upgrading walls!

I think when you upgrade a wall it should give you experience. The amount of experience should be twice as much as the wall level, for example:

upgrading a level 7 wall to level 8 would give you 16 experience or
upgrading a level 10 wall to level 11 would give you 22 experience.

please comment what you think

(and don't say that we don't get experience because its an instant upgrade, i spend 500k for each wall just for a few more hp and don't get a drop of experience(which you would get if you upgraded any other building on the game))

thank you:)

I don't see how it could hurt.

Then again, I don't feel that this is really necessary, as (unlike BB / HD) level makes no impact on availability of buildings.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Brenn

I don't see how it could hurt.

Then again, I don't feel that this is really necessary, as (unlike BB / HD) level makes no impact on availability of buildings.

---

thats not the point. point is, i spend 500k for a wall and would like a little reward for upgrading them

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by VLX

thats not the point. point is, i spend 500k for a wall and would like a little reward for upgrading them

---

the reward is that when attacking players see your wall, they will shudder in fear and might just skip your village.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HeavensFace

the reward is that when attacking players see your wall, they will shudder in fear and might just skip your village.

---

haha good point, i like the way you think:)

but the way i think is that people with dragons and hogs, miiight not be as fearful:p

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HeavensFace

the reward is that when attacking players see your wall, they will shudder in fear and might just skip your village.

---

I shudder in fear when I see level 9 walls..... *sigh*:rolleyes:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by VLX

thats not the point. point is, i spend 500k for a wall and would like a little reward for upgrading them

---

They're pretty easy for me. Just farm them

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ali7861

They're pretty easy for me. Just farm them

---

i a'int got no fertilizer or a hoe to farm them with... :(
but for real, i never said it was hard for me, it would just be nice to get some experience:)

I'd like a little xp for it.

That would be a little too much xp. If you do the math, you have a TH 8 and you plan to upgrade all 225 walls to level 7. Now since xp is double than the level, you get 14 xp for a level 7 wall. You multiply that by 225 you get 3150 xp out of that. And yes I know that it takes a long time to max out the walls, but ultimately in the end, you have way to much xp . So how about instead of double the xp, you keep it the same ratio, given walls aren't that important to upgrade.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TurtleBandits

That would be a little too much xp. If you do the math, you have a TH 8 and you plan to upgrade all 225 walls to level 7. Now since xp is double than the level, you get 14 xp for a level 7 wall. You multiply that by 225 you get 3150 xp out of that. And yes I know that it takes a long time to max out the walls, but ultimately in the end, you have way to much xp . So how about instead of double the xp, you keep it the same ratio, given walls aren't that important to upgrade.

---

actually, my friend, 3,150 wouldn't even get me 1 level up... i don't see how you think 3,150 is that much experience, but i see no reason to change my idea.

bummer, I missed out on my 5k experience for getting all lvl 10. that almost a lvl

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by vinnyXo

bummer, I missed out on my 5k experience for getting all lvl 10. that almost a lvl

---

haha, almost

It feels to me like it would be a relatively sensible change (and trivial to backdate for all of those wall farmers)

But what's the point?
Level doesn't mean anything in the game anyway.

While we're at it, lab upgrades and heroes ought to provide XP as well.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by VLX

actually, my friend, 3,150 wouldn't even get me 1 level up... i don't see how you think 3,150 is that much experience, but i see no reason to change my idea.

---

I'm sorry to say that 3150 is enough to level you up, or at least make up the majority of it. And also to point out, leveling up your walls will increase exponentially due to the change in town hall : wall level. EX: At th 10 you get 250 walls, all level 10, you plan to upgrade them to 11. At the end of the upgrade, you have successfully gained 5500 xp. Enough to get you 1 level plus 1/3 of the next one, depending on what level you are.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by PhilISuppose

It feels to me like it would be a relatively sensible change (and trivial to backdate for all of those wall farmers)

But what's the point?
Level doesn't mean anything in the game anyway.

While we're at it, lab upgrades and heroes ought to provide XP as well.

---

then why not take level out of the game if it doesn't mean anything? i just think it would be nice to get a little experience for upgrading walls.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TurtleBandits

I'm sorry to say that 3150 is enough to level you up, or at least make up the majority of it. And also to point out, leveling up your walls will increase exponentially due to the change in town hall : wall level. EX: At th 10 you get 250 walls, all level 10, you plan to upgrade them to 11. At the end of the upgrade, you have successfully gained 5500 xp. Enough to get you 1 level plus 1/3 of the next one, depending on what level you are.

