Penalization Efforts to reduce loss of Clan Wars

This post is to warn of the impending problem that must be seen as a threat to the super cell society.
The coming and going of clan mates whom join a clan for a war only to leave it during war time.
Also the effort to reduce this factor made by Super Cell is not sufficient enough to stop further perpetrators from continuing this trend of ruining the game play for other players and causing wars that should have been won to be lost.
Clan Leaders and Co Leaders should be able to "CHOOSE" whom in the clan is allowed to fight Also Known As the filter ability since new members who have entered the clan can automatically rank for war, only to leave during war.
Plus the consequences of leaving be it 1 day or 2 days is not really preventing people from doing such actions. How about a counter that STACKS upon each clan left during war, also an increase in DAYS of the penalty would be nice, 2 Days during Prep and 1 Week penalty during war time. This will require all new members to participate. This pandemic is ruining the game please take this into consideration so the game play of Clan wars will not be ruined by party poopers.

Thanks:cool::cool:

This could be abused a clan could bully someone when war starts just for cheap laughs. It would need to have anti abuse measures for this to work

1 week?!? What if YOU were in a clan that bullied you or you just couldn't stand them anymore(even if it were during war) and you left, now you cant be in a war for a whole week! Oh myyyyyyyyy no.

Also this opt-out has been suggested (and some with a lot of detail) please don't post without looking up your idea first.

Personally, I don't believe there needs to be a penalty for leaving war when there is a nice little boot button if you have inactive or unloyal players in your clan. Keep it tight knit and all loyal and you'll be fine, if you want to recruit more youre just going to have to deal with the possibility of people not attacking or leaving!

Do a quick sweep of your clan before you start a war, and see how drastically this never effects you again!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ayyyyyema

Personally, I don't believe there needs to be a penalty for leaving war when there is a nice little boot button if you have inactive or unloyal players in your clan. Keep it tight knit and all loyal and you'll be fine, if you want to recruit more youre just going to have to deal with the possibility of people not attacking or leaving!

Do a quick sweep of your clan before you start a war, and see how drastically this never effects you again!

---

Well the BOOT button only works with people suspected of hopping and or non-loyal players. But what I am referring to is during the start up for a smaller clan *ahem* 10 players manageable for war and during the war 2 players receive a better deal from another clan on Global chat, lets say by leaving their current clan and joining this will give them Co-Leader in the new clan, of course most people will leave a clan for a "higher" position. And what about the clan they left behind? Most of the time a war is lost it is from 2 reasons: Inactivity of players and players who have left during war.

Now lets get to the nitty gritty of things, bullying, this is an obvious reason to quit a clan, although a clan does bully an individual, 2 things once again: "Its just a game" and "Its only words said by people you probably have not met and will probably never meet in any given circumstance" (if you do you have all the rights and reason to punch them in the face). Lets also factor that no matter how much bully occurs the choice of leaving is still up to the person being bullied...etc..., if the bullying is that bad then they can report it to Super Cell, in Terms & Services there should be a clause that states against it, otherwise; if its that bad they can leave and send a support ticket explaining their situation with clear facts and physical evidence, aka screen captures, this should nullify any penalty placed on them. Bully is a problem just as clan hopping. All i want is for the "Clan Hoppers" to be penalized at a greater rate due to their ability to basically prevent a win during Clan Wars.

New update to the idea: Clan hopping usually tends to be a pattern of joining a clan, asking for troops and then leaving once troops all filled, or staying until the preparation day and then leaving with full knowledge that this will undermine and or obstruct a clans ability to win. Which means hoppers jump multiple times, If the latter (ideas above for those whose lexicon are limited) can not be approved there should be a total amount of clans entered, troops received and troops given in a players profile. If a player (hopper) joins any clan in the future and has a clans joined to be 100, troops received to be 10000 and troops given to be 0, it should make our lives as clan leaders to decide whether the utilization of the boot button is necessary and whether this individual is qualified for clan wars. I would rather wait an extra day before starting a clan war if it means victory rather than start a war unbeknownst to me that the participants of the war are planning to leave or have the intentions of leaving for a better offer.

Also the quick sweep is good when it comes to activity but most of the time the most active members in your clan could also be those looking for the best deal arrange-able in fact i would rather have in-actives that i can boot than a player that has no interest in helping the clan.

http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...itelist-option