Healers

Hello

Another 'feature' that bugs me.......

If I win a battle using healers and I have time left on the battle clock, rather than having the heroes go back to my camp injured, I would prefer the remaining time is still used by the healers - especially to heal the heroes that are alive but injured. This could either happen on screen or logically behind the scenes.

SC could calculate the remaining time and work out how much the healers could have healed my heroes and then return them back to the camp either partially or fully healed, depending on 5 things :

1) how injured the heroes were,
2) the time remaining,
3) the number of healers,
4) the time taken to travel from their current position to the hero, and
5) the level of the healer(s)

It would be a simple mathematical equation and as I mentioned earlier, this could either be on-screen (with the timer counting down which the user could elect to forego by clicking 'end battle') or applied behind the scenes.

Thoughts?

Clash on!

That sounds pretty fair idea to me.

I totally support it !

It's overpowered.

It allows for heroes to be used too frequently in the game.

At TH10 with 240 troops, one could afford to just make an extra healer, hold onto to it, then finally deploy it just before 100% destruction on a premie base, which usually happens near the 2-2.25 minute mark. That's a lot of time for a healer to heal one or both heroes, you'd basically never have them resting unless they died in battle with a lvl4 healer healing them for 45 seconds.

People often boost their heroes to keep them healed up and ready to go for the next raid, but what you are proposing here would likely eat away at SC's gem profits since people will not need to boost heroes nearly as often.

It's a great implementation for the players, but I doubt it'll fly with the SC staff.

I disagree it is overpowered given there are ways and means of doing it. The healer could continue to work on other troops until they are first healed for instance. There could be a limit beyond which a healer cannot be deployed as another example. I don't get why the remaining time cannot be used, effectively penalising an attacker. There are many other ways players game things so that in itself should not be a reason to not do it, plus there is always a cost of any such 'gaming the system', which in this case would be less troops available for an attack.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by hawdog

It's overpowered.

It allows for heroes to be used too frequently in the game.

At TH10 with 240 troops, one could afford to just make an extra healer, hold onto to it, then finally deploy it just before 100% destruction on a premie base, which usually happens near the 2-2.25 minute mark. That's a lot of time for a healer to heal one or both heroes, you'd basically never have them resting unless they died in battle with a lvl4 healer healing them for 45 seconds.

People often boost their heroes to keep them healed up and ready to go for the next raid, but what you are proposing here would likely eat away at SC's gem profits since people will not need to boost heroes nearly as often.

It's a great implementation for the players, but I doubt it'll fly with the SC staff.

---

Maybe make it only apply if the hero is not knocked unconscious. Once he/she is down, they are down. That would create some strategy.

But I agree that SC is not going to be jumping on this for their own reasons. We can talk it through for the fun of it, but its not gonna happen.

I actually hate the fact that you can't heal a Hero from being dizzy/unconcious. And please don't be the person to tell me that this is going to be overpowered...reasons why is because we all know the Hero alone can't 3 star a base (a base relative in strength to your own base) even with 5max heal spells, a player normally has at least 2 different spells on them for their different purposes in battle meaning less likely to heal a Hero completely, would also depend on the Hero's level of course and even with max heal spells they only heal a Hero at a rate of 50% of what a normal troop would be healed, and if you are having to heal your Hero then he is in the midst of battle and is likely still receiving damage from defense towers that are still in play, and if the clock is still going and a player's Hero gets downed on the conplete other side of the base where your troops are still advancing forward and you think I'm going to heal my Hero now since no defense towers are near to hurt him as soon as you put the heal spell on him he's gonna start walking away to go attack something..essentially leaving the heal circle. So there, not overpowered!! I'm sure I didn't even think of everything either.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Champion

I actually hate the fact that you can't heal a Hero from being dizzy/unconcious. And please don't be the person to tell me that this is going to be overpowered...reasons why is because we all know the Hero alone can't 3 star a base (a base relative in strength to your own base) even with 5max heal spells, a player normally has at least 2 different spells on them for their different purposes in battle meaning less likely to heal a Hero completely, would also depend on the Hero's level of course and even with max heal spells they only heal a Hero at a rate of 50% of what a normal troop would be healed, and if you are having to heal your Hero then he is in the midst of battle and is likely still receiving damage from defense towers that are still in play, and if the clock is still going and a player's Hero gets downed on the conplete other side of the base where your troops are still advancing forward and you think I'm going to heal my Hero now since no defense towers are near to hurt him as soon as you put the heal spell on him he's gonna start walking away to go attack something..essentially leaving the heal circle. So there, not overpowered!! I'm sure I didn't even think of everything either.

---

I'm sorry I'm gonna say it is OP. You shouldn't be able to bring a hero back from the being knocked out. You can't bring troops back so why should you be able to bring back heroes. Once a hero is dead it is dead. If you could do this you would get a lot more complaints than people actually liking the idea.

Its the the same as the OP said yes it is a good idea but it would allow heroes to be used too often. And like someone said earlier people would just train a hero and drop so they would never have to wait for the hero again. There is a reason they have to regenerate. It's so they can't be used to often.

So tell me what constitutes as 'being used too often' please. I can gem my hero to be healed and only deploy them at the 2 or 2 1/2 minute mark in my attack. You know what the difference is there though? I used gems, that is all. Seriously I think some people are on here just to say its not a good idea because they want to be one out of possibly 100 people who would like the idea. Or some people are on here that don't like an idea all because they didn't think of it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Champion

Or some people are on here that don't like an idea all because they didn't think of it.

---

Yep, agree 100%