Disappointed

I feel that i am becoming very disappointed in this game. I almost want to stop playing. I feel that being unreal about some ideas such as troops that dont die, you dont get back or at least elixer back. It just seems unfair. I have spent to much time for nothing waiting for troops to raid and in the end loosing them for nothing. I feel this game doesnt deserve my time at some points when i could be spending it on things that are real. This idea is so small but a big deal is made about it. Sorry Supercell. I dont like talking about things like this on my favorite games but i have lately been disappointed. You really should look over the idea.

It's up to you whether to continue playing or quit. The game isn't made to be extremely easy. You have to try and work for accomplishments throughout the game (although you could always just gem, but that costs money).

About your ideas to help you out more, they have already been ruled out. There's a sticky you can read that lists what is and isn't ruled out. Maybe if you read that you could come up with some sort of new idea that isn't ruled out.

Anyways, the decision for you to play or not is yours to make. Not anyone else's.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Valkery710

I feel that i am becoming very disappointed in this game. I almost want to stop playing. I feel that being unreal about some ideas such as troops that dont die, you dont get back or at least elixer back. It just seems unfair. I have spent to much time for nothing waiting for troops to raid and in the end loosing them for nothing. I feel this game doesnt deserve my time at some points when i could be spending it on things that are real. This idea is so small but a big deal is made about it. Sorry Supercell. I dont like talking about things like this on my favorite games but i have lately been disappointed. You really should look over the idea.

---

If troops that didn't die were still available I would be smashing noob bases with all dragons without spending any elixir on troops.
It's a terrible idea.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PhilISuppose

If troops that didn't die were still available I would be smashing noob bases with all dragons without spending any elixir on troops.
It's a terrible idea.

---

Thats how the game is anyways. If Boom Beach which is crated by Supercell can do this how come you can do it on here. I smash people on there and i get my troops back on that game. It just shows your stronger. Those that are attacked get a shield anyways so how would one attack affect them that much?

Here is an idea. Put some of the ideas that people have into the game for a period of time and see how they like it. See what others think of it. Dont just rule stuff out so fast. You wanted peoples ideas by making a forum for the game. Show them that your listening. Dont make permanent changes just temporary ideas. Its really that simpke to make your game even cooler. If you did this you know how much money id be spending on it. 100s.

Last heres the reason why im making a big deal about things like this. I am planning a game designer and if i made a forum to get peoples ideas i would be temporarily using the ideas to see what ones i would make permanent because taking ideas from people will show them that i am listening. Its like xbox games such as COD. How much money do they make becuase so many ideas are put into the game. Its what you do as a game designer. You take in ideas to make a better game.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Valkery710

Last heres the reason why im making a big deal about things like this. I am planning a game designer and if i made a forum to get peoples ideas i would be temporarily using the ideas to see what ones i would make permanent because taking ideas from people will show them that i am listening. Its like xbox games such as COD. How much money do they make becuase so many ideas are put into the game. Its what you do as a game designer. You take in ideas to make a better game.

---

You also have to think of this from a Company's standpoint. If we smash noob bases for no loss, how will that attract new players? that would discourage newer bases from starting thus less revenue in total for SC, also If we remake the Elixir from troops not dying, that would mean more elixir in our hands leading to less people gemming up resources.
If Supercell listened to everyone's suggestions, we would have gem collectors in every base making them lose money even faster

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Valkery710

Here is an idea. Put some of the ideas that people have into the game for a period of time and see how they like it.

---

Half the people would go crazy while a new idea is being tested and the other half would go crazy once its removed. There are some ideas I wished to be implemented but I'm in no way disappointed with Supercell that they arent. Hope you can enjoy Clash of Clans again, its a great (yet addicting) game!

This has nothing to do with gems. And if you look at the troops that die you have to rebuild them. How many troops die usually? So you will still have people using gems to build the troops they lost. See and another thing is i thought of an idea that was a 360 degree camera that you can zoom and rotate the screen. But that got ruled out and didnt even get looked at. You beed to think of peoples ideas like this. Make it a setting that you can change. But as i was saying youd still have people boosting resources such as gold. Finishing buildings. Upgradig troops. Finishing spells they have brewing. Its one little change. Make it a temporary change. See how people like it. I understand where your money comes from and you still have many things that people will be buying gems for. Just try it. For at least a month.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by StephenD

Half the people would go crazy while a new idea is being tested and the other half would go crazy once its removed. There are some ideas I wished to be implemented but I'm in no way disappointed with Supercell that they arent. Hope you can enjoy Clash of Clans again, its a great (yet addicting) game!

