Clan War Donations

Clan wars is pretty big now, and most clans do it once or twice a week, including my clan. My clan takes way serious and we have ran into some problems along the way, and I bet many other clans have.

Have you ever started clan wars, then as soon as preparation day comes, people in your clan donate low level troops or the wrong troops? Yes, has happened to my clan too. We have had someone not long ago donate 1 level 4 barb in every clan castle so that we cannot donate dragons or wizards, which we donate in our CW castles. So heres my Idea to solve this:

Ideas:

- In your clan war clan castle, you should be able to select which troop(s) you want donating into your CW castle, this way people cant donate low level troops. You also have to select an alternate troop(s) so if non of your members can donate what troop you want, they can donate the alternate troop(s) instead.

- You may be thinking, "Yes, thats why Supercell made it so you can ditch the troops in your clan castle which the little button". Yes, this is true, but not every member in clans are active. Sometimes, you might be wanting certain members to ditch some troops so you can donate better troops, but they not online, so you cant, and by the time they online, Clan war could have started.

- This does not effect troop levels. They cannot select which level of troop you want donating to your CW castle, just the troop.

Benefits of this:


- Hoppers, trollers etc... cannot donate low level troops into peoples clan castles.

- Members of your clan know what troops to train so that they can donate to CW castles.
I like to donate troops into CW castles and I like to know what troops I should train instead of just training any troops then it turns out no one wants that troop.

- Doesn't effect anything major in Clan Wars or the game itself.


If you don't like this Idea, fair enough, But please do not comment with something like "urgh stupid Idea, just shut up and get of the forums". Just say something like "I do not agree with this Idea, Sorry" or "I don't like this Idea, sorry".

Agree i chosed yes!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Satse

Agree i chosed yes!

---

Thankyou :)

I disagree, most clans - the clan leader (or co-leaders) is the one who wants to decide what goes into the CC.

If this was a option for the leader/co-leaders only, I would agree.

I agree, many people have problems like these. Thing is, they are trolling. Most, or all, of them understand the situation because we all play the game and understand names and levels. If they have a chance to restrict certain troops, I bet they'll just ask for dumb troops for defense. Like healers, goblins or wallbreakers.
They made an upgrade to delete troop if not wanted.

I say this: we are able to click on the troop icon, and it'll show A list of all players who donated that specific troop(s)

that'll be nice if that was in the next update. We would know who donated them, and just get rid of the problem, by kicking them.

If the problem is the members not being active to dump their cc troops, you might need to dump them.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Phyxios

I disagree, most clans - the clan leader (or co-leaders) is the one who wants to decide what goes into the CC.

If this was a option for the leader/co-leaders only, I would agree.

---

I understand what you mean here, and most clans do this, yes. But what I'm getting at is that hoppers & trollers etc... donate the wrong troops to annoy the clan, then sometimes leave. And if the members are inactive sometimes, or just cant get on, then it can hurt clan wars alot.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 15Conor

I understand what you mean here, and most clans do this, yes. But what I'm getting at is that hoppers & trollers etc... donate the wrong troops to annoy the clan, then sometimes leave. And if the members are inactive sometimes, or just cant get on, then it can hurt clan wars alot.

---

how about members with "new" status cannot donate? :P

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Phyxios

how about members with "new" status cannot donate? :P

---

Actually, thats a good idea tbh, and would help alot.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Phyxios

how about members with "new" status cannot donate? :P

---

That's weird i think. I mean if i haven't got a clan at the moment i Search for clans if i found one many people are saying first donate before you can ask troops