Printable View
No you donate well. I've seen your clan, very nice. But I wasn't referring to you, how could I when I don't know anything about you, I was referring to my clan mates. This idea would put a stop to their arguments that they have donated a lot, when they have asked for far more. I don't think the idea is absurd. If troop donations are logged according to housing space then why can't troops received be logged in the same manner?Quote:
Originally Posted by XenapZ
is already in the sticky,
but i don't like the idea,
because i have a lvl 4 cc and other members have a lvl 1 cc
so if i ask i can get 25 troops others can only get 10-15-20-25 troops each time
if you have less time to play and you are just 2 time a day online and every time you want to donate and there are not many who can ask, you get more then you give.
is it your fault?
no but players see that and think I won't give him anything anymore because he takes way more then he gives.
also if i donate a dragon it count as 20 but it takes way more time to create.
so a dragon says 20 but the time it needs to create is time you can't make your own troops you use for attacking.
Well i was the only one not agreeing and you did post right after me so it looked like you where referring to me.Quote:
Originally Posted by Kep
But anyway, dont you see how wrong it would look if one guy donates archers all the time but mostly recieves giants?
He would have a really hard time keeping his ratio and people would think less of him even if he where the biggest donator in the clan quantitywise.
Sorry about that, yes did look that way.Quote:
Originally Posted by XenapZ
wouldn't clan members get wind of the fact that some members donate good troops and others not so good? I donate different troops to different members (sometimes out of specific requests and sometimes out of a thank you). Someone gives me a dragon and I give him one back, but on the whole I give archers cos they're what I prefer to receive myself. Giants are useless in defence, far too slow! By the time they reach the attacker they are shot at themselves by archers. Still don't see why it's a bad idea. You could argue then that troop donation tallies are pointless as they don't show type of troops given either. Isn't it up to the individual what they wish to give?
anyhow I don't wish to argue, I was only agreeing with the original idea.
How about another column showing the difference in troops requested and received!!
No the donation tallies are not useless because even if they dont show the quantity you can still see that a person is active if he has 1000+ donations.