Change outside town hall to give no stars

It would be better if the TH gave a flat loot since it's simpler and won't have problems with collectors since the TH gives a % of total possible loot but overall how exactly would this hurt farming? (aside from finding less abandoned bases which SuperCell doesn't want you to find). Aren't farmers/people who want easy shields the type of people who have resources that they want to protect? By preventing people from getting easy shields, it would also cause their bases to be skipped. This allows more resources to be stolen from collectors in never base, thereby increasing the flow of loot

Also the TH's description says something along the lines of 'This building is the heart of your village and should be protected' so, to some extent, it sounds like the game wants you to not let your TH die. It's where all the villagers and builders are hiding after all.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DMS4TheWin

That is the absolute WORST idea i have ever read on these forums.

---

This sounds a tad exaggerated. Being able to attack anyone you want or getting gems for successful 3 star attacks sounds more problematic

No worst idea in the history of the forums.

If there TH is outside they lose trophies, it's their own fault. This is a bad idea.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Growls

Now before you say NONONO, please listen.
By outside town hall, I mean a town hall placed outside walls, so that anyone attacking will attack the townhall to get trophies. By doing this the defender only loses trophies a lot of the time, and keeps their resources.
I suggest that you change it so that THs no longer give 1 star, but the TH should give ~20% of the total of the defenders resource pool (DE included).
This will make the TH still valuable enough to protect, yet stop people from TH farming.
Why do you want them to stop farming THs do you ask?
Because of shields, taking out someones outside TH gives the defender a 12h shield. Why do we care? Because it reduces the overall pool of targets to attack. The more targets to attack, the more major (All in) attacks placed, the more overall down time between attacks, the more quality targets for all.

---

umm... DUDE!!! You REALLY have to be a town hall three to understand why this idea is a benefit to this game CAUSE ITS NOT!! It's probably the ONLY way to get loot with a town hall nine. The only way I'm maintaining about 3m gold and elixir at a time is because for the last couple of months, I've been being sniped by town hall fives in silver II. And has it EVER occurred to you that Supercell added storages for a reason? Dude, sorry to say this, but if they are going to add this, they'll have to make a 24hr shield that costs 5 gems (and they won't).

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MrAwesomePants

umm... DUDE!!! You REALLY have to be a town hall three to understand why this idea is a benefit to this game CAUSE ITS NOT!! It's probably the ONLY way to get loot with a town hall nine. The only way I'm maintaining about 3m gold and elixir at a time is because for the last couple of months, I've been being sniped by town hall fives in silver II. And has it EVER occurred to you that Supercell added storages for a reason? Dude, sorry to say this, but if they are going to add this, they'll have to make a 24hr shield that costs 5 gems (and they won't).

---

I am TH9, not far off going TH10.
Have you not sat there clicking Next 100+ times to find a target? Its because all of the good targets have a 12 hour shield.
Trophies in my mind, should be an indication of how good you are at multiplayer attacks/defences, not an indication of how well you can snipe.
Poor design from the outset in my opinion.

This would ruin the games economy . This would just make loot harder to find.

Now I think having it specifically for outside town halls is a bad idea... that would be hard. But I think destroying the town hall should have some sort of benefit, if. you ask me. The town hall is supposed to be one of the most important building, no, THE most important building. Ever noticed how that is one of the 3 buildings you get at the start? Ever notice how cannons point away from them, no matter where they are? Supercell designed the game so that you TRY to trophy push. Hybrids are the ones who actually follow what you are supposed to do. The point of the game is to WIN, not intentionally lose. It really is kind of ruining the game.


My proposition is that much more loot (much more than the current 1000), like 10% of your loot, with a cap of the town hall level times 1000. Or a loot reduction/ bonus for destroying/ not destroying (not respectively:p) the town hall, or the other stars (the 50%).

Go for the loot instead of the TH. Problem solved.

I won't say whether this idea is good or bad, but I will say I am 99% sure it will never be put in the game.
Also, it's a bad idea.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Growls

Now before you say NONONO, please listen.
By outside town hall, I mean a town hall placed outside walls, so that anyone attacking will attack the townhall to get trophies. By doing this the defender only loses trophies a lot of the time, and keeps their resources.
I suggest that you change it so that THs no longer give 1 star, but the TH should give ~20% of the total of the defenders resource pool (DE included).
This will make the TH still valuable enough to protect, yet stop people from TH farming.
Why do you want them to stop farming THs do you ask?
Because of shields, taking out someones outside TH gives the defender a 12h shield. Why do we care? Because it reduces the overall pool of targets to attack. The more targets to attack, the more major (All in) attacks placed, the more overall down time between attacks, the more quality targets for all.

---

Thats the benefits of it you loose trophy but you gain shield its a win/win situation.... This is a strategy game
there are many ways not to loose trophy even the TH is outside, you just have to think... think... think...
I have a farming base at TH8, maxed out buildings, I seldom got raided, and if I got raided Im more thankful to
them because I gain shield :D