Printable View
There is a very easy way to get rid of clan hoppers.
Make it cost elixir to join a clan. The amount could increase with the level of your clan castle. But make it cost enough that there is no advantage to joining a clan just to get a few troops. I would think that 10,000 elixir for level 1 clan castle, increasing to 100,000 for high level clan castles would be a good amount. The elixir that you pay could be divided up equally between the members of the clan.
No offense, but that is a terrible idea. I jump from 5 different family clans and i wouldn't pay anything to keep doing this. It would be better if sc made it so someone wouldn't be able to leave a clan during a war or something like that.Quote:
Originally Posted by BoilerDon
NO - family clans and feeder clans
Theres nothing wrong with hoppers really, stop hating on them!
Hoppers can be fixed in game within your clan, manage your clan better dont expect supercell to do evvverything for you
Your idea will make more complaints.
Think please. If you want to hop in the game you can, Supercell aren't going to just make a rule and say Hoppers may not Hop.
Hoppers are going to hop if they want, that's how they want to play the game. Eventually they'll struggle when they're level is going higher and they want better troops from better clans because they'll get booted by experienced players.
What is the problem with hoppers?
There are good hoppers - those who jump between "family" clans, and those who are lost looking before they commit.
And there are "bad" hoppers - those who join, request & receive, then leave.
Easy fix. Just set the game so that you can donate immediately after joining, but you can not "request" from the clan until you have both A.) been a member for 24 hours B.) Donated at least 20 troop units.
That should fix the bad hoppers.
Or don't donate good troops to people who just joined.Quote:
Originally Posted by pmg2010
Better Idea: Disallow leaving the clan for 24 hours after receiving troops.
horrible idea. There shouldn't be anything implemented to stop "hopping" its just part of the game. Figure out a way around it within your clan.Quote:
Originally Posted by pmg2010
There are simple ways to deal with these issues. Make clan/co status independent of clan membership. This means that if a clan elder or co-leader leaves the clan and then returns, his status remains intact. Clan leadership could exempt elders and co-leaders from the cost of joining the clan. They could also set the cost to join. If they want to set it at zero, that would be their option. If they need to boost membership, they could set the price low. If they want the clan to be very exclusive, they could set the cost high. The elixir paid to join a clan would be equally divided between the clan members. It could be put into the Clan Castles, where it would have to be collected. Another option is to allow people to join the clan as visitors for free. Visitors can donate and chat, but can't request or fight in wars. Then the fee to join the clan would make the visitor a full member.
Hoppers are great they go around requesting troops giving out free xp, if you don't want it then simply don't donate to them.