Clan troops received

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bigtooth78

I will remember that. And MY OPINION is that this would be a great addition ( I always prefer more data / statistics at my disposal not less ) AND if I feel someone is negative (not mentioning any names) that is also MY OPINION. But thanks for the oh so helpful reminder.

---

I didnt argue with your opinion. I accept it. But when you tell people to ignore my posts...perhaps going a bit far?
I didnt argue with your opinion, so id like it if you didnt do so with mine.
As Tink said
'When you post ideas on this forum, not everyone will agree, that's ok because then you get an opportunity to discuss it.
Taking any comments with a different opinion personally, will become very tiring for you.
lets move on please.'

Theres no need to start a new argument. Its over.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MrH

I didnt argue with your opinion. I accept it. But when you tell people to ignore my posts...perhaps going a bit far?
I didnt argue with your opinion, so id like it if you didnt do so with mine.
As Tink said
'When you post ideas on this forum, not everyone will agree, that's ok because then you get an opportunity to discuss it.
Taking any comments with a different opinion personally, will become very tiring for you.
lets move on please.'

Theres no need to start a new argument. Its over.

---

For someone who wants to move on YOU KEEP REPLYING! Here's a peace offering... Don't reply to this one and move on. If you choose to reply it will suggest to me you want to keep chatting. There's my olive branch. And for the record the only feedback you gave to this post is the counter is not needed. But again is not having more statistics better? Why would you not want more counters and stats?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bigtooth78

For someone who wants to move on YOU KEEP REPLYING! Here's a peace offering... Don't reply to this one and move on. If you choose to reply it will suggest to me you want to keep chatting. There's my olive branch. And for the record the only feedback you gave to this post is the counter is not needed. But again is not having more statistics better? Why would you not want more counters and stats?

---

You ask me not to reply and ask me 2 questions.

I replied to you because you just replied to me.

Yes the feedback i gave is that 'it is not needed'. that is my feedback. Hopefully thats ok with you.

And i dont think it would be a good idea, as SOME people might be self-conscious about requesting as everyone seems to think that requesting lots is a bad idea. That is my opinion, so thank you for your 'for the record'. consider it recorded.

So my second olive branch is now. i havent asked you any questions and so there is no need for you to reply now.

Time to stop spamming this thread.

-H

No. If a person donates actively, why should it matter how much they request? This would do nothing but make people afraid to request, thereby weakening their defense. Not only this, but an active player donates as well as requests on a regular basis. This would be essentially punishing high activity.
Let's say I'm in your clan. I donated 750 the past week, but I received 1500. Does this make me a mooch? Apparently so. If the player in question donates actively, you should be happy to give back.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Baconman

No. If a person donates actively, why should it matter how much they request? This would do nothing but make people afraid to request, thereby weakening their defense. Not only this, but an active player donates as well as requests on a regular basis. This would be essentially punishing high activity.
Let's say I'm in your clan. I donated 750 the past week, but I received 1500. Does this make me a mooch? Apparently so. If the player in question donates actively, you should be happy to give back.

---

I couldnt agree more.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Baconman

No. If a person donates actively, why should it matter how much they request? This would do nothing but make people afraid to request, thereby weakening their defense. Not only this, but an active player donates as well as requests on a regular basis. This would be essentially punishing high activity.
Let's say I'm in your clan. I donated 750 the past week, but I received 1500. Does this make me a mooch? Apparently so. If the player in question donates actively, you should be happy to give back.

---

Again I would prefer the data. Every decision and circumstance is different but more data helps with informed decisions period. If someone is always requesting and only donating a few troops in comparison then yes I would say they are a mooch albeit an active one. If people would be afraid to request perhaps that speaks more to the tone of their clan rather than the effect of a counter. Again I want as many stats as possible.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MrH

You ask me not to reply and ask me 2 questions.

I replied to you because you just replied to me.

Yes the feedback i gave is that 'it is not needed'. that is my feedback. Hopefully thats ok with you.

And i dont think it would be a good idea, as SOME people might be self-conscious about requesting as everyone seems to think that requesting lots is a bad idea. That is my opinion, so thank you for your 'for the record'. consider it recorded.

So my second olive branch is now. i havent asked you any questions and so there is no need for you to reply now.

Time to stop spamming this thread.

-H

---

Again if one wants to end a discussion walk away rather than trying to squeeze in the last word with another reply.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bigtooth78

Again if one wants to end a discussion walk away rather than trying to squeeze in the last word with another reply.

---

It doesnt matter if he replies back. You reply back to him as he does to you, so why do you tell him to drop the issue when you yourself are still replying to him? your expecting him to just sit there and keep his mouth shut like an obedient little boy. Noone wants to be silenced, they will speak their mind. I definitely like to speak my mind and i will certainly keep a topic going if the person talking to me is being ignorant as you are. With that being said, both your opinions are just fine. You prefer statistics, we prefer not stressing out the clan. Thats that.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cristian

It doesnt matter if he replies back. You reply back to him as he does to you, so why do you tell him to drop the issue when you yourself are still replying to him? your expecting him to just sit there and keep his mouth shut like an obedient little boy. Noone wants to be silenced, they will speak their mind. I definitely like to speak my mind and i will certainly keep a topic going if the person talking to me is being ignorant as you are. With that being said, both your opinions are just fine. You prefer statistics, we prefer not stressing out the clan. Thats that.

---

Lol then he replies with a meanigless one word line...but like i said i dont wanna spam this thread anymore and i actually hope the mods close it to stop him dragging the argument on and on and on...although that would be unfair on the creator. and i am replying to cristian not to bigtooth here.

No.

In the clan I am in, some people donate dragons, wizards, really fancy stuff in general. Others just donate archers and normal troops.

It would make the environment really stressful for those who get the high level troops.