Printable View
So within the clan you can pick between the members and attack each other.
With a reputation point system added for fun factor and bragging rights lol.
It would be like a version of the trophy system were you earn status points for winning against clan members. Then your score would be displayed in the clan castle to see who is stronger.
It would also give the less experienced player a chance to practice on each other to see where defences could be improved with out losing any loot.
I dont like this idea because people in your clan can make the same base design as the person i will be attacking in clan wars and I can find the best way to beat it
As said above, exploitable. Leave vanity stuff aside, it adds nothing to the game...
If players want to learn to attack and defend, they have to attack and defend. No testing grounds or sandbox mode.
Hi,
I also don't like the idea.
A clan is all about unity and collaboration. Fighting against each other is against it. If this is implemented, the powerful members will attack less powerful ones.
Also note, "Select what you want to attack" option is missing in CoC (other than "revenge")
Thank you.
Tito Dutta
(real name + village name, I do not own any clan, don't think I am inviting you by mentioning my village name)
Exactly- it would ruin the whole concept of clan wars. Trying new strategies in an attempt to beat your opponent not to 'perfect' your base design.Quote:
Originally Posted by XavierBOSS
Definite no from me.
It would take so much time to change and reconfigure your base to match the enemy for just a little bit of loot.Quote:
Originally Posted by XavierBOSS
Not to mention you would have to have all the same level defences. I'm not saying it couldn't be done I'm just saying it's unrealistic to waste the time for clan wars.
Could you explain how it could be used as an exploitable ? When your donating ,collecting loot/ farming you don't want to throw away your defence it still gives you a reason to play. something to keep you entertained During this processes of the game.Quote:
Originally Posted by Nagrarok
Not unrealistic and it doesn't take all that much time. Down in my signature there is a link to a thread with all of the details and ideas for how they could be coded around to prevent exploitation. No matter how badly you don't want to acknowledge it this would be HUGELY exploited without a robust set of rules limiting how and when it could be done.Quote:
Originally Posted by XxAndrewxX
Have you ever battled the same player twice ... Because I haven't it would be no benefit maybe they could disable being able to battle each other during clan wars to prevent what you are sayingQuote:
Originally Posted by FireThief
As said it would be like the trophy system so you would have nothing to gain by attacking low level clan members and low level clan members would have nothing to loseQuote:
Originally Posted by titodutta