Donation requirements.

Hello fellow Clashers! I think that it would be fantastic if supercell added a donation requirement that the leader could edit, and the way it would work would be that if you are below the requirement at the end of a week, you get a warning. After the warning, if you don't meet it again, you get kicked. If you are a new recruit, the first week is free so that if they join at the end of the week it won't count it as a fail. The leader can also set the amount of warnings until kicking. (idea courtesy to babu) Another leader function could be to set a checklist of donatable troops, making it so you oly have your prefered troops cycling through your castle. (idea courtesy to northoford) Please post you feedback! (constructive)

We really need this. I have also been in some clans where you can ONL donate archers or you get kicked, that would be nice if you could set a certain troop that you could only donate, and a certain level of that troop. Yes, this needs to be added.

Yeas, you get a set amount of warning by the leader and if you fail to reach the donation requirement you will be kicked.
Luv this idea

Thanks for the positive feedback! I agree with both of your ideas as well! I will add them to the OP

Yes yes yes yes yes yes YES

I really want this because some people in my clan 0 donations some have over 1000 by Wednesday which is unfair as some people are carrying the clan while others are sucking it dry

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SirBacon

Hello fellow Clashers! I think that it would be fantastic if supercell added a donation requirement that the leader could edit, and the way it would work would be that if you are below the requirement at the end of a week, you get a warning. After the warning, if you don't meet it again, you get kicked. If you are a new recruit, the first week is free so that if they join at the end of the week it won't count it as a fail. The leader can also set the amount of warnings until kicking. (idea courtesy to babu) Another leader function could be to set a checklist of donatable troops, making it so you oly have your prefered troops cycling through your castle. (idea courtesy to northoford) Please post you feedback! (constructive)

---

I was expecting to see a fascist esque darwinian approach to donations. But nope, not at all. Well implemented mate I think its a really good idea. Then we wouldnt have to waste space in the clan advert to say how many and it would keep the fat trimmed automatically.

It has been brought to my attention that this has a big flaw in the fact if someone takes a vacation or goes out of service. Perhaps they could tell their leader beforehand and he could assign people with a vacation that gets him out of donations until his vacation is over. The person themselves could have this button, but then it would be spammed and in the end solve nothing.

I see that as a leaders responsibility to track and kick people for low donations etc. I'm a leader and have no problems tracking that and doing the Sunday night boot. One of my elders uses a excel sheet to record all donations every week and when people join also its a lot of work but that way we don't have anyone getting kicked for being sick or busy. We use averages and if the players average is below our set amount then they get kicked. Just what we do if its any help to anyone. I would like to see a tracking of how man donations people receive that would be really nice, main for new players that join. Then you can see if they are taking a ton of troops but giving nothing quickly and can deal with it in a few days instead of a week or two.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Saskabee

I see that as a leaders responsibility to track and kick people for low donations etc. I'm a leader and have no problems tracking that and doing the Sunday night boot. One of my elders uses a excel sheet to record all donations every week and when people join also its a lot of work but that way we don't have anyone getting kicked for being sick or busy. We use averages and if the players average is below our set amount then they get kicked. Just what we do if its any help to anyone. I would like to see a tracking of how man donations people receive that would be really nice, main for new players that join. Then you can see if they are taking a ton of troops but giving nothing quickly and can deal with it in a few days instead of a week or two.

---

See, I had a system very alike to this myself, but this could take all the work out of this and really push people to donate, because I'd be more scared of a cold-blooded computer getting ready to kick me if i'm incompetent than a leader that I can sway the opinion of or convince otherwise. But still, in my post above I talked about how a sick or busy person could be excused. So thanks for the feedback, but I still think this could work out.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SirBacon

Hello fellow Clashers! I think that it would be fantastic if supercell added a donation requirement that the leader could edit, and the way it would work would be that if you are below the requirement at the end of a week, you get a warning. After the warning, if you don't meet it again, you get kicked. If you are a new recruit, the first week is free so that if they join at the end of the week it won't count it as a fail. The leader can also set the amount of warnings until kicking. (idea courtesy to babu) Another leader function could be to set a checklist of donatable troops, making it so you oly have your prefered troops cycling through your castle. (idea courtesy to northoford) Please post you feedback! (constructive)

---

In addition to the preferred donatable troops... Say the clan leader doesn't set a certain troop for donations or if someone wants a troop other then the set troop...when you are in your clan castle there should be an options like tab to where you can set the troops you will accept for donations. Just simply check the troops you would like to be donated to you. Send your troop request and when a person goes to donate troops only the troops you have "checked for donations" will appear in the donations tab

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KimuGaijin

In addition to the preferred donatable troops... Say the clan leader doesn't set a certain troop for donations or if someone wants a troop other then the set troop...when you are in your clan castle there should be an options like tab to where you can set the troops you will accept for donations. Just simply check the troops you would like to be donated to you. Send your troop request and when a person goes to donate troops only the troops you have "checked for donations" will appear in the donations tab

---

That's even better! great thinking I love it!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SirBacon

See, I had a system very alike to this myself, but this could take all the work out of this and really push people to donate, because I'd be more scared of a cold-blooded computer getting ready to kick me if i'm incompetent than a leader that I can sway the opinion of or convince otherwise. But still, in my post above I talked about how a sick or busy person could be excused. So thanks for the feedback, but I still think this could work out.

---

Im on board with the idea don't get me wrong. I just would like to see how many donations people receive a week also and would rather get that before a auto kick system. I seems fairly easy to have put in place and would make it alot quicker to get rid of noobies just joining for free high level troops. My clan was right full and active then we had people slow down or stop playing and now we are trying to rebuild our numbers that is my main reason for seeing the need for it, in addition to the auto kick system. Thanks for taking the time to read

How about that warning had an option for each clan to do on or off? Some clans would abandon the idea otherwise.

I see a major problem though. Say I went on holiday for two weeks, normally now you can tell the leader and elders And you will be left be, but what about this system?