Limit number of attack per season

This could be one of the worst ideas i've seen on the forums so far

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by o0oAnnyo0o

Woah, just woah. He's unbelievable. 2k5 win in 1 season. It's insane. Well, I just give a suggestion to LIMIT the big problem (NOT LOOT PROBLEM) that's going on. And I think it would be best in everyone interest to set a ceiling. Choosing the number would be critical, though. And it probably would be SC's job to figure out a good number. 1k2 is just an example I throw out there. But, I honestly believe that there aren't many people capable of doing what Brandon did.

---

There are 20160 minutes in a two-week period. Divide that by 2500 and you get 8. That means this guy had to win a raid every 8 minutes over a period of two weeks. I doubt there are many real players that actually do this.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by badfish1979

There are 20160 minutes in a two-week period. Divide that by 2500 and you get 8. That means this guy had to win a raid every 8 minutes over a period of two weeks. I doubt there are many real players that actually do this.

---

Sniping you could, but that is still insane..

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by badfish1979

There are 20160 minutes in a two-week period. Divide that by 2500 and you get 8. That means this guy had to win a raid every 8 minutes over a period of two weeks. I doubt there are many real players that actually do this.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TimeForShady

Short details of my troops, spells, trophy range and training method: (More details below under 'Farming for Dark Elixir')
Townhall 9
Troops: lvl 6 Barbs, lvl 6 Archs, 20 lvl 5 Gobs, 20 lvl 5 Minions
Spells: 4 lvl 5 lightnings
Trophy: 1600-1800
Army Composition: 45-50 Barbs, 110-115 Archs, 20 Gobs, 20 Minions
Training Method: 1 Barrack Barbs, 3 Barracks Archs, 2 DE Barracks Minions. (20 Gobs will be trained using 1 Barrack that trains Archs)
Barracks Boost: None
Training time with Gobs: 18mins 15secs
Training time without Gobs: 15mins 45secs

Changed my method during th10 as I found that the new method could allow me to farm DE 15-20% faster per day than my old method.

Townhall 10
Troops: lvl 6 Barbs, lvl 6 Archs, 20 lvl 6 Gobs, 8 lvl 4 Wbs, lvl 6 Minions, lvl 3-4 Hogs
Spells: 1 lvl 6 lightning, 1 lvl 6 healing spell, 2 lvl 5 rage spells, 1 lvl 2 jump spell
Trophy: 1800-2000
Army Composition: 49-54 Barbs, 115-120 Archs, 20 Gobs, 8 Wbs, 10 Minions, 3 Hogs
Training Method: 1 Barrack Barbs, 3 Barracks Archs, 1 DE Barrack Minions, 1 DE Barrack Hogs. (20 Gobs and 8 Wbs will be trained using 1 Barrack that trains Archs)
Boosts: 4 Elixir Barracks, Spell Factory
Training time with Gobs and Wbs: 23mins 20secs (5mins 50secs boosted)
Training time without Gobs and Wbs: 16mins 50secs (4mins 7.5secs boosted)
*Note: Those troops stated without the quantity will be training non-stop in the barracks, final quantities will depend on how many troops I've donated and used in the previous raid. Gobs and Minions are up for insurance purpose so I try not to use them in my raids.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Harrisman24

Sniping you could, but that is still insane..

---

Yeah. Talking about that. How does he do that? A win every 8 minutes, and play 24/7. Maybe nobody notice that before, but, after after looking at your calculator, I start doubting it. Given his troops combination, it's IMPOSSIBLE.

He's not snipping. That's the point.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Harrisman24

Sniping you could, but that is still insane..

---

Every 8 minutes 24/7 for two weeks straight?

Besides, this guy clearly showed that he wasn't sniping.

When did he sleep during that 2-week period?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by o0oAnnyo0o

Yes, you see it right. I think SC should limit number of attack per season.

And let me say it first: It will NOT effect negatively to the MAJORITY of the coc community and it will helps many of us.

First, the loot problem. If people can't spend hours and hours playing, others would find loot. Hence, all the loot thread would stop.

Second, more important, to stop a certain group of people who can do thousands of loot each season. Yes, I say it, thousand. How could he do it would NOT be discuss here, because if we say it, this thread will disappear in few minutes. Please don't ask how or asking for prove that people do thousand of raids. And Please do not discuss it. Just accept the fact that there are people who do that. But let say that, the target who I'm aimed at can easily make 1000 win per season. I actually have one on my revenge list who have like 100-150 wins/day in last few days. And his trophy is STABLE around 1600 so it's not trophy pushing or TH sniping. To this point of the season, he made more than 1000 wins already. And it's just WIN. Yet, only 5 defense win. And it was 5 since a week ago.

I doubt that the majority of our communities can do thousand of raid every season. So it won't effect the majority of us. For those who truly can do it, I'm really sorry. But, this way, we can limit a certain group of people, and having more loot for everyone.

It's not SOLUTION. It's just a band-aid. But I think it NEEDED for a better communities.

Guys, before you complain about the limit number of attack, let's do some simply maths:

If we limit the attack, for example, at 1200. And you barcher and boost your barrack and be able to pull 10 attack per hour, it would take you 120 hours to reach the cap. It's almost 9 hours of CONSTANTLY raiding (6 minutes per raid) per day. It's not enough for you??? If you constantly raiding everyday for more than 9 hours, I really have bad news for you....

---

OP. You have a right to your opinion, others have a right to theirs.

If you choose to play Clash your way and others choose to play it their way, as long as it is within the rules, both approaches are valid.

You have identified a universal truth about the current state of Clash - that there is a loot problem. I.E. people wish to advance in the game but are restricted by the lack of loot by which to advance.

It is the problem that needs to be accurately identified: its causes and effects BEFORE solutions are advanced.

Quick fixes will alienate some, please others. Your suggestions may have some merit in the short term. I believe they would only add to the problem in the long run. Restrictions polarise many and may lead to further ch@#!ting..

I suggest an overall approach to the current problems are required, short term fixes and restrictions on players may in fact worsen the situation.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by badfish1979

Every 8 minutes 24/7 for two weeks straight?

Besides, this guy clearly showed that he wasn't sniping.

When did he sleep during that 2-week period?

---

Indeed, I was just referring to what I quoted :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by o0oAnnyo0o

Guys, before you complain about the limit number of attack, let's do some simply maths:

If we limit the attack, for example, at 1200. And you barcher and boost your barrack and be able to pull 10 attack per hour, it would take you 120 hours to reach the cap. It's almost 9 hours of CONSTANTLY raiding (6 minutes per raid) per day. It's not enough for you??? If you constantly raiding everyday for more than 9 hours, I really have bad news for you....

---

What about those who have lots of gems and insta gems troops for every attack?

Also, this implementation hurts what is most important to SC: active new players, i.e. TH4-6. Those army training times are very short, and if you are a TH5 going for 1250 cups achievement, you most likely will hit that mark.

Not to mention that it hampers the way people regulate cups by one-trooping.

Terrible idea and wouldn't solve any loot issues.

I would like to point out that previously a huge clan family, I believe it was indo eternity, held an event to see who could get the most attacks in a season. Many members throughout that clan family exceeded 1000+ attacks. Anyone noting that some people have an insane number of attacks won in a season does not prove they are using any 3rd party program within the game, competitions are just one potential explanation for people with these numbers. Stop chasing ghosts.