Clan Wars Donations: Not The Normal Version

I believe that we should get some XP for donating, kind of as an incentive. However, then this would allow for players to fill the war requests with giants and then continue to do this to increase level.

When you click donate, it comes up with the green panel with the troops. My idea is that the player who requests can cross out the troops they don't want. They can pick the troops that they do not want in the CC and a red line comes across preventing the donator from donating unwanted troops. Then there can be a level limit. There will be three available choices, lv1+, lv3+ and lv5+ to prevent the request asking for only maxed troops.

This will include the incentive to donate, but also keep the requests as people want it. This also does not screw up the donation for XP system.

Thanks for listening to my idea, would like to here your thoughts of my first idea.