---

Im not entirely basing it off all of supercells games. Its this one. You have more people playing it than Boom Beach and Hay Day. Give people somethig to show for. I got 8 people playing COC in the last month. But if im gonna get people to play it... Then ideas that you requested for in the forum then take some of them and give something new to the game. New feels. It will end up like Myspace. People will get tired of the same old thing and stop playing. Maybe not anytime soon but in the future. Give the clashers some of peoples ideas and show them that you made the Ideas and Feature Requests for a reason. 99.9% of their requests arent given a chance.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Valkery710

This has nothing to do with gems. And if you look at the troops that die you have to rebuild them. How many troops die usually? So you will still have people using gems to build the troops they lost. See and another thing is i thought of an idea that was a 360 degree camera that you can zoom and rotate the screen. But that got ruled out and didnt even get looked at. You beed to think of peoples ideas like this. Make it a setting that you can change. But as i was saying youd still have people boosting resources such as gold. Finishing buildings. Upgradig troops. Finishing spells they have brewing. Its one little change. Make it a temporary change. See how people like it. I understand where your money comes from and you still have many things that people will be buying gems for. Just try it. For at least a month.

---

okay i see what you are saying, now about point with new players? Sub-200 would be filled with farmers smashing bases with GoWiPe or mass Drags and if we dont lose that Elixir/DE or the troops survive, then we could keep smashing lower level bases constantly

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HiFliya

okay i see what you are saying, now about point with new players? Sub-200 would be filled with farmers smashing bases with GoWiPe or mass Drags and if we dont lose that Elixir/DE or the troops survive, then we could keep smashing lower level bases constantly

---

Okay and see this is where another one of my ideas could in to play. I had a post that was about there being no point to xp and levels but you should make it to where when certain people reach a certain level that they cant go lower than a certain amount of trophies. People are going to attack lower bases by trophie dropping and that makes it unfair for those people. Base peoples trophies off their level so higher clashers arent dropping lower than those that as high as them and attacking lower leveled clashers than they are.

This game has flaws and something like this can be fixed. Making a way to get your troops back could be a really big hit in this game. Making certain leveled players to not he able to go lower than a certain amount of trophies can keep higher clashers from attacking new starters or lower clashers.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Valkery710

Thats how the game is anyways. If Boom Beach which is crated by Supercell can do this how come you can do it on here. I smash people on there and i get my troops back on that game. It just shows your stronger. Those that are attacked get a shield anyways so how would one attack affect them that much?

---

That's not 'how the game is anyway' you have no idea what you are talking about.

There's no point stomping on weak bases with 12 Level 4 dragons which cost 504,000 elixir.
But to use that army and it to cost NOTHING is just stupid.

BoomBeach is a completely different game with a completely different economy.
You might as well try to add features from HayDay or Destiny...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Valkery710

Im not entirely basing it off all of supercells games. Its this one. You have more people playing it than Boom Beach and Hay Day. Give people somethig to show for. I got 8 people playing COC in the last month. But if im gonna get people to play it... Then ideas that you requested for in the forum then take some of them and give something new to the game. New feels. It will end up like Myspace. People will get tired of the same old thing and stop playing. Maybe not anytime soon but in the future. Give the clashers some of peoples ideas and show them that you made the Ideas and Feature Requests for a reason. 99.9% of their requests arent given a chance.

---

They get bombarded with idea requests every day. The game would change too much and too fast if they implemented even half of what is suggested. They'd lose a lot more players that way than the number they lose by not implementing certain ideas.

This is the same with nearly all online or multiplayer games, a small percentage of ideas are implemented and the rest are ignored.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Valkery710

I feel that i am becoming very disappointed in this game. I almost want to stop playing. I feel that being unreal about some ideas such as troops that dont die, you dont get back or at least elixer back. It just seems unfair. I have spent to much time for nothing waiting for troops to raid and in the end loosing them for nothing. I feel this game doesnt deserve my time at some points when i could be spending it on things that are real. This idea is so small but a big deal is made about it. Sorry Supercell. I dont like talking about things like this on my favorite games but i have lately been disappointed. You really should look over the idea.

---

First of all the game has been like this forever and everybody goes through it at any level. Secondly, SC isnt going to change a thing because you quit. Thirdly, nobody is forcing you to play. Fourthly, be smart about your raids and not deploy all your troops mindlessly and maybe you can save some. This game isnt meant to be so easy where you can keep using troops that didnt die in battle. Strategically use as little as you can to save elixir and time

So guys... Take a look at some of the complaints on fb. Your losing players. I knew this was gonna happen but yet you do nothing to get them to keep their attention on the game.

Show your players that your listening. Otherwise people will stop playing and what happens in the end? You lose money.