Donation/Request Ratio - find the slackers in the clan!

My clan is very active, however it is only the top 20-25 players that actively donate between each other and you have the slackers that just take. I know you can see how many donations are given by each member, however you can't see how much they are taking. So if a member is away for a week for instance - he looks like a slacker, but really just hasn't been there.

Wouldn't it be a great idea to give the donation and request statistics as a ratio so that you can weed out the slackers in the clan.

I agree with this wholeheartedly, as it will also let you know who the real clan members are as it will show by their requests, as the higher players have bigger Clan Castles, and the smaller guys have smaller Clan Castles, so you could find a small guy giving say 400 troops but only requests for 200 , this is a great idea, I hope Supercell uses this info its very good for a clan to see , as well as it weeds out the Clan Hoppers that every clan hates.

I agree with this suggestion. Donation number alone says nothing at all about the contribution of an individual to the clan, per the arguments above. Why have this number at all then without other useful information such as a donation/request ratio.

Thanks for the backups guys!

Agreed!
Asked for this a few month ago, and still think it is a good idea

This idea is very popular. Donate/request transparency in clan listing would def keep clan members more honest. It'd certainly decrease clan drop out and keep more users from getting disillusioned. More players = more money...

Very much agreed!!!

As an elder of an active clan, I have noticed besides some people who never donates, there are some players who may donate now and then, but could be requesting 20 times the amount they donate. This has rendered the amount of troops donated a kinda unfair criteria to judge the behavior of players. For instance, player A may be busy for a week, he only requested 20 clan troops for himself, but managed to come over and made 250 donations. On the other hand, player B uses clan troops for every single battle of his, he also donated 250 troops but actually used 4000 troops from the clan.


Displaying both numbers of troops requested and troops donated, will make it very clear that which people are mostly helping out other players and which ones are being greedy and selfish. I think this will do good to the game and most importantly, to the players themselves, in the long run.

I agree!!!!
Please add troops received.

this is much better than what we currently have, i hope they implement it. + 1 for this one.

+1

10 characters