Clan Traitor TAG - CoC HELP FIX THIS PROBLEM

Please fix the people that leave during wars after joining a clan. How about adding a "CLAN TRAITOR" Tag/symbol above there name for 48 hours. This can only only be removed during the 48 hours from a Co-leader or above.
Attachment 62093

Maybe you can add the option for a friendly approval to leave a clan during a war also. Of course they have the option to leave anyways and receive the TRAITOR tag for 48 hours.

Its getting real old trusting someone into your clan and they leave just after you start a war!

CoC... I ASK YOUR HELP TO MAYBE SWAY PEOPLE FROM DOING IT.
Maybe even a penalty also so people just don't do it to get the tag.

The♥♥♥♥

SC has been very clear that they will never provide any negative feedback/mark/tag/symbol/status/tattoo/etc. to any player/account that is visible to other players regardless of what it is called.

Besides, why would you want to force somebody to stay in your clan when they don't want to be there? They will just be disruptive in chat, donate stuff you don't want, and whatever else they do to irritate you until they are allowed to leave with no penalty. Far worse than just letting them go.

I have had members go over to a clan after a war to either recruit active members or have had ghosting clans invite us to discuss the tactic and then some have started a war locking the visitor out of home war. Or I've visited a friends clan and got stuck in their war. When this happens if i dont like the people or clan i leave. The only label needed is the ineligible for war notification.

I'd rather see something identifying traitors from the opposing clan during war, to stop spies. But i guess that is acceptable the same as ghosting (for those without honor). All creative use of game mechanics.

Seriously though.....

We just had a war were seven people left after getting war troops. I'm noticing this starting to be a bigger form of hoppers. They join your clan, wait for war, get high level troops to attack then they leave. You can't just give them troops you don't want/need as this is a war.

I keep saying it and I firmly stick to my guns....

You leave the clan, you clan castle gets emptied. You can't take them with you if you leave. period.

I myself would really like to see some sort of penalty for leaving during and active war. It's really hurting clans and gives the other clan a significant advantage.

I hate it as much as everyone. And I agree the war hopper tactic is becoming more prevalent. But I don't think Supercell should create such a flag.

One possibility would be that instead of their war timer being a restriction against joining other wars it prevents them from any other clans at all. But I must confess that is off the cuff without a lot of thinking through. I bet some guys could post problems with it.

Instead of a negative could they add counters for wars entered? A person that has entered many but their War Hero numbers is low would be a warning sign. Not sure if that is good or not either.

I like the idea (will never happen, just fun thought) of if anyone leaves during war the other clan members can target him directly for raids for one week after. (pummel that bum)

My overall thought is that Supercell might sympathize with the problem, but this one they will need to leave alone.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rwelshjr

I hate it as much as everyone. And I agree the war hopper tactic is becoming more prevalent. But I don't think Supercell should create such a flag.

One possibility would be that instead of their war timer being a restriction against joining other wars it prevents them from any other clans at all. But I must confess that is off the cuff without a lot of thinking through. I bet some guys could post problems with it.

Instead of a negative could they add counters for wars entered? A person that has entered many but their War Hero numbers is low would be a warning sign. Not sure if that is good or not either.

I like the idea (will never happen, just fun thought) of if anyone leaves during war the other clan members can target him directly for raids for one week after. (pummel that bum)

My overall thought is that Supercell might sympathize with the problem, but this one they will need to leave alone.

---

PUMMEL THE BUM would be fun!! Vote yes on that one!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by iceageg

SC has been very clear that they will never provide any negative feedback/mark/tag/symbol/status/tattoo/etc. to any player/account that is visible to other players regardless of what it is called.

Besides, why would you want to force somebody to stay in your clan when they don't want to be there? They will just be disruptive in chat, donate stuff you don't want, and whatever else they do to irritate you until they are allowed to leave with no penalty. Far worse than just letting them go.

---

The point Iceageg is that SC needs to do something.. clan hoppers are doing this more often and it's screwing up the game. There are way to many clans because everyone wants to be a stupid leader like you get some sort of extra points of rewards. This game has many flaws and if they have people screwing up the clan war aspect(the best part of the game) then they need to fix it! Do I think they would add a flag.. Of course not. I expect them to read this as much as there customer support handles problems in the game--- ZERO %!

Nope sorry sc shouldnt have to hold your hand to better your clan. Manage your clan better, dont accept new people right before war. If they stay for a few days, they probably wont leave during war. Dont have a bunch of people join, so one or two people leaving isnt that big of a deal.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ayyyyyema

Nope sorry sc shouldnt have to hold your hand to better your clan. Manage your clan better, dont accept new people right before war. If they stay for a few days, they probably wont leave during war. Dont have a bunch of people join, so one or two people leaving isnt that big of a deal.

---

Hold my hand? What.. It's there game.. They added it and they need to prevent people from abusing the system.. Is it ok to ♥♥♥♥? Is it ok to lie ♥♥♥♥♥ steal? Is it ok to have an alt base to join a clan and see bombs.. Where is the line I. The sand? I bet if your noob self had a problem you would like answers from people that actually mattered and not some noob that has no clue.. No?? Exactly SU!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by The♥♥♥♥

Hold my hand? What.. It's there game.. They added it and they need to prevent people from abusing the system.. Is it ok to ♥♥♥♥? Is it ok to lie ♥♥♥♥♥ steal? Is it ok to have an alt base to join a clan and see bombs.. Where is the line I. The sand? I bet if your noob self had a problem you would like answers from people that actually mattered and not some noob that has no clue.. No?? Exactly SU!

---

♥♥♥♥♥ so leaving a clan is against the rules apparently huh? Lol

maybe if you knew how to run a clan.. Youd realize what Im trying to say and not have a little tantrum because supercell cant manage the clan for you:rolleyes:

Please dont be a child over this. Supercell will not shame people and label them as a traitor. Its YOUR fault they hopped, learn how to avoid hoppers. Read one of the THOUSANDS of responses to clan hoppers that are from the majority.