Unique Idea for walls/wallbreakers

I know there is a suggestion about creating a moat, but what about this: allow people to switch their walls to be a moat. And allow wallbreakers to switch from carrying a bomb, to carrying a plank - to span the moat. Create a reasonable charge to make the switch for each.
Hog-riders are afraid to jump over moats, and the only way over would be with "plank layers" and jump spells. This will allow people to design their bases with walls on one side and moats on another, which will create more strategic thinking on the part of everyone. Plus, I haven't seen too many people use the jump spell, so this may get more use out of it.

Your thoughts?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HeavyC

I know there is a suggestion about creating a moat, but what about this: allow people to switch their walls to be a moat. And allow wallbreakers to switch from carrying a bomb, to carrying a plank - to span the moat. Create a reasonable charge to make the switch for each.
Hog-riders are afraid to jump over moats, and the only way over would be with "plank layers" and jump spells. This will allow people to design their bases with walls on one side and moats on another, which will create more strategic thinking on the part of everyone. Plus, I haven't seen too many people use the jump spell, so this may get more use out of it.

Your thoughts?

---

This sounds unbelivably OP for many reasons-

1. There is no longer any point in levelling your walls, As in their moat state they take no damage.
2. People could just make an eggshell design 4 moats thick and just make it so you just have to spam wall breakers and hope to god enough of them survive and hit the right part so you can actually attack the base.
3. Hog riders will go from limited use to weaker and more expensive giants if this happens.
4. People will basically have to split their wall breaker numbers in half in order to avoid a situation in which their wall breakers are useless against an all wall or all moat base, It's hard enough finding decent raids as is we don't need to basically half the number of raidable bases.
5. Jump spell will be used just as much, It's underused because it's way to situational and usually only serves to get the slower Pekkas and wizards to the core. This idea will change nothing.

It kinda ruins the idea of Hog Riders.

Hobbit,
You're right, but obviously the designers and programmers would have to put a little more thought into the limitations and effects. My intention was not to spell out the entire program in this thread; it was just supposed to spark an idea. Unfortunately, I think it lit Iblob on fire. I hope he's OK.