TH8 Bases- Which is Best?

Which is the best anti-hog base?

Base 1
http://i.imgur.com/10u4vd3.png
Base 2
http://www.jayceooi.com/wp-content/u...i-Hog-Base.jpg
Base 3
http://i.imgur.com/YCswT5G.png

I say base 1, but I would switch the wizard towers and mortars because mortars have a slow rate of fire.

Anyone else think base number 1?
Or base 2?
Or base 3?
Please explain

Base #2 cuz u can put two giant bombs next to each other, which will exterminate the hogs when attacking, and especially that it has a pretty wide cc radius, and people are often hesitant when they see a base with a lot of space so they can't speculate where the traps are. Hope I helped u!!

Probably #2, CC is centralized and what Mohlem said, 2 giant bombs will destory them

I don't like base 1 because the castle isn't centralized and is lureable, so I would say either 2 or 3.

Number 1 is my personal favorite out of the three.

I like number 1 because it looks like a base that can defend from almost any type of attack.

test them all. anti hog bases might not be the way to go since most people who are somewhat serious about clan wars know they are nerfed. try finding a base that is good against most attacks and can flip/bomb hogs if they dare jump over your walls

number 3 uses traps best imo, plus it has the centralized cc.
also, it seems to be a larger base, which means it defends better against non-hog armies as well.