A New Idea For 'Breaking' Attacks If The User Comes Online!

Printable View

September 22nd, 2014
HAZARDOUS

1 Attachment(s)

A New Idea For 'Breaking' Attacks If The User Comes Online!

Hello there!
I know how frustrating it can be when you see this (although it is very rare!) -

Attachment 66072

You feel powerless, helpless and probably stupid.

What I propose is a simple solution.

Whenever a situation like this arises where an attack is taking place and the user comes online - the attack is 'broken'. This situation is very rare and very few players (including me) have actually seen this screen. But if this happens, what happens is that the loot which is already raided goes to the raider but the rest which is left out remains with the user being attacked. The percentage of the base destroyed till the user came online is taken into account as the final percentage.

I hope that you like this idea and would like to see this implemented.

" If you have something good to say, I'll take it seriously.
If something not so good, very seriously! "

Thank you!

* This thread is suggestion-friendly! So go on comment! :) *
September 22nd, 2014
ldyjsmyn

Quote:

Originally Posted by HAZARDOUS

Hello there!I know how frustrating it can be when you see this (although it is very rare!) -Attachment 66072You feel powerless, helpless and probably stupid. What I propose is a simple solution. Whenever a situation like this arises where an attack is taking place and the user comes online - the attack is 'broken'. This situation is very rare and very few players (including me) have actually seen this screen. But if this happens, what happens is that the loot which is already raided goes to the raider but the rest which is left out remains with the user being attacked. The percentage of the base destroyed till the user came online is taken into account as the final percentage. I hope that you like this idea and would like to see this implemented.
" If you have something good to say, I'll take it seriously.If something not so good, very seriously! "
Thank you!* This thread is suggestion-friendly! So go on comment! :) *

Breaking an attack during the middle of a raid would be unfair to the attacker. I have seen this screen many times and and no i do not like that wait. However i do feel that leaving it how it is is the best way.
September 22nd, 2014
Denrochee

Any player that plays a decent amount has seen that screen.

First of all as previously mentioned, SO unfair to the attacker, and what about the players whos only time offline is after the 6 hour boot, if they can come back an end a raid, getting most likely, a free defensive win before going on for another six hours they would never lose.

Edit: as soon as I posted I thought of a way to exploit, at my cup range 2800ish, I get attacked between 5&20 minutes of getting offline, the higher you go the sooner you get attacked. Whats to stop me from constantly logging on and off to break attacks and get free defensive wins and roll in da cups?
September 22nd, 2014
LachNessMeownster

So... You log off in champs league, wait 30 seconds until you are under attack, then log back in and win?
September 22nd, 2014
rwelshjr

Quote:

Originally Posted by ldyjsmyn

Breaking an attack during the middle of a raid would be unfair to the attacker. I have seen this screen many times and and no i do not like that wait. However i do feel that leaving it how it is is the best way.

This says it well. We would all like to be able to stop that scallywag that is defiling our base. But it is his right.

If I had dropped a ton of troops to level a base then only got half of what I was expecting because the attack got broken I would be quite upset. I would come right here to gripe to SC about how unfair that was. And I would have lots of company too.
September 22nd, 2014
KingDao

I see the new face of trophy pushing..... Breaking your shield and logging in every 30 seconds to "break" raids and gain trophies..... This is a terrible idea. You're done kid.
September 22nd, 2014
klem70

Sorry I see the message a lot.

Stopping the attacks in no go for me.

Maybe let us watch it live.
September 22nd, 2014
Sokitani

Quote:

Originally Posted by HAZARDOUS

Hello there!
I know how frustrating it can be when you see this (although it is very rare!) -

Attachment 66072

You feel powerless, helpless and probably stupid.

What I propose is a simple solution.

Whenever a situation like this arises where an attack is taking place and the user comes online - the attack is 'broken'. This situation is very rare and very few players (including me) have actually seen this screen. But if this happens, what happens is that the loot which is already raided goes to the raider but the rest which is left out remains with the user being attacked. The percentage of the base destroyed till the user came online is taken into account as the final percentage.

I hope that you like this idea and would like to see this implemented.

" If you have something good to say, I'll take it seriously.
If something not so good, very seriously! "

Thank you!

* This thread is suggestion-friendly! So go on comment! :) *

Ive been playing clash fora year and a half and Ive seen this screen at least 100 times.(Especially when pushing for masters)

This would be unfair what if someone was doing an expensive raid and as soon as they deployed the troops the battle was broken before they were able to steal anything
September 23rd, 2014
HAZARDOUS

Right..

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheGreatLach

So... You log off in champs league, wait 30 seconds until you are under attack, then log back in and win?

Quote:

Originally Posted by rwelshjr

This says it well. We would all like to be able to stop that scallywag that is defiling our base. But it is his right.
If I had dropped a ton of troops to level a base then only got half of what I was expecting because the attack got broken I would be quite upset. I would come right here to gripe to SC about how unfair that was. And I would have lots of company too.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Denrochee

Any player that plays a decent amount has seen that screen.
First of all as previously mentioned, SO unfair to the attacker, and what about the players whos only time offline is after the 6 hour boot, if they can come back an end a raid, getting most likely, a free defensive win before going on for another six hours they would never lose.

Edit: as soon as I posted I thought of a way to exploit, at my cup range 2800ish, I get attacked between 5&20 minutes of getting offline, the higher you go the sooner you get attacked. Whats to stop me from constantly logging on and off to break attacks and get free defensive wins and roll in da cups?

Quote:

Originally Posted by ldyjsmyn

Breaking an attack during the middle of a raid would be unfair to the attacker. I have seen this screen many times and and no i do not like that wait. However i do feel that leaving it how it is is the best way.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sokitani

Ive been playing clash fora year and a half and Ive seen this screen at least 100 times.(Especially when pushing for masters)

This would be unfair what if someone was doing an expensive raid and as soon as they deployed the troops the battle was broken before they were able to steal anything

Ok cool. I understand your concern. I guess you're right. No problem! Was just a thought anyway.

Quote:

Originally Posted by KingDao

I see the new face of trophy pushing..... Breaking your shield and logging in every 30 seconds to "break" raids and gain trophies..... This is a terrible idea. You're done kid.

Even if this idea isn't a go, it certainly doesn't mean I'm done. Get that straight.

Quote:

Originally Posted by klem70

Sorry I see the message a lot.

Stopping the attacks in no go for me.

Maybe let us watch it live.

Yeah. that would be great!