The NEW one and only loot is good or bad thread

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pete82

1 mil per hour is completely unreasonable. No one needs that to normally progress through the game, even at TH10. This is why SC doesn't take this thread seriously....

---

I dont know know what level you are but try this on for size.

If you think one million an hour is unreasonable let us presume you think 500k per hour is fair. If a person plays two hours a day that is quite a lot of time to spend just playing a game. That gets you one million a day in your 'reasonable' game.

I am working on my lava walls....I would like to FARM the gold as I am not rich and cannot BUY them. At 500k per hour and two hours solid play EVERYDAY day (assume no loss from raids LOL) my walls would take me......

Three days a wall and a total of TWO FULL YEARS to complete.

one million an hour unreasonable?????

You, sir, are the one who is unreasonable

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Omes

What?? this is not how it supposed to be concluded!
Beware the wrath of Darth Coathanger! :rolleyes:

---

Same problem since the birth of CoC, nothing new. ;):p
Thanx for thinking of me.:D

I got nice loot this morning! With a profit of 2 million.

Revenge allowed..
1) a pop up requiring a user to enter number 123(random) to prove they are on line.
- don't enter attack aloud.
2) that will stop fluffy bunny's and auto clickers..
3) revenge attacks get a full share of loot.
4) 41%attack to aquire any loot bonus.
5) 50% kills to aquire trophies.
- this will stop/slowdown sniping and fluffy bunny
- at the very least would require a total rewrite of there programs and logic.
6) role back pink for walls, that is the life's blood of our armies...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Anoushka

I have nothing against what you just wrote, I do accept that I am at fault by not conveying a similar message, I'm certain it would ease the matter for a while. And my post was not out of frustration with the thread itself. Almost 400pages in this thread tell me that there is a problem of course, my only frustration comes from the fact that don't have an unambiguous answer to provide as of yet

Suggestions are more than welcome and have not gone unnoticed, some have been ruled out due to how if affects the rest of the game, others are a possibility

---

I was thinking maybe a narrower range in which people can search bases, for example maybe 50 trophies greater or less than what you have. This would probably push inactives up the que but could also limit the bunnies. It might be better if implemented after the bunny issue is dealt with though.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CloudGigaTitan

? Obviously the loot issue has not died judging by the number of pages and posts about it on this thread.

Another obvious reason why it has not died is because the loot especially elixir is still LOW LOW LOW oh so terribly LOW

---

Or players like me quit game, so no need to complain more.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Relentless

I dont know know what level you are but try this on for size.

If you think one million an hour is unreasonable let us presume you think 500k per hour is fair. If a person plays two hours a day that is quite a lot of time to spend just playing a game. That gets you one million a day in your 'reasonable' game.

I am working on my lava walls....I would like to FARM the gold as I am not rich and cannot BUY them. At 500k per hour and two hours solid play EVERYDAY day (assume no loss from raids LOL) my walls would take me......

Three days a wall and a total of TWO FULL YEARS to complete.

one million an hour unreasonable?????

You, sir, are the one who is unreasonable

---

I think playing for an hour straight and adding up your gold in that hour in unreasonable. If I actually played for 2 hours in a day I would make far more than 2 million gold. I only log on when my army is ready.

Yes, 2 years to max walls is very reasonable. I've played for a year and my GG is over 1 bil. I think that is a very good pace.

Edit: level 125 TH10 with a 1.05 billion GG. I never said it should be 500k btw, I just think expecting 1 mil in an hour of straight barching collectors is unrealistic to always obtain.

Supercell has said in the past that 90% of all the loot in the game comes from the collectors. So logically, increasing the incentives for people to max their collectors is what can help the economy the most. I mean, you can have higher level collectors and increased collector production, but if people don't build them, it doesn't matter.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pete82

I think playing for an hour straight and adding up your gold in that hour in unreasonable. If I actually played for 2 hours in a day I would make far more than 2 million gold. I only log on when my army is ready.

Yes, 2 years to max walls is very reasonable. I've played for a year and my GG is over 1 bil. I think that is a very good pace.

Edit: level 125 TH10 with a 1.05 billion GG. I never said it should be 500k btw, I just think expecting 1 mil in an hour of straight barching collectors is unrealistic to always obtain.

---

I second this. When you become TH10, you instantly have the worst loot penalty in the game. Not just talking stats/numbers, but the fact you can only effectively farm TH9-10.

This leads to inconsistent looting. Sure, you could pull in 1m an hour. You could pull in 2m if you have the patience/luck/skill.. It just isn't realistic. Especially how loot is atm *refers to the thread this is being posted in*.

I'm working on lavas too, if I hadn't put in the amount of time I have/do, then I would not have been this upgraded. Now I get loot wherever I can, I try not to be too fussy *refers to league farming guide in sig*

I think it is very reasonable to make walls take years to max. If everyone had max walls in less than a year, where would the self accomplishment come from? Champions? No, that's too easy. Max defense? Nope. Max troops? Meh.

Walls.

"They are more than just a defense, they are a decorative, bragging defense" ( M&S reference for all those Brits )

I'm sure there are ways Supercell can increase the amount of collector raids. Stopping the fluffy bunnies is the most important one. If they can't stop them there are numerous bandaid solutions they can implement to increase collector-raids.

That being said they should use the current loot-problem to NOT do that. Getting gold/elexir/de shouldn't be done by pillaging collectorbases. A boring, tedious and generally not fun way of raiding. They should increase league bonus and make league bonus schale with how many stars you get. i.e. Current league bonus for one-stars, X5 for two-stars and X10 for threestars.

Championbonus is 120K each and 800 DE. Scoring a 3* there is probably extremely rare and if done only done with an extremely expensive army. The reward should be accordingly. At first it'll be a bit of a raidfest on bases who're currently high up but really shouldn't be. Those bases will be quickly 3*ed repeatedly until they're in a league more befitting their defence.

From a game perspective it seems more fair to reward people for defeating hard bases, not preying on weak bases who just happen to have a lot of loot.