Change outside town hall to give no stars

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by magnor

However, there are deserted bases or "farmable" bases to varying numbers and with varying defences anywhere from 1100 to 2500trophies (that's only based on my experience. I know of people who farm at 3000+). Loot is always there.
People complain that it's not, but I think those people don't change their trophy range and look for it. Instead they complain (hence the long post you introduced me to).

I'm saying I have never experience a longer than 1 week loot problem in this game. I don't need it to be easier to get. I'd rather keep it as easier to protect. Changing these two things doesn't make sense (and from what I'm reading more than a lot of people agree with me), and if Th snipers want to benefit from it, so what? Their not hurting anyone.

---

The game would probably be better if it doesn't rely on deserted bases and SuperCell is trying to deter that too by reducing their appearance. TH not giving a shield can hurt farming but the game should (in my opinion) be more focused on doing well rather than relying on easy bases and cheap shields so that it's more skill based

I agree that loot is out there but I prefer resource to flow around faster with less nexting even it means that it'll flow out of me faster (more of a personal preference difference here). I don't strongly want or don't want TH to give 0 stars, but I do want for the TH to be something more than a building that most players want destroyed.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sukiawesome

What do you have against th snipers? It's the only way for lower town halls to get into very high leagues. Also if you don't like ppl sniping you, put your th in the base or revenge. The 12 hour shield is for losing 4-11 cups as well.

---

I have nothing against TH sniping. I snipe all the time. I have also kept my own TH outside since TH7. My problem is the knock-on effect of having outside THs, not sniping in and of itself.
The knock on effects:

1. Reduced overall target pool due to free shields
2. No true indication of your ability/level in multiplayer rankings.
3. Lower town hall people, gaining trophies above their real level, gives higher TH people MUCH LESS RESOURCE TARGETS. This is because of the diminishing returns of a higher TH person attacking a lower TH person. It is also because of the crappy matching system when searching for targets, it should not be based on an inaccurate trophy system, it should be based on your overall spent on buildings upgrades or a combination of trophies and total spent.
4. They made THs take up more of a footprint for a reason, 4x4 squares. If it becomes a loot resource, it will force people to put it inside their walls, making all bases slightly weaker.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Growls

I have nothing against TH sniping. I snipe all the time. I have also kept my own TH outside since TH7. My problem is the knock-on effect of having outside THs, not sniping in and of itself.
The knock on effects:

1. Reduced overall target pool due to free shields
2. No true indication of your ability/level in multiplayer rankings.
3. Lower town hall people, gaining trophies above their real level, gives higher TH people MUCH LESS RESOURCE TARGETS. This is because of the diminishing returns of a higher TH person attacking a lower TH person. It is also because of the crappy matching system when searching for targets, it should not be based on an inaccurate trophy system, it should be based on your overall spent on buildings upgrades or a combination of trophies and total spent.

---

1. There is enough players in the game in order to always find a match, excluding very high champs.
2. Never base how good someone is off there trophies, but there experience level and how good their base is.
3. Well just go to a higher league where there are no "bad" players, go to champs for the real deal
4. Well 1k gold and elixir is already toooo much loot for the Town Hall

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Growls

Now before you say NONONO, please listen.
By outside town hall, I mean a town hall placed outside walls, so that anyone attacking will attack the townhall to get trophies.

---

NONONONO

10chars