Look, I shouldn't have to say this but this is a really bad idea. I enjoy getting loot from premature town halls. Also if you are getting attacked by people with higher town halls than you do, I bet you attack people with a lower town hall level than you. No one would play the game is this was implemented because it would ruin farming and make trophy pushing harder.
You state that like I said they were attacked by only one! When you are attacked by a lvl that has so much more powerful troops and no way to defend, and all you get is a revenge option!! Yeah they are really go in to waste time trying to fight a losing battle!Quote:
Originally Posted by Kinguadaworld
Farming may work for us but how do you think the lower lvls think when they have higher lvl attacking them! We might think it's fair because of how hard it is to collect resources, but do you think it's fair having their base torn thru with an army of goblin! When they have to use their goblins more carefully against others there.own lvl!
When they are just starting out the game works for them they get attacked by people there own lvl and they go against people there own level! With an occasional higher lvl if their trophies go to high! until around TH lvl 5! Then they get levels 6 & 7 attacking them and destroying their whole base without losing much in the process! Now all of a sudden the game seems less fair! Until lvl 7 when you find out why!
The game is most decidedly unfair. That's the point. It's what drives people to keep playing. No one is going to spend any effort upgrading their base if they get no advantage from it. The loot penalty ensures that being unfair doesn't mean there is relentless bullying.Quote:
Originally Posted by Street3
If trophies were used like supercell originally intended this wouldn't be the case a maxed out th 2 would then start getting attacked by TH 3 because their trophies are so high!! So on and so forth till your TH is maxed and you can't upgrade anymore!!!!Quote:
Originally Posted by Figjam66
That is originally how the trophies system was supposed to work and then someone stopped and thought about what you actually lose when your TH is destroyed and there you go a trend started, it picked business back up for higher lvl so supercell left it! Which means despite the complaints.And the people it discourages from playing it still makes more money with than without! And until a better idea comes along it's here to stay!
Yup!!! Pretty much!Quote:
Originally Posted by dahimi
Why are we still discussing this? Let the thread fade into the depths of the IFR subforum...
http://i61.tinypic.com/2z720y0.jpgQuote:
Originally Posted by Sluuurpee
You take a loot penalty attacking down to a weaker town hall, why not a penalty when attacking someone lower level than you? Like 10% penalty for every 5 levels you are above them. This would at least stop some of the poaching of super high level people dropping to low trophy ranks to ♥♥♥♥ the people there. They could still gain loot, but at least it would be tempered.
Horrible idea. Levels should make no impact on loot. ^^^ would basically punish people for donating, as they'd get less loot from similar strength people who haven't donated as much.Quote:
Originally Posted by partisian
The proposed idea sates that only townhalls of the same level can attack each other so the scenario you describe where the th3 attacks the th2 wouldn't be possible if this was implemented.One of the MANY other problems i see with this idea is it discourages farming which makes it very hard for people who can't afford to spend big money on the game to progress.Quote:
Originally Posted by Street3