Allow Clan Leader to Dismiss Anyone's War Troops

Printable View

August 6th, 2014
Warble

Allow Clan Leader to Dismiss Anyone's War Troops

For exactly the same reasons it is great to be able to remove your own war CC troops, it would also be useful to allow the leadership of a clan to remove any member's troops. It would greatly simplify the tedious process of trying to get a message to one person in a 50 member clan. Currently, and this is usually an issue when a new join tries to be helpful or a mistake is made by the donator, the only recourse for very active clans whose chat log only goes back a few hours is to send out a clan mail to everyone for that one person, or hope you happen to be online at the same time to say something.
August 6th, 2014
dahimi

Nope.

You have dominion over your clan. You may kick, invite, start wars, promote, demote, or set whatever clan options there are.

Your power stops at my base. You may not dismiss my troops, rearrange my buildings, chop down my trees, tax my resources, or do anything else which affects my base.
August 6th, 2014
Phyxios

Quote:

Originally Posted by dahimi

Nope.

You have dominion over your clan. You may kick, invite, start wars, promote, demote, or set whatever clan options there are.

Your power stops at my base. You may not dismiss my troops, rearrange my buildings, chop down my trees, tax my resources, or do anything else which affects my base.

^ what he said.
August 6th, 2014
Ferrocy

Quote:

Originally Posted by dahimi

Nope.

He is not talking about messing with your base, he is talking about your "clan castle." This is like an embassy. A fellow clan member can insert units in there without your permission so why can't the leaders of the clan take them out? It is the clans property, not yours.

--Ferrocy
August 6th, 2014
dahimi

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ferrocy

He is not talking about messing with your base, he is talking about your "clan castle." This is like an embassy. A fellow clan member can insert units in there without your permission so why can't the leaders of the clan take them out? It is the clans property, not yours.

--Ferrocy

It's not the clans property at all. Who is responsible for the layout on prep day? Carrying the embassy analogy further, guess what happens when the host country decides they don't want the embassy there anymore.

Sure folks can donate, but I'm free to drop the donations at any time. Once the troops are given to me, they are mine.
August 6th, 2014
sa3er

Quote:

Originally Posted by dahimi

It's not the clans property at all. Who is responsible for the layout on prep day? Carrying the embassy analogy further, guess what happens when the host country decides they don't want the embassy there anymore.

Sure folks can donate, but I'm free to drop the donations at any time. Once the troops are given to me, they are mine.

Dear dahimi,
You're clearly judging one-sided mind only!!

As I've described in other thread it's more like a leader controlling how his country is going to war. For example a low city donates some old men to some other low city to defend in upcoming war, while the country leader comes oversees and says it is not true and with this kind of defense we are going to lose that part of the country. So must reject those old mans and receive these trained (high level troops) from strong cities.

Ok, let's say fair to your opinion, even if that's against your wired kind analysis about leader powers, a leader has the right to know who donated what troops to fellow members in a clan war.

Once again, you're free to express whatever your personal ideas and kind of thinking, in the end Supercell is the one who would make the right decision, like always.

Regards.
August 6th, 2014
toggle57

Analogy wars!!! priceless.
August 7th, 2014
Brick2025

Personal freedom will be infringed and this can be abused.
August 7th, 2014
bazvergara

Being the clan leader doesn't make you leader of anyone's village.

What if you dismiss a troop which you thought was weak but as it turned out the reason it was not dismissed by the CC owner was because it was part of his defense strategy?

war is won by cooperation and strategy.talk it over through your clan chat.
August 7th, 2014
sa3er

Quote:

Originally Posted by bazvergara

Being the clan leader doesn't make you leader of anyone's village.

What if you dismiss a troop which you thought was weak but as it turned out the reason it was not dismissed by the CC owner was because it was part of his defense strategy?

war is won by cooperation and strategy.talk it over through your clan chat.

God, are you kidding me!?
I'm talking about Clan Wars!! Did you even read what I wrote!!!?
Yea what you have in your clan in the main game, well suite yourself, but in a *WAR* people regularly follow a leader cause that's how you win a war! yeah!? I'm talking about *LEADER*, yea it is called LEADER, the one person who made the clan you're already in!

You people....I bet you are one of those evil members who do that to your leader (Donating level 1 archer to clan mates in Clan Wars!!)

Even though considering all this, having the name of people who donated in war and their donation count/troop names is must have for every clan leader.

Best Wishes.
August 7th, 2014
Kuo

Some of them dont get it! Whats happened if somebody donated you wrong troops in war clan castle while you are sleeping? Its happened to me, my bud made a mistake and i accepted. That is really very good, we all want very speifically troops or not, good idea and i hope this will implented or other way to make force donate, for example, i want level 5 wizards, 7 wiz and 2 arch. And they have 5 archers and accidentally donate me 5. When its hit at 2. It automatic close then wait for wiz' turn? That way you will get exactly amount of troops
August 7th, 2014
CREAON

Quote:

Originally Posted by dahimi

Nope.

