Printable View
So do you know how tiring it is to find a clan but there are so many people that only have 1 person in them??? well i think supercell needs to remove them because they just waste your time finding a clan and if you wanna visit somebody, you see soomany clans with just 1 person in them and sometimes you cant find the clan that you wanna visit because there are so many of those clans. they are inactive and dont do anything. it would be better to just remove all of them to stop this!
All clans start with one person, it isn't another persons buisness to mess with somones game preference. My advice to you is to search these forums to find a worthy clan, it is much easier then using the game. Good luck searching!
I don't see how this would help though, it only gets rid of them. There is really no benefit.Quote:
Originally Posted by BlueKnight12
I understand that but they are inactive and when i wanna find a clan to visit, i cant find them because there are so many 1 person clans
What do you mean "Visit"? If you are currently not in a clan, and you click Join Clan in the clan section of your chat, then it gives a list of clans that have 30-40 members. I have never seen one that only had one.Quote:
Originally Posted by BlueKnight12
Absolutely. There are so many fake North 44s that when you search for it the real one doesnt come up. At least add some order to how the search results come up (either show clans with the most members or trophies).
Nope. If I want to have a one person clan, that's my business.
Dude, all people start off with one person in their Clan. Some people plan to grow their Clan. You cannot just restrict people from making Clans even if they are the only person in there. They have done nothing wrong. Supercell should not remove these. They are innocent people that want more members. Have a heart.Quote:
Originally Posted by BlueKnight12
Overall Opinion: Out of the box, but not out on the right side of the box. Thumbs down because this idea only hurts the game.
:rolleyes:
just go to the top clans tab to find the real North 44. Same goes for any other top clan that has copy cat clans.Quote:
Originally Posted by reddy4u2
I'm sorry, but, "I can't", shouldn't be a reason for SC to impliment a change that would affect a larg portion of the game community.Quote:
Originally Posted by BlueKnight12
There have been similar requests before.
Usually though they ask for clans that are entirely inactive to be removed.
Personally I don't see the point.
If you're dumb enough to call your clan FIRE CLAN or NORTH 44 or DARK WIZARDS or any of the other common names, you deserve not to be able to be found easily.
inactive clans should be closed or hidden from search
What you need, is a filter to order, as well as select based on clan size.
Guys when i search for a clan, there are too many inactive one person clans i mean we should get rid of the inactive one person clans because when i search for a clan, there are too many 1 person clans in the way so you cant find the clan that you wanna join because of them and i joined a few and they where tons of hoppers and inactive leaders that havent talked in forever (found one since last year). its just annoying
So people will just lose the money they put into it because of your inconvience.... To some that 40k is a lot.... At least I think thats how much it costs...
Also could not agree more with thisQuote:
Originally Posted by PhilISuppose
No, dont get rid of any inactives. Alot of people including myself collect alot of resources from the inactives lol. I really dont think the 1 man clans are really that big of an issue.Quote:
Originally Posted by BlueKnight12
He wasnt saying get rid of inactive players just inactive clansQuote:
Originally Posted by otis85
Ah, yes. That makes perfect since. Then the player would just be clanless. Then I dont see anything wrong with getting rid of the 1 man clans if they have been sitting inactive for a couple months or so. But like some have said in the tread if someone wants to have their own clan by themselves, thats cool too. As long as they stay active. Can SC even tell how much activity the clans have? Also, I'm not a computer wiz at all so this is a leget question, would it help with SC lagging if they cleaned out all the inactive clans?Quote:
Originally Posted by Swimmer
i think it would really help if they did tho
I get what your saying but removing all one person clans is not a good idea because you would get rid of the start of clans if they were to remove one person clans it would need to be within reason like when was last time they attacked and if not within 1 month then remove the person from clan and delete clan entirely but I don't see how they could do that so I don't agree with that ideaQuote:
Originally Posted by BlueKnight12
That is a good idea for what supercell should add but it'd take a lot of work but would have many benefits for players but I'm not sure if they'd make it because it doesn't attract new people to play or keep players from playing like a new troops or defense doesQuote:
Originally Posted by Kruzkal
So like i said, removing the inactive 1 person clans would make sense and save peoples time looking for a clan!
The simple answer is to let 1 person clans exist for the season. At the end of each season, all one person clans get removed. It is very easy to recreate a clan if needed.
Please do not bump the thread if you already made a new one the same thing.
there are legitimate reasons for a person to want to park by themselves in a clan for a period of time. (Armed services members do it a lot for just one example) Also they paid for that clan so there is an issue with taking it without their consent. And not matter what their reason its not right to just rip it out from under them.
Why are these guys searching for clans not just using the filters to have it not return any clans below a certain number. Even a 3-4 member clan might not be good and if you are searching for an active war clan maybe you want to consider filtering off anything with less than 10. Problem solved.
Edit, I just realized this is a very old thread recently bumped by a fresh spawn. Most of this commentary was before they added the filtering and at that point in time it was a legitimate frustration.
SC has addressed this by adding the filtering capability (is the fresh spawn aware?).They had to do it that way because for the reasons I give above they can't just delete them.
How can a clan start without there being atleast 1 person at one time?
#WhereDidLogicGo?
Bear in mind this thread was made before advanced clan searches. Although people still want 1 man clans gone?
My point exactly. But I think its just the one the bumped the thread and being fresh spawn he may still be in the process of learning the game.Quote:
Originally Posted by Keepo
I think that clans with no activity whatsoever (no badges AND no donations) for two consecutive seasons should disband automatically.
Or at least allow the settings for advanced settings retain themselves so i dont have to move the trophies to 20k and the number of players to 40 every single time.
The problem is that people that made themselves a long term parking space tend to need longer than that. Service people can be months. But they want to keep their clans and win record stats for when they return and wake it up again.Quote:
Originally Posted by Gama321
The filtering is SCs fix. Guys that are now saying that's too9 hard to use a filter I don't know.
This is very trueQuote:
Originally Posted by rwelshjr
If thats the case then they should at least not show up on searches then, if theyre not active and nobody's home its not like you would join anyway.Quote:
Originally Posted by rwelshjr
Sorry, I searched but did not find this thread until after I posted and then this one showed up... I would have deleted my new thread if I could have and just made the "when the season ends" suggestion here since I didn't see anyone make that minor suggestion before.Quote:
Originally Posted by HydroPenguin
i suppose that keeping a clan around just for the war record somewhat makes sense, but it would be nice if the basic search "randomized" results in a way that pushed inactive clans to the bottom.
Hence the "at the end of the season" suggestion.... But it doesn't matter now ;-)Quote:
Originally Posted by Experience