Printable View
Hi Supercell,
Please consider penalizing war list members who leave the clan either during the preparation day or either during the battle day.
The penalty should be 50% of resources + 50% trophies + 7d cool down period.
It's is hard enough to recruit as is but no clan should have to endure such poor behavior whereby people choose to drop out during a critical time.
Thanks,
silentbuddha
Clan: Darth Empire
That is ridiculous. Either don't start wars with new members or deal with it. With your idea, trolls could just create clans, start a war, and then abuse players so much that they'd choose to leave even with the ridiculous penalty.
Firstly, it's not always new members that leave during Prep/Battle day.Quote:
Originally Posted by MrScribbler
Secondly, I would rather there be a deterrent against those trolls than not have one.
Thirdly, instead of 7day cool down period,...how about forbidding the "drop out" from joining another clan for 7 days.
I don't believe in just dealing with it, but I do believe that we should be open minded solutions even if they are not ideal.
Thanks,
SB
This is ridiculous. Why stop there? Have SC send a hitman to their house.Quote:
Originally Posted by silentbuddha
People can and should be able to drop clan whenever they want.
Why don't you instead manage your clan better? For example, create an application process as well as a "war list" of known good members. Kick out anyone not on the list before the war starts.
Maybe you should figure out why your members don't want to stay.Quote:
Originally Posted by silentbuddha
Clearly. However, that doesn't mean it would improve the game at all.Quote:
Originally Posted by silentbuddha
So great now you have compelled these people who don't want to be in your clan to stay until the war is over. What does that get you? Do you expect these people to do a great job on their attacks? Do you expect them to not sabotage your war by leaving their TH outside in their layout? Please tell me what you've gained besides forcing unhappy people to stay in your clan.Quote:
Originally Posted by silentbuddha
Open minded? You can't be serious. You gave exactly zero thought to this whatsoever. Open minded solutions would be figuring out what actually would work best for both the game and your members.Quote:
Originally Posted by silentbuddha
Forcing people to stay in clans under threat of ridiculous penalties is best for no one.
It will never be a good idea to penalize somebody for leaving a clan they don't want to be in.
The game actually does this already. You cannot participate in another war.Quote:
Originally Posted by iceageg
As I see it, leaving your clan while in a war should prohibit wars for a bit longer than it does now. Maybe not 7d, but perhaps 4d as opposed to the current 2d.
The idea of penalizing those that leave while at war sounds good, but what about those kicked? That could be abused.
SC could make the penalty for only those that leave and not if your kicked...
Check their profile.
I don't necessarily agree with this, because you already have a war ban, why make it worse?
Hogwash. My clan family opted for a war clan. We meet there, start the war, attack, and return to our main clans.
Some go home right after the war starts, and come back on battle day. We did this to prevent having inactives during war, and to make sure that our main clans don't die on the vine while our best warriors are away.
Also, since we only let known people into the war clan, there is no possibility of a spy getting in, solving another problem that we've had in previous wars.
Using this system, we complete 100% of our attacks, which is something I have yet to see any other clan accomplish.
Farming right now? Heroes or spells down for upgrade? Don't go to war. The clan doesn't suffer as a result.
We found a way to make it work. There is no reason to penalize us for our ingenuity.
Horrible idea. Now you're just going to have people put their th outside and drop one gob per battle and then harass your chat. Great idea genius.
Just wanted you to know, I laughed at this :pQuote:
Originally Posted by dahimi
Quote:
Originally Posted by silentbuddha
The person drops an archer on 2 different war base. Then leaves. This idea is now done.
its not a penality given to somebody by sc... some times a player from ur clan may leave to other players clan and help his fellow mates for troops and return tonur clan... while he was gone if some one starts a war in the other clan it wuld be a mess so they made a cool down that he can still return to u and participate in war started by ur clanQuote:
Originally Posted by Jokke2
I either would not attack or I'd send in 100+ wallbreakers for the hell of itQuote:
Originally Posted by silentbuddha
I'd also re-design my war base.
all defenses in a far corner, th in another with the other buildings, mass walls in the middle all together.
During war there is no leave button in clan info! instead going thru brutal punishments
Why do I need to stay in a clan Simply because they started a war without my knowledge?Quote:
Originally Posted by BladeBucket
I suggest that when people have an idea for the game that they focus a lot more on describing what they think the problem or playability issue is.
Specific "solutions" from users often miss issues of possible abuse, or create problems in other areas of the game.
The architects and developers at supercell obviously know their stuff and we should trust them.
I fixed that for you Phyxios. I still think the most important argument here is forcing anybody to be in a group/clan/etc. that they don't want to be a part of is at it's very core a horrible idea.Quote:
Originally Posted by Phyxios
Not being able to take part in a war for 2 days isnt really a punishment. SC need to introduce something that doesnt allow players to hop from clan to clan whilst they're involved in a war...e.g ban them from joining a clan until the war is over?...Quote:
Originally Posted by TurtleBandits
On the other hand, if SC doesnt include a new punishment, they should allow you to visit a players profile via their war base, via the war map. This would be useful as you would be able to track down members involved in your clan war.
Nope, they most certainly do not, and if they did you would be complaining about an even worse problem than you think you have today. Detailed explanation on page 4 of the following thread . . .Quote:
Originally Posted by Jake97
http://forum.supercell.net/showthrea...qnces!!!/page4
So if just can't take a clan anymore and I leave I could lose 1000 trophies. Also someone in our clan left then came back with 12 hours left because he went to visit his brothers clan to help him out, so he should receive a ban?
This wasn't intended as a punishment but to prevent exploitation.Quote:
Originally Posted by Jokke2
Imagine being able to join 20 clans and participate in 20 wars at once? TH snipe two attacks each, even if all 20 loses, you'd make a nice pot of loot.
This was intended to prevent people from participating in more than one war at a time, not as a punishment for leaving a clan while a war was active.
I'm surprised no one pointed this out.Quote:
Originally Posted by ClashySquill
Did the OP really advocate to lose 50% of Loot AND Trophies?!
Sounds like somebody left your clan during warQuote:
Originally Posted by silentbuddha
Ehhhh how about just making a longer cool down rather then taken cups and loot away thats just ♥♥♥♥♥♥ed