Clan Hopper Solution

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by danielgooding1979

Good idea RazerWolff .


Maybe a 24hr to & 7 Day automatic Re-joining restriction from returning to clan for anyone hopping within a time frame.

The time frame should be withing days to a week maybe.:cool:

---

Or make a clan blacklist that leader and coleaders can access preventing them from rejoining entirely.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by RazerWolff

But i have to wonder, whats the point of xp when trophies are the dominant factor deciding rank, unless they both work with eachother to decide rank?

---

When I recruit, I look at level not trophies. There are some terrible players in crystal and up leagues.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ninja352

When I recruit, I look at level not trophies. There are some terrible players in crystal and up leagues.

---

Good point. I just wanted clarification.

The only trouble with leader and co leaders having a choice in black listing is that it could be open to abuse.
Good idea though :cool:.

How would you implement this? It stores what troops are in the CC, not who donated them.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Brenn

How would you implement this? It stores what troops are in the CC, not who donated them.

---

were talking about removing troops from the clan castle when you leave a clan, as this will debilitate clan hopper and in order to prevent the xp farming mentioned on the first page, we are adding blacklisting to prevent clan hoopers from rejoining.
EDIT: im sure supercell wont have a problem attaching a name to the troops.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ninja352

Then they join again, you donate and get xp. They leave, join again, you donate and get xp... See where I'm going with this?

Not gonna happen.

---

If there's still the normal 20 minutes wait to request time, how is this any different than dropping the units into the goblins?

Nothing is going to stop a hopper from just staying in your clan until they use the troops and then leave.

Hoppers shouldn't be a problem to avoid if your clan has ways of preventing them. One way of stopping hoppers is by establishing a rule that they must donate at least once before they request themselves; the rule could be added to the clan description or just told to the player once they join. If anyone requests instantaneously after joining and being informed what they should do before requesting, then you know you've got yourself a hopper that should be kicked immediately.

It's that simple.

This eliminates the purpose of ALL request N' leave clans. Donating is xp. Personally, I love hoppers. Free xp for me, and free troops for them. Everyone wins

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ninja352

You're welcome, if it weren't exploitable I would like the idea.

---

It's no more exploitable than normal, because even though the troops would disappear, there would still be cool down, and so it would still be the same result as if a member just dumped the troops and waited 20 minutes to request again