Too many clans....what's the solution? Post your ideas and thoughts Clashers.

I see too many clans there and everyone trying to recruit in global makes it time wasting chat. Also lots of clans are not full strength that makes them inefficient and players motivation goes down. Lots of guys become more inactive or suffer from not getting castle troops. We need a solution for this. I have some ideas and I am sure that many of you also have great ideas to counter this problem and make clans more efficient and full strength.

1) Too many clans: COC should raise the gold limit for making new clans. Also there should be some clan cost for each clan to pay divided among the clan members....lets say 25000 gold. The more the members in a clan are....the less the cost per member and more members pay less cost per each member. That would be incentive to join a bigger clan.
2) There should be some restriction for clans such as minimum number of participants after few days of making a new clan, for example minimum 10 members must be in a clan after 15 days of establishing it.. That way lots of inactive clans will clean out from the system and people will be more active and motivated by joining bigger clans.
3) There should be some limit on each player on the number of clans they can join in 2 week period....that way clan hopping can be tamed and players will be more responsible.

I hope others have great ideas to make this game more attractive . Near full strength clans are fun and provide motivation to play this game more....that way wars will be more fun too.

Just sayin u said lots of guys but some girls play clash as well u know

I quite like the idea to prevent hoppers;)

I just want to comment on number 2, there are many clans who create a "vacation" clan, for members who will be out during war or a few weeks. Somewhere to put there accounts so they can easily come back to their clan. That idea would ruin these clans.

oh also about the hoppers thing, I never see the problem with hoppers, free xp cool, or just dont donate to em and boot em if they request in the first few minutes. But sometimes people just dont like your clan cause its not what they thought and leave? Anyways... That hopper thing would ruin feeder and family clans, itd limit their ability to visit throughout the clans in the family.

Inactive clans are slowly being cleared by Supercell, with every update. It's not their fault more and more appear every day.

I also disagree with most of the changes you suggested, it's not fair. They will only recieve a lot more complaints, they need to please the majority here, not the minority.
Whats wrong with a high number of clans anyway, they are not harming you.

I do like the hopping solution, but one flaw. Most clans have families, like my clan, and I like to visit other clans in the family. How do you get around that?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by EpicChris

Inactive clans are slowly being cleared by Supercell, with every update. It's not their fault more and more appear every day.

I also disagree with most of the changes you suggested, it's not fair. They will only recieve a lot more complaints, they need to please the majority here, not the minority.
Whats wrong with a high number of clans anyway, they are not harming you.

I do like the hopping solution, but one flaw. Most clans have families, like my clan, and I like to visit other clans in the family. How do you get around that?

---

Agreed.

Although hoppers are quite annoying.

What exactly is the issue you're trying to solve? None of your reasoning makes sense. So what if people recruit? Describe how they are inefficient. Explain how having your clan destroyed by some silly arbitrary rules is better than not receiving troops quickly.

Also:

1. This would be trivial to abuse and is ruled out.
2. What do you have against small clans with a tight knit group of friends?
3. This would make clan visiting impossible as well as ruin clan families that consist of a number of individual clans.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by EpicChris

Inactive clans are slowly being cleared by Supercell, with every update. It's not their fault more and more appear every day.

I also disagree with most of the changes you suggested, it's not fair. They will only recieve a lot more complaints, they need to please the majority here, not the minority.
Whats wrong with a high number of clans anyway, they are not harming you.

I do like the hopping solution, but one flaw. Most clans have families, like my clan, and I like to visit other clans in the family. How do you get around that?

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CaveJohnson

Agreed.

Although hoppers are quite annoying.

---

Hoppers are annoying, but besides being annoying what damage do they do? Also you realize that you can completely eliminate them by simply managing your clan properly right?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dahimi

Hoppers are annoying, but besides being annoying what damage do they do? Also you realize that you can completely eliminate them by simply managing your clan properly right?

---

I know I made a point about hoppers, but here I completely agree.

Managing your clan effectively will reduce hoppers, some clans stay you have to say a certain time before requesting troops. Policies like this are easy to enforce, and even prove loyalty.


Also, donating is technically XP, they maybe annoying and take a bit of elixir, but if your donating PEKKA, or witches to every newcomer. When the hopper leaves, it's just a karmic ***** slap. (Yes, I censored that myself to avoid swearing, but you get the idea).

no.

10 charsss