, this must be a practice/test base.
Here are a bit of suggestions to make it better:

The Base: The title says it all. The "Compartment." The base doesn't need to live up to it's name. Being a mid-th9, compact compartments have brought me bad experiences. Space out the walls a bit more, and maybe 2/3 buildings per compartment...?

Defenses: Major defenses are exposed. Your bottom x bow could be switched with the inner mortar, in my opinion. Make the base a bit more spread out, as I'll explain later on.

Walls: See those bottom air defenses? Now take a look to the line of walls covering the top half of it. Swing that part w/ the walls covering AQ and BK outwards, compartmentalizing now three buildings. I'd suggest bringing in a point defense. Try this with the rest of the walls, and maybe... just maybe... compartmentalizing may be a success.

Storages: Very susceptible. Too close together for my liking. Gobs with Jump spells/heal can wipe 'em out quick, faster than your infernos can fry them. As said, stagger walls and make bigger spaces. By doing so, you can include trap giant bombs or other traps.

Traps: As said earlier, traps could be useful. What use are they when placed in predictable spots? I mean, of course they could be predictable when 2x2 spaces are in your base, but it'll be a bit harder for players to guess if it's a tesla or not. Use your imagination! If you can create bases like these, you should know trap placements!

Overall, it's a start. If you make the changes I've suggested, you may not want to call it "The Compartment" any more, lol. Without doubt, it's definitely not anti-hog, anti-dragon, or anti-GoWiWi. Try to improve this by bringing in AD closer, and wizard towers in more optimum places. This is meant to be a farming base, but people can attack you using these army compositions.

Anyways, I hope there will be a Version 2 of this, you have unique designs, they may be a bit weird, but at least they can inspire. Try incorporating your compartment idea to another famous anti-hog or anti-____ th10 base. Could be a success!

first of all it really means a lot that you would spend so much time on a full review for a sucky base! yea im not the most talented lol. maybe you should redesign this if you ever get bored? i mean you sound extremely experienced so if you gave it a shot it would probably be so strong with the adjustments! just thanks so much for the tips! :D see now you are the type of person that i can respect because you didn't just leave a one sentence hate comment like many others..THIS right here my friends is TRUE thoughtful constructive criticism! in the future i hope to add all of your improvements because i can always look back to this! so once again thanks man!!
October 2nd, 2014
crazyclasher1

that was the best

Quote:

Originally Posted by lukedaman27

Yes, you've made a new base already, and yes this old one may look like a piece of ♥♥♥♥... But I'd still like to give some feedback... I don't know, might probably have a chance... with a lot of alterations. Ideas are meant to be shared, ya know?

So, although this goes against the general rule of "X-junctions are a no-no," it has just a bit of potential... Stagger the walls a bit, make it much more robust. If anything, this must be a practice/test base.
Here are a bit of suggestions to make it better:

The Base: The title says it all. The "Compartment." The base doesn't need to live up to it's name. Being a mid-th9, compact compartments have brought me bad experiences. Space out the walls a bit more, and maybe 2/3 buildings per compartment...?

Defenses: Major defenses are exposed. Your bottom x bow could be switched with the inner mortar, in my opinion. Make the base a bit more spread out, as I'll explain later on.

Walls: See those bottom air defenses? Now take a look to the line of walls covering the top half of it. Swing that part w/ the walls covering AQ and BK outwards, compartmentalizing now three buildings. I'd suggest bringing in a point defense. Try this with the rest of the walls, and maybe... just maybe... compartmentalizing may be a success.

Storages: Very susceptible. Too close together for my liking. Gobs with Jump spells/heal can wipe 'em out quick, faster than your infernos can fry them. As said, stagger walls and make bigger spaces. By doing so, you can include trap giant bombs or other traps.

Traps: As said earlier, traps could be useful. What use are they when placed in predictable spots? I mean, of course they could be predictable when 2x2 spaces are in your base, but it'll be a bit harder for players to guess if it's a tesla or not. Use your imagination! If you can create bases like these, you should know trap placements!

Overall, it's a start. If you make the changes I've suggested, you may not want to call it "The Compartment" any more, lol. Without doubt, it's definitely not anti-hog, anti-dragon, or anti-GoWiWi. Try to improve this by bringing in AD closer, and wizard towers in more optimum places. This is meant to be a farming base, but people can attack you using these army compositions.

Anyways, I hope there will be a Version 2 of this, you have unique designs, they may be a bit weird, but at least they can inspire. Try incorporating your compartment idea to another famous anti-hog or anti-____ th10 base. Could be a success!

probably some of the best advice ive ever seen!
October 2nd, 2014
lukedaman27

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jdoggxx123xx

first of all it really means a lot that you would spend so much time on a full review for a sucky base! yea im not the most talented lol. maybe you should redesign this if you ever get bored? i mean you sound extremely experienced so if you gave it a shot it would probably be so strong with the adjustments! just thanks so much for the tips! :D see now you are the type of person that i can respect because you didn't just leave a one sentence hate comment like many others..THIS right here my friends is TRUE thoughtful constructive criticism! in the future i hope to add all of your improvements because i can always look back to this! so once again thanks man!!

Haha, yes, it was my pleasure! I'm not a big fan of negative comments, and I always think, then why not give positive comments to improve something? It's worth the chance, eh? And yes, with a few tweaks, a base like this could be adjusted so that it can defend properly. Many bases are underestimated, take this one for example. Who knows, it could become the new trend for CoC. It can become an illusion; it may look like a bad design, but when the attacker comes in, he might be in for a suprise...

Quote:

Originally Posted by crazyclasher1

probably some of the best advice ive ever seen!

Thank you sir! I appreciate it! Making tips like these are astoundingly fun for me. I learn new stuff myself, and can freely share them with others. There are still other people out there who make better guides/advice than me haha.
October 2nd, 2014
crazyclasher1

yea

luke is really nice for that
October 2nd, 2014
0002

Well, If you attack from the top with barch, you're going to lose, but that's all I can see about this base. Not much potential if you ask me.....
October 2nd, 2014
Jdoggxx123xx

yes

Quote:

Originally Posted by 0002

Well, If you attack from the top with barch, you're going to lose, but that's all I can see about this base. Not much potential if you ask me.....

i am greatly aware of it by now haha
October 3rd, 2014
bestshooter11

like i said before

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jdoggxx123xx

i am greatly aware of it by now haha

WHO CARES what others think if completely negative with no help

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page