Printable View
I have added some additional statistic charts at the bottom that compare this troop's damage to wizards and its health to giant bombs.
Hope they help :) And as always I love it when you guys comment so make sure to post anything you have to say whether it's a suggestion, some friendly support, or some criticism! I appreciate it all!
I'm not even at a high enough level to get this troop and I'm still excited about it. Great job!
I do have one question though. Let's say this troop follows the giants, cutting through to the center of the base. Now there are buildings in front, and behind him. Can he throw his knives in front and behind simultaneously? Or will he focus in one direction at a time?
I think that the housing space is too much. For a ranged support unit, archers and wizards would be more effective. Valkyries do much more damage, as well as destroying walls occasionally. Sure, it may do more dmg per second than a wizard. However, if you factor in that it attacks 3 buildings at once, it is less effective. Let's say a wizard 1 shots a cannon. If there are 3 cannons, it would take the wizard 3 shots. The rogue would attack all 3 at once, so each cannon has more time alive, and therefore can do more damage to the rogue or any other units. With a lower housing space, it could be an alternative to the wizard, but at 5 housing space, wizards would be a better choice. Anyone understands me? I tried to explain this in terms of archers and wizards to my friends, but unfortunately they think me a fool.
He will throw both in front and behind, sweeping his arm horizontally in an arc and bending at the waist to rotate enough to hit targets anywhere around him.Quote:
Originally Posted by AceOfRaids
Actually at higher levels this unit does less damage than a wizard however the damage is not the main focus, an entire group of wizards can easily be taken out by one giant bomb but this unit has the unique ability among ranged units to have enough health to survive them. Also, say a group of 8 wizards walks into the middle of 3 cannons, If you have ever watched them they tend to target the same thing meaning that they would have to refocus twice in order to take out all 3 whereas Rogues would target all 3 at once and if there were 8 of them they would actually most likely take them out faster than 8 wizards would since they wouldn't need to take the time to refocus.Quote:
Originally Posted by 000calc1
If either of you have any more questions I'd love to hear em! I'll answer them as well and quickly as I can as well as any questions anyone else has! So feel free to post any questions, comments, concerns, criticisms, or support here!
When you say 60 damage, does it mean that each knife does 60 damage or each knife only does 20 damage?
Looks pretty good, although i think its max level should be 4. And if it is available only at town hall 10, i think all upgrades should be available in level 8 lab (level 7 is for town hall 9). But those are small details. Otherwise, I really like the idea, its almost like a long-range valkyrie. Very good job, and good luck! :)
The total damage is split between the three knives so at level 1 each knife does 20. Thanks for the question dude :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Serenejazz
When you say that its max level should be 4 do you mean I should remove level 1 and 2? or level 5 and 6? because it only starts surviving giant bombs at level 3 which is one of the main aspects of this troop. Also, I see what you're saying about the lab level 8, I just figured 5 upgrades in one lab level is a bit too much. I dunno maybe there'll be a lab level 9 someday. Anyway, thanks for the support dude! If you have anything else to add feel free to comment! I'd love to hear any ideas :cool:Quote:
Originally Posted by Lindhoolm99
I meant that Level 1 would be the same as level 1, and level 4 would be the same as level 6, so maybe remove level 3 & 5? Dunno. Just dont think it needs 6 levels.Quote:
Originally Posted by evjohn13
About the lab, i think it would be best if the troop actually become available at town hall 9 instead of town hall 10 (just my opinion tho). It just dont make too much sense to be able to upgrade a troop at th 9 if it becomes available at th 10. But, if they take this troop in the game, which i hope, they would find a way as always. Keep up the good work! :)
Hmm, I think i'm going to keep it with 6 levels, removing any in the middle would completely defeat the purpose of having each level be able to withstand the next giant bomb level which is one of the core aspects of the troop. as for the second point I did think about that, although what would be best from my point of view would be a lab level 9. I doubt supercell would add 3 troops to one town hall level, I Honestly believe that at some point in the not so far off future they will be adding a town hall 11 which would make sense since walls go up that high, and also the last two dark barracks troops would finally have a town hall to unlock at. But i shouldn't go into stuff like that too much here, Wouldn't want my thread to be closed for going off topic too much :PQuote:
Originally Posted by Lindhoolm99
Anyway, If anyone else has any other questions, concerns, criticisms, or comments, I'd love to hear them as always! So keep em coming! I'll answer them as well and as quickly as I can :cool:
Dude, I've been going through all your troop and spell ideas and you have come up with some really cool ideas!:D Overall I think that this is a really cool and well balanced troop and I have to say how it targets three different things at once will really help in battles.