How does supercell determine the most heroic attack in clan wars
My friend was quite cross when i got the most heroic battle award ????
Printable View
How does supercell determine the most heroic attack in clan wars
My friend was quite cross when i got the most heroic battle award ????
I've never been able to figure it out.
But your friend doesn't sound like much of a friend.
hmmmm
LOL he is the clan leader though so attitude remains ;) LOL
The most important factor is the difference in rank on the war map. I do not know, if there are others (e.g. number of stars) counted in, but the battle won against a player who is ranked higher than you on the respective map is the most important.
Kind regards
Patrick
i guess ur right bcoz as far as i remember i had attacked a base that was no 3 in my enemies clan
and i was at no 6 in my clan . i beleive u are right .
thanks buddy
add me up as ur friend :)
peace V xD
I don't know if this is entirely true. In our previous war I was ranked #6 and a clan mate of mine was ranked #9. We are both th 9's. I attacked the enemies number 2 which was a th10 and was worth loot bonus of 450k of each so it wasnt like he was underdeveloped. I earned 1 star from my raid. My clan mate attacked their #1 who was also a th10 but was worth 475k of each so an even better th10. He also got 1 star from the raid. I came out with the most heroic attack. Becuase of this it would not be based on war ranking.Quote:
Originally Posted by pmhausen
Well, war ranking is based on the total "points" in the relevant categories (Offense and Defense). So, I am guessing for most heroic attack/defense, is bases on the difference between the attacker's offensive points and defender's defensive points.Quote:
Originally Posted by Charli3Murphy6
I guessing its the difference between the offense ranking of the attacker and the defensive ranking of the defender.
In the above example, if your buddy who is ranked 9 and attacked #1 has a higher offense score than you do at #6 attacking their #2 then it follows that you could have the more 'heroic' attack.
I WISH that was the case. Unfortunately, it is not. It is more random than that. If it was, I would love it, because I usually attack much higher than my rank. Last war I 3-starred a rank 7 when I was a rank 14. But the award went to a member that attacked his same rank. Proof can be provided IF necessary, but I'd rather not bother because I think everyone knows it is pretty inexplicable.Quote:
Originally Posted by pmhausen
Where you are ranked in your clan from top to bottom is based on defensive strength.
I think the only way to see heroic attack and how it works would be for everyone to see what recommended target is before any attacks are made and then how many bases above that you actually attack.
Reason being that recommended target is systems measurement of your offensive strengths vs a base defensive strengths.
So example:
Member A #6 ranked: recommended initial target start of war before any attacks is 14 and you attack 3 = +11
Member B #9 ranked: recommended initial target start of war before any attacks is 16 he attacks 4 = +12
Member B got Heroic attack for attacking a base measured 12 higher than member A who came in at 11 higher although technically member A attacked a more difficult base.
*This is just a fun speculation no evidence to support my findings.
I suspect it has something to do with destruction percentage or speed. In our current war, a player has successfully defended against 4 attackers, but he doesn't have most heroic defense. The player who has it defended against a lower ranked opponent (their #17 vs our #14) but the attack ended at 49%, possibly 49.9999% if there were decimal places. I've also seen wars where no one has been named for most heroic defense. That leads me to believe that it's not a comparison between levels and there's some kind of minimum before it's awarded.
I'm sure SC has an algorithm for it...
Ask your friend don't be such an idiot. There are other achievement in life he should go for. Higher education, higher salary, bigger house, bigger car, hot girlfriend, sports achievement, social works, and even within the game most war star, most gold loot, highest trophy, etc etc etc. Most heroic attack? not even recorded after the war ended, and not even 1 gold extra for that achievement. You should find a smarter friend...Quote:
Originally Posted by decszpro1998
Did you even read this thread? After almost 2 pages of critical thinking on how most heroic is determined you posted this. Which serves no purpose to this thread other than making yourself come across as ignorant and mean towards another forum memeber. No reason this should have been posted.Quote:
Originally Posted by necro17000
Quote:
Originally Posted by Aspekt
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jietoh
hmm never really thought of it that way. I guess I just assumed that it was strictly based on defense. Now I can explain further. I attacked with Loonion. Maxed loons, lvl 5 minions and 4 maxed rage spells with lvl 3 drag and couple maxed wiz in my cc. My friend attacked with GoWipe. His troops were all maxed for th9. He had wiz, archers and a witch in his cc. (all maxed) I believe I ended with around 58% and he ended with 54% and we both took around the same amount of time of 2 minutes 25 seconds.
Not sure if (lol funny cuz that's my clans name) this helps at all but you guys already have a better grip on it than I did.
That is bad A banner man. How would one go about doing one like that?Quote:
Originally Posted by Charli3Murphy6
Here is the link to the forum member DragonX101 who did mine. He does great stuff.Quote:
Originally Posted by BigPapiSolis
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...=1#post2478543