Donation/Request Ratio - find the slackers in the clan!

My clan is very active, however it is only the top 20-25 players that actively donate between each other and you have the slackers that just take. I know you can see how many donations are given by each member, however you can't see how much they are taking. So if a member is away for a week for instance - he looks like a slacker, but really just hasn't been there.

Wouldn't it be a great idea to give the donation and request statistics as a ratio so that you can weed out the slackers in the clan.

I agree with this wholeheartedly, as it will also let you know who the real clan members are as it will show by their requests, as the higher players have bigger Clan Castles, and the smaller guys have smaller Clan Castles, so you could find a small guy giving say 400 troops but only requests for 200 , this is a great idea, I hope Supercell uses this info its very good for a clan to see , as well as it weeds out the Clan Hoppers that every clan hates.

I agree with this suggestion. Donation number alone says nothing at all about the contribution of an individual to the clan, per the arguments above. Why have this number at all then without other useful information such as a donation/request ratio.

Thanks for the backups guys!

Agreed!
Asked for this a few month ago, and still think it is a good idea

This idea is very popular. Donate/request transparency in clan listing would def keep clan members more honest. It'd certainly decrease clan drop out and keep more users from getting disillusioned. More players = more money...

Very much agreed!!!

As an elder of an active clan, I have noticed besides some people who never donates, there are some players who may donate now and then, but could be requesting 20 times the amount they donate. This has rendered the amount of troops donated a kinda unfair criteria to judge the behavior of players. For instance, player A may be busy for a week, he only requested 20 clan troops for himself, but managed to come over and made 250 donations. On the other hand, player B uses clan troops for every single battle of his, he also donated 250 troops but actually used 4000 troops from the clan.


Displaying both numbers of troops requested and troops donated, will make it very clear that which people are mostly helping out other players and which ones are being greedy and selfish. I think this will do good to the game and most importantly, to the players themselves, in the long run.

I agree!!!!
Please add troops received.

this is much better than what we currently have, i hope they implement it. + 1 for this one.

+1

10 characters

I have players in my clan that are currently 'eldered'. I have given over 3,000 troops this period and rarely do I see these guys donate to others but always see them requesting for troops. Their donations are minimal at best..maybe 400 troops donated but they've probably received over 1,000 troops. Would like to weed out the useless elders with this feature. Our clan banner says one thing in all caps..DON'T JOIN IF U DON'T DONATE!

Come on, we need a few more players backing this idea - please add your comments so this request is taken seriously.

Thanks!

What I like the most, is that when they request, they do it in bunches, but when it comes to donate, like not even between those who requested at the same time, they do like Mandrake... they disappear!!!

I support this idea as well. It would be nice to also remove "request troops" from the map and put it in a tab next to global/chat (or have all requests float to the top of chat). On this donations tab, all open requests are posted and you must see them, possibly scroll past them (donating along the way we hope) to add your request. Once posted, I recommend removing the "thanks for the troop" note and use the real estate to add the donatations/filled ratio for all to see before they decide to donate.

I have this posted elsewhere but thought it would be nice all on one string now that I found this.

Great idea, would be nice too see the ratios of donations to requests.

This was a very good suggestion

Love this idea! I posted something similar to this a little over a month ago + our clan has been talking about this little wish list item for over a month on clan chat. It would really help with activity tracking and fair measure before kicking players.

We are a fun clan that tries to be fair - having both set of stats clearly visible would really help make some of the decisions easier and fair.

There should i want to find a slacker in my clan

I would very much like to get our clan's players' troop donation/request data from a web-API. It would be ideal if Supercell would create a statistics website for players to view. This would help clan leaders and elders to monitor clan's players. For example which players request a lot but do not donate to others and also inactive players. If supercell do not want to create such a site then could you open an API for us enthusiasts to create our own statistics tools?

Not bad at all

Simple fix for the slacker group. Add a filter in the CC. If there are open troop requests in clan chat, you may not request until you donate yourself. There needs to be a set criteria that would release you from the obligation allowing you to request. Would it be a single goblin? A minimum of five troop spaces? A minimum of five troop spaces to all open requests? I like that one. It forces you to give to all requests before you can request yourself.

Been asking about this for ages, it would be so helpful and help stop a lot of whinging and moaning about donations.

I support this. :)

I think it would be very helpful to have troop donations posted in the tab when a player requests troops. Next to the players name maybe. This way when you scroll through donation requests, you can donate to those who donate and ignore those who don't.
As a side note the donate/request ratio suggested in prior posts might be misleading. I request often because on average I receive 1 donation per 3 request. So to fill my castle I need to request 9 times give or take.

+1 This should have been done from the start.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bigjohnson073

I think it would be very helpful to have troop donations posted in the tab when a player requests troops. Next to the players name maybe. This way when you scroll through donation requests, you can donate to those who donate and ignore those who don't.
As a side note the donate/request ratio suggested in prior posts might be misleading. I request often because on average I receive 1 donation per 3 request. So to fill my castle I need to request 9 times give or take.

---

This is just semantics. It could be donated/recieved rather than donated/requested. Also, if you need to request 9 times to fill your cc, I highly recommend you find a new clan. A second request is not that common in our clan as I suspect is the case in many active clan.

+1 +1 +1 !!!

I specifically registered to this site to make this exact feature request and found many have already been requesting this feature. Just do it already!

Agreed! At the moment i have to either see they have no donations when they request or (after a while unactive in the clan) i visit to see if they have troops in CC. i cant stand hoppers. :)

Already been suggested , n it will be there in the next update ( CoC fb page )