Printable View
Some of the idea's (not including my own) are banned.
Is there a sticky for that too? Because it seems like this forum section is designed to ban all ideas even if they could potentially improve the game.
I am asking this with honesty.
Why is nearly every idea banned?
Not all ideas are ruled out. It's just this subforum has REALLY bad ideasQuote:
Originally Posted by Itschasee
They aren't 'banned' as such they are just ruled out by Super Cell. All of them having a good reason to why they cannot be added to the game.Quote:
Originally Posted by Itschasee
For example- invasion of people's privacy with the online/offline idea
Adding more labs, would make upgrading troops easier as well as ruining the whole part of waiting till one set of troops are upgraded before moving onto the next.
ok I apologize for my inaccurate title wording.Quote:
Originally Posted by FireThief
However, ruled out for privacy? Clan leader/co leader chat is unnecessary so its ruled out? seems odd. I recently sent feedback to supercell about the game's loot declining. Said the cost of finding a base nearly ends up being even when you search over 100 bases either decked out th10 or th8 with 10k in the storages. I'm sure that someone's complained about that and I doubt it wouldn't be on the "sticky"... Yet the sc customer service claimed they would forward the idea of reducing the "Next" cost to development.
So again, bad ideas I think most can agree they're there for a reason. What about the good ideas that might actually contribute to the game's enjoyment? Why do so many of them seem to have already been ruled out? I reject the player privacy excuse.
I understand what you mean, I felt the same way when I first joined the forums and I know how frustrating it is. My advice to you is to keep posting ideas. New ideas. Whenever you have an idea that you think 'hmmm I wonder if this would be good' just post it! Be wild! BUT be sure to be accurate and include all possible information.Quote:
Originally Posted by Itschasee
Regarding some of the reasons on why some ideas are ruled out for some ideas we simply haven't been given a reason to why they are ruled out. The best thing to do regarding this is to just accept it and move on. Posting a ruled out idea over and over again in the hope that Super Cell will suddenly say 'yeah sure!' is super unlikely. Plus it has the unfortunate side effect of annoying players like myself who try to keep this subforum full of new ideas.
Hope this helps. :cool:
This is actually NOT ruled out. Only the ideas listed below the "currently ruled out" header are ruled out, all other ideas listed in this thread are still possibilities: http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...rum-guidelines.Quote:
Originally Posted by Itschasee
When someone says "read the sticky", "use the search function", etc., they don't necessarily mean your idea is ruled out. They can say those things, but your thread will only be removed if it contains idea from the ruled out list. There is nothing wrong with posting your suggestions for ideas already in the sticky, as long as they expand on the ideas (ie. not one liners).
So if someone writes a list of ideas; for example 20, but 1 is ruled out and they didn't check the sticky. The entire thread would be deleted?Quote:
Originally Posted by zachUVA
No, I like to think I (and other mods) use a little common sense when removing threads. If the ruled out idea(s) are a significant part of the thread, it will be deleted. If it's just a minor part and other (non-ruled out) ideas are the main part of the thread, I don't see the point in removing the whole thread.Quote:
Originally Posted by FireThief
Ahhh okay, thank you for the clarification. :cool:Quote:
Originally Posted by zachUVA