Lady, you write so well and convey the feelings of so many of us very well. I gave up last night because trying to read the constant flow of distracting numbers gave me a headache. Certainly just applying statistics to such a large data set can't possibly address the problem when the number is small. I suspect that's actually the whole problem. Coders have to use large numbers and percentages.
For example, I postulate a personal example. One in 66 kids will be diagnosed with some form of autism. Doesn't sound too bad. But in my family four in six have been diagnosed with it. Becomes more of an issue doesn't it. (And I am not complaining). When looking at 200 plus boats, the numbers may look fine but when all the bad ones come at one time, it looks more like my family. And that's all I have to say about that.
I am actually doing more truck orders during this event. I thought to myself that since the profit margin in the town isn't as high, I could certainly use a bit of money, BUT (I know there is always a big BUT in one of my posts :) ) both my farms were close to leveling up so XP looked better to me than TEM for a while. Add to that the large percentage of my barn being used for non food items, tools, and metal bars. I decided to shift my focus for a little while..
Yes yes I know anything extra for doing a boat you would do anyway is like gravy, but when you weigh:
the number of items needed per boat,and
the personal event goal reward of one or two items and
most likely another green voucher
against:
the gift,and
reputation points and
progress toward those 2000 townies needed for that achievement for fewer items,
then the town usually wins.
That's why I think the events are causing the apathy the OP is talking about. You can't even count on the five diamond final reward because we haven't made the goal more times than I care to think about. There is nothing to draw us all together.
Possible solutions (to event malaise only)
Vouchers or decorations for personal goals
Special decoration for final goal
Reasonable total goal amount
Something different to spice things up (as opposed to an activity we would do anyway)
Events that don't happen every week, but maybe once a month. THEY NEED TO BE SPECIAL!
We need something that screams at us and says, " ok so you will have to ease up on your town, boats, truck orders etc for the next four days because we have something SPECIAL for you to do."
Ok I have to go sew now.

