Increase loot from winning a clan war

Currently, winning a war takes more resources than you get as a reward of winning. With placing wizards or dragons in war CC, and building dragons and hogs for the attacks, you always spend way more in elixir and dark elixir than you make back. And if you lose the war you are really negative (as it should be). It seems like you should get something for the risk.

The only bonus is gold. So maybe just increase the elixir and/or dark elixir from winning. Also possibly consider more loot for elders and/or co-leaders. These people are usually the ones filling the war CCs with the highest troops so they spend much more than the general member.

I also want to add that donating to a war CC should count as a donation! Maybe this is a bug, I don't know.

Please consider making clan wars profitable before we lose interest in doing them. Thank you!

--Ferrocy

This is in your control. Build a good clan, and as that clan improves, so will your opponents.

The better your opponents are, the bigger the bonus will be when you beat them.

Want the biggest bonus available? Take out their top two guys.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheConfuzed1

This is in your control. Build a good clan, and as that clan improves, so will your opponents.

The better your opponents are, the bigger the bonus will be when you beat them.

Want the biggest bonus available? Take out their top two guys.

---

Are you actually suggesting that for the time it takes to build and the costs involved that war loot is good?

I think the war loot is sufficient for me as a TH8. The war loot bonus I get (220K+ gold and elixir usually) handily pays off my army, which costs 85-120K elixir plus a spell or so. This leaves enough space that I can donate quite a few wizards and still profit. Plus I have the liberty to participate even when I'm shielded and don't want to break my shield. (Of course, I can't profit if I provide EVERYBODY with wizards. That's why it's called a CLAN war, not a FEW INDIVIDUALS IN A CLAN war.)

How much does your army cost? What kind of war loot are you receiving? I'm just wondering.

It is far from sufficient for the lower members. There is no reason to participate except the threat of being booted from the clan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Underrated1

How much does your army cost? What kind of war loot are you receiving? I'm just wondering.

---

I am TH8, I build 10 dragons and I can get about 240k gold and elixir. 10 level 1 dragons cost 250k, add in 3 spells is over 300k. I use level 3 dragons which cost 360k plus spells. The best land attack will use about 20 hogs, which is 800-1k dark elixir, where I earn about 450 dark elixir.

I should not be striving to break even on a WIN. Yes I could go with a more cost effective army, but this is war, not farming.

--Ferrocy

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PhilISuppose

Are you actually suggesting that for the time it takes to build and the costs involved that war loot is good?

---

In our last war, I got 1.22 mill gold and elixir, and 4k DE.

Is that good?

i loose out on elixir, but i just think its a fun challenge, and i don't mind the gold i get ;D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheConfuzed1

In our last war, I got 1.22 mill gold and elixir, and 4k DE.

Is that good?

---

Wow! I had no idea it got so high!

Ok, so I need to revise my suggestion to, "Increase war loot for TH 7-9s" because they spend more than they make when they win. Because clans are matched evenly, winning should be the reward, not being a high level.

--Ferrocy

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ferrocy

Currently, winning a war takes more resources than you get as a reward of winning. With placing wizards or dragons in war CC, and building dragons and hogs for the attacks, you always spend way more in elixir and dark elixir than you make back. And if you lose the war you are really negative (as it should be). It seems like you should get something for the risk.

The only bonus is gold. So maybe just increase the elixir and/or dark elixir from winning. Also possibly consider more loot for elders and/or co-leaders. These people are usually the ones filling the war CCs with the highest troops so they spend much more than the general member.

I also want to add that donating to a war CC should count as a donation! Maybe this is a bug, I don't know.

Please consider making clan wars profitable before we lose interest in doing them. Thank you!

--Ferrocy

---

I agree with the first part sort of, as for the donations counter towards your donation count - I don't. people can remove troops from their CC and abuse it to get their achievements and level up faster.