Printable View
It is great to see how much members of your clan have been donating, but it would be very helpful to also see how much troops they have received from others. It would certainly make it a lot clearer to see which members are really mooching off of their clan companions.
I personally donīt mind if people donate less than others, but only if they donīt request a lot either.
i agree with this ! please Supercell !
Would be a good stats to see.
Very much agree. i donate loads but only use cc troops for defence, so hardly request. It would be a much neededd stat.
This would be great!
I think this feature would be valuable to asses the way clan members are working together and see who is just mooching
Donations, standing alone, convey an incomplete picture.
Compare two players: one gives 300 troops every 2 weeks and asks/receives 50. The second gives 400 troops but asks/receives 800. Number two 'looks' better at first blush, but is actually sucking clan resources disproportionately. As a clan leader, I'd loved to see who is taking more than they get. Lot's of players wonder if so-and-so is a mooch... real figures would put that to rest.
Ompus, Leader, Clan Maudite
Well if the first one gives giants and the second one gives archers then that statement falls appart.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ompus
The only way this would work would be if you got 1 donation per troop which i dont think would work either, leave it alone.
I think the idea is great, and anyone who doesn't agree -well maybe they're in the camp where they ask more than they give. I'm happy to donate troops but I'd really like to receive some back too!! And if clan members can see that they haven't given as many as they think they have then maybe they'll think about donating some more
Dude, go to d.i.g j.a.m and check my donations and see if you think im one if them.Quote:
Originally Posted by Kep
The idea is ridiculous, read my previous post and youll see why.