---

ok, but you are not considering the time it takes to upgrade all walls to level 11. its not like you get 5500 right away. you work your way through all the walls and near the end, you might notice the difference it makes.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by VLX

ok, but you are not considering the time it takes to upgrade all walls to level 11. its not like you get 5500 right away. you work your way through all the walls and near the end, you might notice the difference it makes.

---

I have considered the time, shown below in the bold. All I'm saying is that the xp ratio is too large compared to other upgrades.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TurtleBandits

That would be a little too much xp. If you do the math, you have a TH 8 and you plan to upgrade all 225 walls to level 7. Now since xp is double than the level, you get 14 xp for a level 7 wall. You multiply that by 225 you get 3150 xp out of that. And yes I know that it takes a long time to max out the walls, but ultimately in the end, you have way to much xp . So how about instead of double the xp, you keep it the same ratio, given walls aren't that important to upgrade.

---

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by VLX

then why not take level out of the game if it doesn't mean anything?

---

I really wish they would and the national flags can go too.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TurtleBandits

I have considered the time, shown below in the bold. All I'm saying is that the xp ratio is too large compared to other upgrades.

---

ok, but did you consider how much XP you can get off of donating troops?!? ive seen clans that get over 8k donations which is over 8000 XP. How do you think people level up? obviously not by upgrading walls! in fact ive seen people with over 40,000 donations(40k XP) and you want to sit here and argue that once you get all level 11 walls that you get a total of 5500 and thats over a matter of months! but 40k in two weeks! if we can't get XP for wall upgrades then we might as well take away XP for troop donations.

so according to you, it would be a bad idea to get 5500 XP once all level 11 walls are done which is level up and 1/3. not to mention takes months to do.

so now lets use your logic for 40k troop donations: 40k donations= 40,000 XP
40,000 XP= about 7 levels up! in 2 weeks!

if you want to keep arguing, please go ahead, i'd like to see what you've got to say about this

The game is fine the way it is.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TurtleBandits

That would be a little too much xp. If you do the math, you have a TH 8 and you plan to upgrade all 225 walls to level 7. Now since xp is double than the level, you get 14 xp for a level 7 wall. You multiply that by 225 you get 3150 xp out of that. And yes I know that it takes a long time to max out the walls, but ultimately in the end, you have way to much xp . So how about instead of double the xp, you keep it the same ratio, given walls aren't that important to upgrade.

---

Thats what around a level of Xp whats the problem with getting a level from wall upgrades its a ton of gold i think when u collect and spend gold u should be rewarded

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by VLX

then why not take level out of the game if it doesn't mean anything? i just think it would be nice to get a little experience for upgrading walls.

---

Good idea take level out of the game.
Much better fix than adding XP for random stuff.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by VLX

ok, but did you consider how much XP you can get off of donating troops?!? ive seen clans that get over 8k donations which is over 8000 XP. How do you think people level up? obviously not by upgrading walls! in fact ive seen people with over 40,000 donations(40k XP) and you want to sit here and argue that once you get all level 11 walls that you get a total of 5500 and thats over a matter of months! but 40k in two weeks! if we can't get XP for wall upgrades then we might as well take away XP for troop donations.

so according to you, it would be a bad idea to get 5500 XP once all level 11 walls are done which is level up and 1/3. not to mention takes months to do.

so now lets use your logic for 40k troop donations: 40k donations= 40,000 XP
40,000 XP= about 7 levels up! in 2 weeks!

if you want to keep arguing, please go ahead, i'd like to see what you've got to say about this

---

If you want to think that this is arguing go ahead, for I have not countered your idea. In fact, all I was implying that upgrades compared to this is unbalanced, and you should consider changing the ratio. And the reason why it is OK to get xp for donations is because you are HELPING others. This is as far as I will take it fyi, because I feel like I am being way to childish about it now. Lets just bury the hatchet and just call it.

Calm Down mates.

No one wants an infraction or a closed thread..

On Topic:
It wont really make a diffenece,
But ifit's implemented,I guess it will be a bit helpful