You have dominion over your clan. You may kick, invite, start wars, promote, demote, or set whatever clan options there are.

Your power stops at my base. You may not dismiss my troops, rearrange my buildings, chop down my trees, tax my resources, or do anything else which affects my base.

Yep I agree
August 7th, 2014
SkyMage1001

I choose what I want in my CC, not the leader. If I'm away for a war, it's my fault that I didn't alert my leader, or leave the clan.
August 7th, 2014
Rapidshock

its all politics
August 7th, 2014
RogueVector

Quote:

Originally Posted by dahimi

Nope.

You have dominion over your clan. You may kick, invite, start wars, promote, demote, or set whatever clan options there are.

Your power stops at my base. You may not dismiss my troops, rearrange my buildings, chop down my trees, tax my resources, or do anything else which affects my base.

Agreeing with this as well.
August 7th, 2014
C0urt0914

Lol

Quote:

Originally Posted by dahimi

Nope.

You have dominion over your clan. You may kick, invite, start wars, promote, demote, or set whatever clan options there are.

Your power stops at my base. You may not dismiss my troops, rearrange my buildings, chop down my trees, tax my resources, or do anything else which affects my base.

Lol preach it dahimi
August 7th, 2014
sa3er

Quote:

Originally Posted by C0urt0914

Lol preach it dahimi

Yes, he's talented preacher who is trying to make a mountain out of a molehill.

Get a clan, become a leader, go to war, and maybe then, you'll understand.
Cheers.
August 7th, 2014
toggle57

Quote:

Originally Posted by Warble

For exactly the same reasons it is great to be able to remove your own war CC troops, it would also be useful to allow the leadership of a clan to remove any member's troops. It would greatly simplify the tedious process of trying to get a message to one person in a 50 member clan. Currently, and this is usually an issue when a new join tries to be helpful or a mistake is made by the donator, the only recourse for very active clans whose chat log only goes back a few hours is to send out a clan mail to everyone for that one person, or hope you happen to be online at the same time to say something.

Gotta say... I was initially liking your idea but after hearing the counter arguments I have been swayed.

I have had plenty of ideas I thought were good but sometimes you have to really listen to the other side.

There were times when I wanted to correct bad donations in a clan war so I do sympathize - but I do think that being leader should have limits - and often I think people confuse being a leader with being a controller or a dictator.

For me a leader mentors and grows a clan into a place people want be... a dictator is just a control freak and they usually have eternal problems with growing membership and holding on to it.
August 7th, 2014
Dan93

Quote:

Originally Posted by toggle57

Gotta say... I was initially liking your idea but after hearing the counter arguments I have been swayed.

I have had plenty of ideas I thought were good but sometimes you have to really listen to the other side.

There were times when I wanted to correct bad donations in a clan war so I do sympathize - but I do think that being leader should have limits - and often I think people confuse being a leader with being a controller or a dictator.

For me a leader mentors and grows a clan into a place people want be... a dictator is just a control freak and they usually have eternal problems with growing membership and holding on to it.

I agree. Yes sometimes bad troops are given in clan wars but those troops are now part of the MEMBERS defense. Yes all defense counts towards the clan in clan wars but this does not give the leader the authority to do anything about it. If they really don't like whats in the clan castle they can SUGGEST for the member to dismiss the troop/troops.
August 9th, 2014
sa3er

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dan93

If they really don't like whats in the clan castle they can SUGGEST for the member to dismiss the troop/troops.

You don't say? Tell me how can I do that when the donation is made in last minutes or if the member who got bad donation is sleep or involved with his life problems during the preparation day!? And believe me, I've tried.

It is obvious that all members count in *CLAN WAR* even 1 single star might change a result, so if you lose, all clan might loose.

It is the *duty* of leader to guide all members, help them to be better in a war and make them in good shape, and boost both their defense and attack power.

Unfortunately I don't know why you guys keep ignoring without thinking and you keep preaching me about politics sh*t which has nothing to do with my idea and this game.

It's a game for god sake and we're not trying to overthrow a government here or make you pay more taxes!!!

Okay, fine, let's just say you're completely right but I just want to know *who* donated *what* in a war, so I can know who did the bad donations and perhaps talk to them or on worst case if they kept doing that, kick them, considering they tried to make the clan mates lose in a war.
August 9th, 2014
K3mpy86

Quote:

Originally Posted by Warble

For exactly the same reasons it is great to be able to remove your own war CC troops, it would also be useful to allow the leadership of a clan to remove any member's troops. It would greatly simplify the tedious process of trying to get a message to one person in a 50 member clan. Currently, and this is usually an issue when a new join tries to be helpful or a mistake is made by the donator, the only recourse for very active clans whose chat log only goes back a few hours is to send out a clan mail to everyone for that one person, or hope you happen to be online at the same time to say something.

This +1. It is needed.

To u people (don't mess with my base u are fools).