Clan Improvement

I love this idea! It would finally give meaning to the name of the game "Clash of CLANS". I also like the ideas mentioned by others in this thread such as requesting certain troops, and being able to chat with other clans. That way you could have a main clan, and then a feeder clan that tests out players before they are able to join the main clan.

Edit: Actually, I think that there shouldn't be the option of "Friending" clans, because then there would be the possibility of top clans friending and then only being able to attack other clans.

Also, there needs to be the option in the Attack menu of attacking "Enemy clans" or just regular attacking, because if you can only attack enemy clans, that wouldn't be fun. There could also be a limit of how many times you or your clan can attack another clan within a day/week. Let's say each player can only attack the enemy clan once per day.

Another problem that occurs is that you could visit the enemy clan member's bases, study them, and then easily raid them. Even if it is made that once a clan is an enemy clan and you can't visit their bases, you could just back out of your clan, study their bases, and then join back into the clan.

These problems would need to be worked around in order for this to work.

What would be the point of these clan wars if there isnt any extra reward for winning and what if theres a clan war and the best player from one clan fights the worst in the other, the lesser Player would be unfairly destroyed, so high level players could use this system to farm without losing trophies

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lukemilner123

What would be the point of these clan wars if there isnt any extra reward for winning and what if theres a clan war and the best player from one clan fights the worst in the other, the lesser Player would be unfairly destroyed, so high level players could use this system to farm without losing trophies

---

There could be a limit where the Top 5 members of a clan could only raid the other Top 5 members of a clan.

i like the idea of clan vs clan attack and making a enemy clan, but i dont like the accept attack request, it would be better if we attack them without letting them to know and i think each clan can have a village and troop for attacking (people in clan donate troops and used to attack other clans.
and the lucky draw is good idea too, i think they should give gems to people in lower levels so that they can have a chance to be in the top list.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CR7

Hey Supercell guys, one thing I don't like about clash of clans of the master tournament, the very first clash of clans players get really good really fast bcoz they receive gems every 10 days, so it would be impossible to new players to overtake the best players, while the best players who receive the gem prizes are undefeated. Therefore I think there should be something like a raffles tickets/"lucky draw" for gems, where you have to "pay" gold to "buy" raffle tickets to get a chance at winning gems.

---

I like the idea. The high level players usually don't do much with the gem reward because they already spend money on gems.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheKnight

Also, there needs to be the option in the Attack menu of attacking "Enemy clans" or just regular attacking, because if you can only attack enemy clans, that wouldn't be fun. There could also be a limit of how many times you or your clan can attack another clan within a day/week. Let's say each player can only attack the enemy clan once per day.

---

Yah, I had already said this before, that on the Attack! button you can choose if to attack enemy clans or worldwide. I like the idea of once per day, but would the revenge attack count as an attack?
Also, I think there should be two cases.

N1: Two clans wanna have fun raiding each other because they are friends so they send and accept the enemy request. That would be fun!
N2: You enemy a clan cuz you hate them or they have stolen a ton of stuff off you, whatever!

Yeah, the friendly thing shouldn't be implemented, only the Enemy status.

Let me know if you think there should be a request or just directly enemied.

It should be accepted by both, or else North 44 and other top clans could make a feast of weaker clans. Although, if one clan wants to back out of being enemies, only one of the clans should have to opt out to have the enemyship canceled.

But exactly as everyone else said that strong clans can only attack other strong clans or stronger! And weak clans can only attack weak clans or stronger!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BeeDee

But exactly as everyone else said that strong clans can only attack other strong clans or stronger! And weak clans can only attack weak clans or stronger!

---

Exactly, they must equal out ;). A clan can only attack another clan around their throphy amount or stronger...

This idea is open to farming abuse so I do not think SC would implement it. Several people in my clan have second accounts. Which are in a second sister clan we have made. In your idea we could use these second accounts like a bank. We make enemies with ourselves and then put all of our resources in our secondary accounts outside the walls. We attack ourselves with an instant win and all of the resources thereby boosting the amount gold an elixir in our main account storage. When we are done raiding ourselves, we go to our second account and take down the shield and start all over again.

AND...

We could all put our main account TH outside of our base and go to our second account and attack our main account's TH for an instant shield with no loss of resources. This has the effect of (a) double producing gold and elixir thereby giveing an unfair advantage, and (b) constantly having shield so no one could attack you.

I know you really like the idea... but it has too many abuse problems with it.

Sorry mate.

Happy Clashing!