Printable View
You know how the clan castle levels 4 and 5 have a ladder or steps? Well I thought if you had a range unit in your castle, why doesn't it climb to the top and shoot like a wizard or archer tower? I can't see why the steps are there at the moment and this would be simple and bring some use to them. The unit would die when the castle was smashed.
That is quite an ingenious idea, and I suppose melee troops would come out as usual? Also what troops would be ranged?
Archers and wizards are ranged, and yes melee troops would come out as normal. Thanks for the good reply!
Love the idea man! Such an awesome thought! Keep up the good work!
please check out my thread on clan improvement!
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...an-Improvement
Bumpety bump bump
I agree with the conceptQuote:
Originally Posted by Mantarians
Thank you for the positive reviews.
I like the idea as what happen is archers come out get smashed giants come out after them and I fell like throwing my iPad across the room
Cool idea!
keep up the good work!
Happy Clashing!
Thank you all :)
Thank you for all the support.
No need to say thx twice in a row. Try not to bump it any more ive seen it 3 times already now.Quote:
Originally Posted by Mantarians
Ik im bumping it saying this but it was already at the top, before anyone says im bumping it.
You are bumping, and anyway if you come onto the thread you may as well reply to what the thread is about! (I'm really not bumping this time!)
I really like it. The only thing is the big clan shield in the way haha. Very good idea! Many new strategies would come into play if this were implemented into the game.
What did the green arrow mean, next to your name?Quote:
Originally Posted by Darvesque
Not bumping Mr. H, asking a question
The stairs are just graphics
Oh, sorry, didn't know.Quote:
Originally Posted by roasteddragonleader
naa man it would be too op
Quote:
Originally Posted by Monferno01
Can you say how? You're the only person who doesn't like it and I can't see how.
Has anyone got any ideas to add on to this?
I think that's a really good idea and I hope they put it in the new update.
Also if there was more than one archer or wizard or something would they all go to the top or would you have to upgrade your clan castle for more to go to the top.
That's a great idea that would give a reason to a currently pointless feature
I was just thinking the same thing! Thank you for making this topic :)
I really think it is a good idea. It makes extra choice for those who donate troops. Some may want ground moving troops to fight back attacking troops while other may want to defending troops on the castle depending on their village layout.
The graphic of the roofs of clan castle and townhall really makes me imagin how cool it is to see some characters on top of it!
P.S. the range of the shooter on top of the castle should be shorter than archer tower(if the shooter is an archer) and wizard tower(if the shooter is a wizard) I think.
Otherwise defence would be too strong in my opinion.
At level 4 clan castle maybe 10 troop capacity, maybe 15-20 at level 5. Do you agree? I'm not quite sure. I think this would be ok. Please say if you can think of anything better.Quote:
Originally Posted by Spudboywizz
Exactly what I was thinking when I started this thread, thank you for all the support everyone!Quote:
Originally Posted by Naortapec
The idea is good.....the balance would be very delicate though.
The CC is already the building that causes the most trouble for me when im attacking...having ranged troops on top would make it even harder.
But if there is perhaps 1 archer at lvl 1, 2 at lvl 2, 3 at lvl 3, 4 at lvl 4, 5 at lvl 5 and 6 at lvl 6, i would like it.
But to get top the archers/wizards they would have to destroy the castle. And a lvl 5 castle has the same hitpoints as a lvl 7 wall. So if u have 5 archers shooting, with 2500 health protecting them...that would be dangerous for the attacker.
Perhaps they can be shot at as well? so if ur attacking a castle, u lure out the troops, kill them, then when ur archers are within range of the castle u can shoot at the archers at the top while they shoot at you?
And what range would the archers have? I suggest 5 as theyre higher up than normal archers.
I like the idea :)
I like it, but would it only be for clan castle levels 4 and 5?
This would be very hard to balance for supercell. In a lvl 5 cc, if someone has 7 lvl 5 wiz, that will make a tower with 3000hp 1190 dps and it even does small splash way too overpowered. That is why I believe supercell will not try to buff the cc or at least not in this manner.
I think it would be easily controlled by limiting housing space on top of the roof.Quote:
Originally Posted by cdp98us
Let's say level 1 clan castle has only one housing space on the roof.
Hence only one archer can be there.
Level 4 clan castle has 4 housing space so then you have choice of either 4 archers or 1 wizard.
This can work for townhall roof too.
Level 7 townhall has a tiny tower on the roof so only one archer can be there.
Level 8 can have 2, and level 9 can have 3.
In other words, no wizard can defend townhall. At least until they release level 10 townhall.
Also, if they make flying units and shooting units able to damage defending troops on the roof, that would be more even, because there will be only limited amount of defending troops.
What do you think about this guys?
I don't think th defense would work, unless it has a deploy range of only a few tiles. As for the cc, I think it should be limited to 1 arch on top for 4 and 2 for 5 with the arch still being affected by lightning spell and attacks of ranged units. If cc is destroyed the arch is destroyed regardless. This would make a tower that does 44 dps and has 3000 hp which I think is very reasonable.Quote:
Originally Posted by Naortapec
I forgot to add that the deploy range of the troops on top should be the same, but their range would be 5, therefore limiting the effectiveness of the tower and just making it a cool, small game change that'll allow top players to have to use skill and help active lower lvled ppl.Quote:
Originally Posted by cdp98us
Maybe 2 troop capacity at cc 4 and 4 at cc 5. Which means you could hold 4 archers or a wiz.
Im pretty sure SC has thought of this before they just dont wanna release all the good ideas in one update, since they only have a few..
Brilliant idea but how many archers will be able to clone to the top of the clan castle
AWESOME, thanks a lot for this!Quote:
Originally Posted by ivanmostdope
Mentioned above, :)Quote:
Originally Posted by ivanmostdope
can the ranged units be shot by ranged units too?
Personally I think the wizard should still leave the castle like a melee troop because it seems overpowered against infantry, in fact probably even more powerful than a wizard tower due to the fact the wizard now has splash damage and does similar damage to a wizard tower, also you mustn't forget that the clan castle has a very high health making it stronger than a wizard tower.
I think so, does anyone else agree?Quote:
Originally Posted by UnicornzFTW
Yes, maybe you could have 2 troop capacity at level 4 cc, 3 at level 5. This would mean wizards couldn't come on. Only archers.Quote:
Originally Posted by Derskull
Does a mod have any suggestions?
Love the idea. Only caveat to that would be that ranged attacking units should be able to target ranged units on the clan castle without having to destroy the clan castle first.
That's what'll happen.Quote:
Originally Posted by BadCookies
Anyone else?
I have image.
Is there any advice you could give me❓
Agreed :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Mantarians
Definetely
The only problem is with the new witch unit... Well she is ranged so if she climbed up there and skeletons kept pouring out of the CC then it would be more OP then ever imaginable
I like it would like to see it the update
Gregory1
You're forgetting about witches, aren't you? They're ranged too :P
this thread was started 3 months ago and the witches weren't out and anyways why did someone reply to a 3 month old thread.
When I upgraded my clan castle to lvl 4 I thought that would be a feature. Love the idea
Love the idea, and maybe once the clan castle gets destroyed the ranged troops come out like normal?
-Sam