Idea for DISCOURAGING clan hoppers, while keeping the integrity of the game intact

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AnonyJoe

1) "Anyone can join" - Keep donated troops upon leaving the clan
2) "Invite only" - Don't keep donated troops upon leaving the clan

Understand now?

---

You answered the wrong question. What does losing troops when you leave accomplish?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BarbarianNotKing

A more logical idea would be a donation history page or just don't keep cc troops when leaving clan. no need to be that extreme with anti hopper methods

---

OMG would someone explain how losing the stupid troops when you leave clan solves anything?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Street3

I see what you mean! So make it to where it would take 12hrs for it to switch to invite only! Giving them plenty of time to decide!

If a hopper leaves 2 hrs or less after receiving troops then they can't join another clan for 2 hrs! This includes being kicked! And if they come back on after the.12 hours is up for switching clan options then they can use their troops and not worry about consequence! If a hopper joins and does not take troops he does not have to worry about consequence!

---

There should never be a penalty for this. There are many many legit reasons to leave a clan.

_x

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

There should never be a penalty for this. There are many many legit reasons to leave a clan.

---

Losing troops would keep the clans that are looking for actual members and not experience for donations, to be able to do so! The penalty would only have a two hour timer in which it could keep track of whether troops were donated! And if the player leaves in those two hours or is kicked then they lose troops if kicked then they also receive the two hour penalty! Plus as I said if they already used the troops before leaving then they get a two hour penalty!

Losing troops is supposed to curve hoppers away from those looking for members and not just donating for easy experience! And those looking for experience would have more hoppers to donate to!

At higher levels donating troops to people who plan on leaving may not be a big deal, how ever it's not just higher levels with clans! If it was you wouldn't receive a town hall until level 8! The option could have a check box in clan edit or supercell could implement it in invite only and open clans! Both options would need to be visible in clan description so that, those looking for troops would know which clan to go to!

Sorry if this post is a little sloppy I have a separate thread that I have been editing in order to keep the idea in a neater way versus scrolling post to post trying to get the whole idea!

Sorry I know I am not supposed to make a thread of one that already exist but if I had an option to make it private I would but I have to order the ideas in order to understand it fully!