Penalties for people leaving clan during Clan Wars

Everybody has had problems with people leaving the clan during clan wars. The cooldown timer just isnt enough to deter people leaving the clan during wars which puts the clan at a big disadvantage. Here are some idea's to impose on people that choose to leave the clan during clan wars.

1. Impose a loot penalty for 72 hours. i.e. 20% penalty on all raids during the 72 hour period.

2. Make the individual unable to join another clan for 72 hours

3. Make the leave button unavailable during war.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Leotidus

Everybody has had problems with people leaving the clan during clan wars. The cooldown timer just isnt enough to deter people leaving the clan during wars which puts the clan at a big disadvantage. Here are some idea's to impose on people that choose to leave the clan during clan wars.

1. Impose a loot penalty for 72 hours. i.e. 20% penalty on all raids during the 72 hour period.

2. Make the individual unable to join another clan for 72 hours

3. Make the leave button unavailable during war.

---

I think the number 3 is a good idea! :D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Leotidus

Everybody has had problems with people leaving the clan during clan wars. The cooldown timer just isnt enough to deter people leaving the clan during wars which puts the clan at a big disadvantage. Here are some idea's to impose on people that choose to leave the clan during clan wars.

1. Impose a loot penalty for 72 hours. i.e. 20% penalty on all raids during the 72 hour period.

2. Make the individual unable to join another clan for 72 hours

3. Make the leave button unavailable during war.

---

I do agre, no 3 is a good idea but does not force to attack .

Not good ideas, loot penelty is just rude, and not allowing you to leave will make problems happen, people will start another war soomn after, and people that want to leave cant leave.....

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Leotidus

Everybody has had problems with people leaving the clan during clan wars. The cooldown timer just isnt enough to deter people leaving the clan during wars which puts the clan at a big disadvantage. Here are some idea's to impose on people that choose to leave the clan during clan wars.

1. Impose a loot penalty for 72 hours. i.e. 20% penalty on all raids during the 72 hour period.

2. Make the individual unable to join another clan for 72 hours

3. Make the leave button unavailable during war.

---

This makes war a way to trap people in a clan. Basically, if I visit a clan but then they start war, I'm stuck in that clan because of these.

Being counted in an leaving during a war without attacking first is definitely an ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ move, and in many clans is considered about the biggest offense there is.

Personally, I'd like to see a longer cooldown period than just the duration of the war, but as people said you can't force anyone to attack.

Really the only thing you can do is be selective in who you let into your clan. Supercell will never go for any sort of penalty, badge that says deserter. If there were a way to see their former clan, and see that clan's war map to see if they attacked, you might have something, but that's about it.

I disagree with any hostage penalties since it would cause people to spam, misdonate, and cause other problems. Besides, there are people who would hop from a small group of clans to visit their friends so after they're done attacking, why should they have to stay? Also SC doesn't want to make complicate exceptions and stuff like that

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by awesomness2016

Being counted in an leaving during a war without attacking first is definitely an ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ move, and in many clans is considered about the biggest offense there is.

---

TH sniping is worse in my eyes because not only are they not helping out, they're leeching

I think number 2 - we had three guys in the last clash off who left during prep day i wasted an hour trying to convince them to come back it was such a waste of my time.

I don't think you can or would want to lock them in but yeah prevent them from hopping to another clan for a bit I like that

This is one of the reasons why I kept my clan exclusively for my friends, and sometimes friends of friends. To prevent clan hoppers. I think no 1 is a little too harsh, but 2 and 3 makes a lot of sense.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Fernie

This is one of the reasons why I kept my clan exclusively for my friends, and sometimes friends of friends. To prevent clan hoppers. I think no 1 is a little too harsh, but 2 and 3 makes a lot of sense.

---

#3 will make people want to do terrible or snipe TH in war so that they get kicked out