Misleading number of TROOPS DONATED

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zombiebender

Then I would not like to see this change.

---

What about letting the leader select which calculation type he wants?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Moseszator

Lol I feel like an extremist now... I don't even use my CC troops for offence, they are too important for protecting my resources

---

If you have an active clan in which every member donates you wouldn't worry about that. I could easily get them re-filled if I use them on raids.

A net amount isn't a good idea, it would be better if donations showed like this for example...

.............................| Troops donated | Troops Recieved |
ChaoticNight .....................350................... 300
Clan Elder

It would also be good if you could click on a clannies name which showed their donations for the day,week, month, year, and since records began!!!

I would love to see troops donated and troops received as well as last login.

Troops received and troops donated would be great, there is also space available for it.

I would love to see donated and received as well. Not that I have a problem in our clan. We are heavy donators and no one is selfish. Last week one guy donated 10097 just for fun. There are also many circumsatnces that come into play. During a trophy push some players may donate only archers while normally they would donate drags and pekkas. Some gpeople may max out elixir while waiting for an ugrade and donate nonstop and not request at all. Sometimes i'm saving that last little bit of elixir for a needed upgrade so I will stop donating tier 3 troops but archers are easy enough. Lots of things skew the numbers. You should know if you have selfish players or not without the numbers....

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by koshi

hmm i dont really like the "net value"... doesnt really say much someon could donate like 1000 and request 1100, and show -100. Meaning he's selfish?

Also there will allways be people showing negative or there will be no people showing positive.

Would be cool if it showed troops requested and troops donated. But the "net value" can give a wrong impression aswell

---

I agree. It would seem like the person is "selfish" just because he is in an active clan.

I think the current system is good the way it is.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Moseszator

The number of troops donated is not a good representation of "who your most valuable member is" (as stated in the update).

Number of troops donated should be calculated by:

No. of troops donated - No. of troops recieved. This calculates the net value of the player's actual donations.

Think about it: If a selfish player only donates after he "recovers back" troops from others, his net donation will be close to 0.

Do you people agree?

---

Clan members who would actually play and use their donated troops have the opportunity to boost overall clan donations if they would simply request. Having high donators is nice, but if they hardly ever request, that's less opportunity for donation participation.

Members need to request more often, and Supercell needs to include an upgrade that allows leaders to monitor the number of times a request is made (not how many troops were received). Remember, clan castles are not always at the same level, so many times, clan castles go unfilled as their incomplete green bar scrolls down the chat unnoticed by members who don't bother to review the chat history when entering.

I think a new system in which they showed what types of troops donated would be great. So that numbers inflated with giants could be seen.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by drakk

I think a new system in which they showed what types of troops donated would be great. So that numbers inflated with giants could be seen.

---

Only xp points are higher when donating, not quantity donated.