Clan Wars attacks on already starred bases

I was a good little girl and tried several advanced search terms and even leafed through several of the most recent posts to double check myself, and did not find this suggestion on the ruled out list. But, if I messed up and this suggestion is out in the forum somewhere, I profusely apologize.

I'm not technologically advanced so I won't have pictures either like some of the awesome people on here have.

On to the actual topic of interest:

Every war I have participated in, I see at least one person do this. In the war I am in two people did it to the same base: They attacked a base that had already been attacked, and that original attack achieved the max of three stars. I am annoyed first of all that people aren't reading up, researching, or youtubing how clan wars work, or even asking in the clan chat for that matter. I try and send out clan mail to exhort members not to attack bases that have already been three starred and to please try and attack bases that have no stars over ones that have one or two. This precaution just does not seem to work - perhaps it's a language barrier, or people don't read their clan mail, or I don't know what.

I think the solution to this would be that once a war base has been three starred, that base can no longer be attacked. When scouting or looking at it, the "attack!" button should be grey, and if someone tries to click it, a red message could pop up saying "This base already has been attacked for maximum stars".

In addition to this war feature, bases that have been one or two starred should have a verify message when clicking the "attack!" button that reads something like: "This base has been attacked and your clan has received 2 stars, if you attack you can only get 1 more star from this base. Are you sure you want to attack?" (same message for one star, but saying you can get a max of 2 stars from this base) with the option in that window to "accept" or "cancel".

Simple....Establish the clan rules, i.e. no TH sniping at war, your attack strategy - who attacks who, expectation for each attack, ie minimum expect 2 stars from an attack.....Anyone infringes these rules, kick them...simple

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mesla23

I was a good little girl and tried several advanced search terms and even leafed through several of the most recent posts to double check myself, and did not find this suggestion on the ruled out list. But, if I messed up and this suggestion is out in the forum somewhere, I profusely apologize.

I'm not technologically advanced so I won't have pictures either like some of the awesome people on here have.

On to the actual topic of interest:

Every war I have participated in, I see at least one person do this. In the war I am in two people did it to the same base: They attacked a base that had already been attacked, and that original attack achieved the max of three stars. I am annoyed first of all that people aren't reading up, researching, or youtubing how clan wars work, or even asking in the clan chat for that matter. I try and send out clan mail to exhort members not to attack bases that have already been three starred and to please try and attack bases that have no stars over ones that have one or two. This precaution just does not seem to work - perhaps it's a language barrier, or people don't read their clan mail, or I don't know what.

I think the solution to this would be that once a war base has been three starred, that base can no longer be attacked. When scouting or looking at it, the "attack!" button should be grey, and if someone tries to click it, a red message could pop up saying "This base already has been attacked for maximum stars".

In addition to this war feature, bases that have been one or two starred should have a verify message when clicking the "attack!" button that reads something like: "This base has been attacked and your clan has received 2 stars, if you attack you can only get 1 more star from this base. Are you sure you want to attack?" (same message for one star, but saying you can get a max of 2 stars from this base) with the option in that window to "accept" or "cancel".

---

Most people will attack three starred bases purely for the war loot, if they feel comfortable that your clan is winning the war they will loot to their own pleasure. I do believe that they already have warning messages for attacking war bases that have 2-3 stars.

Firstly welcome to the forums. Secondly be firm, tough, and stand your ground that's what make a good leader do this simple tips and they will follow you but don't be too mean or they will leave you. And establish rules and say "I will not tolarate who break this rules" this is to create order in a clan without order you're clan will crumbled trust me rule it what make things in checks. Additional tip: people like good clan but they prefer mature clan so try to establish command on all your member. Remember with great power comes great responsibility so don't abuse your power you have to learn when to be nice and when to be firm/tough

By blocking available bases to attack in war, that is the three stared bases, you are blocking a winning clans, or the losing clan for that matter, ability to gain maximum war loot.

I do understand your issue, however, this should be a responsibility of clan management rather than an implimented feature. As hard as it may be for some to kick members, keep in mind that those members who are blatantly breaking clan rules, are thinking only of themselves.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HiFliya

Most people will attack three starred bases purely for the war loot, if they feel comfortable that your clan is winning the war they will loot to their own pleasure. I do believe that they already have warning messages for attacking war bases that have 2-3 stars.

---

I wasn't sure on the message for 2-3 star bases as I haven't had to attack one of those bases in a long time - guess I should have looked into that first - so thanks! This is happening pretty early on in the war where it's anybody's game still. If it was happening towards the end of the war and we were well in the lead I wouldn't care. But still, there are plenty of bases to choose from and secure your loot - on the wars with more people. I can understand that logic for say a 15 person or less war. Would you have any ideas on modifications for my idea on the 3 star base?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mesla23

I was a good little girl and tried several advanced search terms and even leafed through several of the most recent posts to double check myself, and did not find this suggestion on the ruled out list. But, if I messed up and this suggestion is out in the forum somewhere, I profusely apologize.

I'm not technologically advanced so I won't have pictures either like some of the awesome people on here have.

On to the actual topic of interest:

Every war I have participated in, I see at least one person do this. In the war I am in two people did it to the same base: They attacked a base that had already been attacked, and that original attack achieved the max of three stars. I am annoyed first of all that people aren't reading up, researching, or youtubing how clan wars work, or even asking in the clan chat for that matter. I try and send out clan mail to exhort members not to attack bases that have already been three starred and to please try and attack bases that have no stars over ones that have one or two. This precaution just does not seem to work - perhaps it's a language barrier, or people don't read their clan mail, or I don't know what.

I think the solution to this would be that once a war base has been three starred, that base can no longer be attacked. When scouting or looking at it, the "attack!" button should be grey, and if someone tries to click it, a red message could pop up saying "This base already has been attacked for maximum stars".

In addition to this war feature, bases that have been one or two starred should have a verify message when clicking the "attack!" button that reads something like: "This base has been attacked and your clan has received 2 stars, if you attack you can only get 1 more star from this base. Are you sure you want to attack?" (same message for one star, but saying you can get a max of 2 stars from this base) with the option in that window to "accept" or "cancel".

---

Your idea will ruin loot raids in wars.
When my clan (Shæferman) confident that weve definitely won a war, you are allowed to do loot raids.
So you would attack the base with easiest win and best loot bonus to just get 1 star for the war loot.
If the clans language is stopping you from telling the others, you should join a clan of your same language.
Also I think when people are attacking already defeated bases, a warning message pops up and tells you so this shouldnt be happening.

If your clan doesn't know how war works, then just join one that does.

For example: My clan has won 72 wars atm (September 20 2014). We never lose; but if anyone knows the name of a clan that has more wins, PLEASE LET ME KNOW!

if this is your clan then add clan rules and enforce them by kicking clan members, if it isnt your clan then join another that enforces the rules.

Kick them. If they refuse to listen, then it's their fault. It even says you won't gain any stars for attacking 3 starred bases. It doesn't even require a warning. Just common sense.

If all opposition bases have been 3 starred whats the point of not allowing playes the chance to loot. Also if opposition number 1 has 3 stars left.. your number 30 would just be cannon fodder, so poinless him attacking.... unless wanting just give others a chance to see where defences are