Player leaving clan during a war

I have a suggestion to improve clan wars and prevent players from leaving a clan during a war. We all know it's a pain, because the whole clan is penalized: the enemy clan still can earn stars from the leaving player, but that player obviously can't earn stars.

So, for a player leaving a clan durin a war, my suggestions are:
1. the other members have the ability to attack the player (like the 'Revenge' option)
2. the player can't war for the next 7 days
3. the player looses 20% of his loot

Feel free to add any suggestion to this thread.

Take care!

Martin

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by limohabs

I have a suggestion to improve clan wars and prevent players from leaving a clan during a war. We all know it's a pain, because the whole clan is penalized: the enemy clan still can earn stars from the leaving player, but that player obviously can't earn stars.

So, for a player leaving a clan durin a war, my suggestions are:
1. the other members have the ability to attack the player (like the 'Revenge' option)
2. the player can't war for the next 7 days
3. the player looses 20% of his loot

Feel free to add any suggestion to this thread.

Take care!

Martin

---

I am still against punishing a player for leaving a clan that they don't want to be in, or forcing them to stay in a clan they don't want to be in. All that will happen is they will be disruptive and cause MORE of a problem if you try to make them stay. Bad policy in general and bad idea in practice.

suggested multiple times. and as always NO

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by iceageg

I am still against punishing a player for leaving a clan that they don't want to be in, or forcing them to stay in a clan they don't want to be in. All that will happen is they will be disruptive and cause MORE of a problem if you try to make them stay. Bad policy in general and bad idea in practice.

---

I agree with you for a player being able to leave a clan. But during a war, I think the player should have consequences for leaving the clan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Phyxios

suggested multiple times. and as always NO

---

I've seen posts of preventing players from leaving clan, but not during a clan war.
Sorry if I missed some

Martin

I agree, leaving during clan wars has to be punished

If someone joins my clan who has deserted their previous clan during war, I always kick them right away. If all leaders did that, people would get the hint that deserting a clan during war is not cool.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SpacemanKermit

If someone joins my clan who has deserted their previous clan during war, I always kick them right away. If all leaders did that, people would get the hint that deserting a clan during war is not cool.

---

But probably they keep doing that.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by limohabs

I agree with you for a player being able to leave a clan. But during a war, I think the player should have consequences for leaving the clan

---

You're right. It would be much better if they were angry because you forced them to stay and they dropped one goblin for each of their battles, then started filling all clan requests with useless troops because they hated being stuck there but wanted to wait until their punishment wouldn't be enforced. Sounds like a great idea.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by iceageg

You're right. It would be much better if they were angry because you forced them to stay and they dropped one goblin for each of their battles, then started filling all clan requests with useless troops because they hated being stuck there but wanted to wait until their punishment wouldn't be enforced. Sounds like a great idea.

---

You can leave before and after clan wars, you only have to wait one day.