Isotopic
De protection base
Attachment 60313
Please rate the base
If the ratings seem good I will make full thread
Logs:
to come
Printable View
Isotopic
De protection base
Attachment 60313
Please rate the base
If the ratings seem good I will make full thread
Logs:
to come
I nnee some feedback
-Mortar placement is a joke
-You're funneling into the core. Three giant bombs are better placed elsewhere.
-WT placement doesn't cover entire base/give good coverage
-AD placement overlaps too much
-unstaggered junctions
-double gold storage, at least spread them out a bit.
-horrid outer building placement.
Overall rating: 0.25/10. Yes I'm harsh but in all honestly this base really isn't all that good.
Looks average to bad. This is a DE base... It funnels into the DE. I sent a few giants or a golem to be a meat shield and let my gobs do the job . I don't like the vulnerable mortar at the bottom and the wizard tower at the top because with some planning and force, two key defences could be taken out just like that. Mortars are supposed to cover ALL of the base, not half of it. Same with the AD and wizard towers.
I like this base. I clearly see that the wizard tower and mortar are good for barches and all out arch and barb. Even though those 2 building are HIGHLY vulnerable. I see this base is good for saving DE. Looking at your DE i can guess this is a good base for protection of DE. But for all other resources... not that good. The funneling is kind of good not 100% i myself think that Pingfao's Tesla Theme Park is better for protection of all loot. Isn't this only for DE because all other resources are easily accessible. So my rating is 5/10. But the 5 comes from protection of DE.
Best Regards -Pjmj11
Protection of DE? How?Quote:
Originally Posted by Pjmj11
The base funnels right into the core.
ACTUALLY. The base has hoghly upgraded traps and defenses at the core.
Deploy a stream of goblins by the TH.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pjmj11
The first few will set off all the giant bombs.
The rest of them will arrive at different times--each one would be able to get 1-2 hits off on the DE storage before dying.
Send giants or some type of meat shield to distract the defences while the goblins take all the DE after all the traps are set off.Quote:
Originally Posted by Brenn
You have 4 splash building that have coverage of the de , gobs die istantaneouly look at the log i posted
If the break-into-the-bottom-and-use-the-funnelling-to-your-advantage tactic doesn't work, attack from the side using GoWiPe or something and since one mortar and one WT are probably out of range, then it should be easier to attack into the core with two splash defences out of the way.Quote:
Originally Posted by Kwam
Were all the goblins deployed in a group? If so, that's why. A smart goblin user wouldn't deploy them in a group for this base...Quote:
Originally Posted by Kwam
I highly agree with kwam
I actually like this base. All these people talking about how they'd beat it.. If you come across this on a raid you don't know where the traps are. You can't plan it out like you're doing. Also, if someone gowipes, they should destroy most of the base and get all the de anyway so that is irrelevant. I like that the giants won't set off all if any of the bombs because they'll be going for the closer defenses (the teslas are too deep for the giants to go all the way up the middle). The only thing I would possibly suggest without overhauling is replace the first giant bomb with a Tesla so that any barch troops will bunch up before getting destroyed by the giant bomb. Unorthodox bases can sometimes be a good thing. 6/10Quote:
Originally Posted by Kwam
Bad base. Six wall breakers and you are in the center with barch. Way too easy to get DE with little effort. 2\10 because you have good defenses.Quote:
Originally Posted by treyshooter