Printable View
Dear designers, my clan mates and I think that would be very nice if when we attack in multiplayer games all the trops that stay alive could retransform in elixir to our storages. Thanks for read this and try to help us. Our clan is COPIAPO ESCOBAR, and my username is MUÑY.
Please read the sticky before posting ideas like this. It has already been ruled out by Supercell.
This idea is great. I feel that the producers are being to unreal about this game. It seems like they are saying everyone that goes to war dies.
Quote:
Originally Posted by NightDrawn
This idea has NOT been ruled out and is currently on supercells list of considered ideas, please refer to the sticky thanksQuote:
Originally Posted by NFriesen
I didn't say it was ruled out, it's in the "frequently requested" part.Quote:
Originally Posted by Figjam66
So you counter that by posting insulting spam, wow what a guy:rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by NFriesen
That is neither insulting or spam.Quote:
Originally Posted by Figjam66
If anything, what you posted was.
LOL! did you make this? or already had it?Quote:
Originally Posted by NFriesen
I'd argue that it is insulting since it suggests that it's silly and you're slapping OP for his ideaQuote:
Originally Posted by NFriesen
ruled out!
I'm going to start cracking down on people posting "read the sticky".
People seem to be using it as a means to increase their post count, and half the time the idea has not been ruled out anyway.
If it's ruled out or frequently requested, PLEASE DONT BUMP THE THREAD BY POSTING. Doing so makes no sense.
Report the thread to moderators if it is a ruled out idea and move on please.
Edit: reworded the second paragraph
THANK YOU, TINK :rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by Tinkerbell
OP, I like this idea, and would help out the Elixir "shortage" if you will because of the ability to upgrade walls with that resource now... +1
For clarification, does this mean that the idea sub forum is intended for SC staff to read ideas and judge whether it is good/bad only? The quote makes it seem like forumers shouldn't try providing even positive criticisms or point out why the idea doesn't workQuote:
Originally Posted by Tinkerbell
Not at all. I'm simply referring to people who mindlessly spam read the sticky, or make non constructive negative comments.Quote:
Originally Posted by Sirix
Saying you don't like the idea nicely, and explaining WHY is the way to go. :)
Those Boom Beach players...
They're everywhere!
On a serious note though, I don't think they should keep the living troops, instead they should give you a 50% elixir refund on them.
Thanks for the fast clarification.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tinkerbell
The refund idea seems doesn't seem bad now especially since elixir is now a scarce resource. It would also encourage people to use powerful troops in war since they will get a refund from the survivors
Also, I agree that keeping surviving troops alive is bad but don't think that OP wants surviving troops to be reused. He said that living troops will transform into elixir Cyber
Edit: Fixed wording
I think getting back the elixer but not the troops will prevent the spamming of dragons as people will have to re-train their troops. I can totally see the viability of this and it doesn't seem to unbalance the game (I don't play anymore but I have observed how quickly all the elixer went down the drain).Quote:
Originally Posted by Sirix
Bad idea. Use some strategy and thinking instead of mindlessly using all your troops. Or else people would just use max dragons and PEKKAs over and over and over again when they dont die. Heroes are the only ones that stay alive and it should be kept that way.Quote:
Originally Posted by camb1982
but only that one guy nfriesen was banned for it? what??Quote:
Originally Posted by Tinkerbell
ive seen a lot of people do it
I almost thought it was one of those terrible "Survived troops can be re-used" threads. Title was a bit misleading for me. ;)
But a refund for troops that are alive after a raid? I can live with that. It doesn't have to be a full refund though. Limit it to 50% or so (percentage of your refund could increase per earned star you get).
yeah 50% sound betterQuote:
Originally Posted by Senthu
Uhm, everything about the game is unrealistic....Quote:
Originally Posted by Valkery710
That's not what the idea is sayingQuote:
Originally Posted by Benson822175
It's probably a combination of timing and the slightly more hostile than average nature of the 'read the sticky' postQuote:
Originally Posted by 0100111001000110
Ok, all of you are currently getting extremely off topic.
This idea is extremely requested but I remember reading in the "Help and Support" section that they don't let this happen because of the strategy component of the game.
They want to let players try and make themselves the best by using the least troops as possible.
e.g
You have 125 archers and a dragon in your clan castle. You release the dragon and about 100 archers. You are left with 25 archers. Supercell wants you to use the least troops as possible to win as I had already stated
Thumbs DOWN. http://forum.supercell.net/images/icons/icon13.png
:rolleyes:
The section talks about returning alive. This is about returning elixirQuote:
Originally Posted by Joshokitty
I have a better idea! How about giving back the elixir based on how much health the troop has left?