Attack hoppers

I'd like to see the ability for clan members to attack anyone who leaves the clan within 24 hours of joining. This would discourage people from joining, loading up on donations, and leaving. It would be like revenge on deserters. Actually, it might be best to have revenge open for 24 hours -- if they get a shield, that will eat up a lot of the time.

I often look up the people who hop, and they tend to have pretty weak defenses so I would really like a chance to clobber them after they leave (especially since they also tend to have lots of gold md elixir!).

So, I'd like to see a 'revenge' or 'attack' option come up when you click on a recent departé in the clan chat, and keep that active for 24 hours or so.

Bruce2g. Aka Leopold the gre

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bruce2g

I'd like to see the ability for clan members to attack anyone who leaves the clan within 24 hours of joining. This would discourage people from joining, loading up on donations, and leaving. It would be like revenge on deserters. Actually, it might be best to have revenge open for 24 hours -- if they get a shield, that will eat up a lot of the time.

I often look up the people who hop, and they tend to have pretty weak defenses so I would really like a chance to clobber them after they leave (especially since they also tend to have lots of gold md elixir!).

So, I'd like to see a 'revenge' or 'attack' option come up when you click on a recent departé in the clan chat, and keep that active for 24 hours or so.

Bruce2g. Aka Leopold the gre

---

So because they took a whole 25 arch from you you want to be able to attack them?

id say most hoppers are up for this as there norm a lot higher lvs then the clan leader,

but all that aside it lets players trade gold and elixir, that's a big no no, also it's unfair and so on

Some clans have several sister or feeder clans and members tend to go from clan from one clan to another. So how will this Revenge option apply to them?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by VenomAL

Some clans have several sister or feeder clans and members tend to go from clan from one clan to another. So how will this Revenge option apply to them?

---

if someone just hops from a sister clan u wouldnt revenge them would u?

i like the idea. perhaps they could be a sticky at the top or there could be a third tab in messages: inbox, viewing who attacked u and clan revenge.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MrH

if someone just hops from a sister clan u wouldnt revenge them would u?

---

To some, not necessarily.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by VenomAL

To some, not necessarily.

---

Yeah ull always get the occaisional idiot who cant resist it, but on the whole its not a huge obstacle to the idea. good point though it would have to be considered

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MrH

if someone just hops from a sister clan u wouldnt revenge them would u?

i like the idea. perhaps they could be a sticky at the top or there could be a third tab in messages: inbox, viewing who attacked u and clan revenge.

---

They would revenge, and plan to.

i have 100k goldi don't need, I leave and move stores to one corner lower lv player hits and takes 100k gold

Sorry but this just seems far to abusable to me by players who know what their doing and want to trade resources or shields. If you can find away around this, by all means carry on the discussion.

Maybe you could make a cool down for joining clans or only be able to join the same clan 3 times before a 1 month cool down. Also you could have a clan history of who left who joined who promoted who, etc so if a person come then leave the clan leader can click their name and click a button that said "not recommended" or something like that so when he joins or asks to join other people's clan they will know. Also you can only "not recommend" some one if they've had anything to do with your clan not random people to prevent abusing the command. Another thing to prevent abusing is a limit of 5 "not recommended" and if you get more then say 25 not recommended(they add up) you will be monitored/banned. The Not recommended is shown by -1,-1,etc next to the player's name in the chat bar or in the clan "lobby". Finally if you deem this person righteous you can set to default therefore he won't have a "not recommended". This will only prevent clan hoppers as there will always be idiots who do and and you cant completely stop them. This might be a little to complicated for CoC's servers but who knows.Regards,Farticus Sparticus_________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________Join Major Cheifs only lvl 20 and 800+ trophy req.!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by FarticusSparticus

Maybe you could make a cool down for joining clans or only be able to join the same clan 3 times before a 1 month cool down. Also you could have a clan history of who left who joined who promoted who, etc so if a person come then leave the clan leader can click their name and click a button that said "not recommended" or something like that so when he joins or asks to join other people's clan they will know. Also you can only "not recommend" some one if they've had anything to do with your clan not random people to prevent abusing the command. Another thing to prevent abusing is a limit of 5 "not recommended" and if you get more then say 25 not recommended(they add up) you will be monitored/banned. The Not recommended is shown by -1,-1,etc next to the player's name in the chat bar or in the clan "lobby". Finally if you deem this person righteous you can set to default therefore he won't have a "not recommended". This will only prevent clan hoppers as there will always be idiots who do and and you cant completely stop them. This might be a little to complicated for CoC's servers but who knows.Regards,Farticus Sparticus_________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________Join Major Cheifs only lvl 20 and 800+ trophy req.!

---

Some interesting ideas, but definitely don't have it so you can't join a clan more than three times.... I am the leader of my clan and have to hop around to different clans frequently. I know a lot of high levels that do this... pretty much everyone in the top slots, so that wouldn't work.

Should be a timer on joining same clan, with a much larger time if you got booted.

there already is

Sneaky Dave had a GREAT point. I didn't think of it, but fortunately Dave is sneakier than I am.