Misleading number of TROOPS DONATED

The number of troops donated is not a good representation of "who your most valuable member is" (as stated in the update).

Number of troops donated should be calculated by:

No. of troops donated - No. of troops recieved. This calculates the net value of the player's actual donations.

Think about it: If a selfish player only donates after he "recovers back" troops from others, his net donation will be close to 0.

Do you people agree?

+1 Agreed.


pinser who thinks this is a good idea

Agreed and I would love this in the next update.

hmm i dont really like the "net value"... doesnt really say much someon could donate like 1000 and request 1100, and show -100. Meaning he's selfish?

Also there will allways be people showing negative or there will be no people showing positive.

Would be cool if it showed troops requested and troops donated. But the "net value" can give a wrong impression aswell

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by koshi

hmm i dont really like the "net value"... doesnt really say much someon could donate like 1000 and request 1100, and show -100. Meaning he's selfish?

Also there will allways be people showing negative or there will be no people showing positive.

Would be cool if it showed troops requested and troops donated. But the "net value" can give a wrong impression aswell

---

This.

Rather than showing a net, it should show both the donated as well as recieved.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by koshi

hmm i dont really like the "net value"... doesnt really say much someon could donate like 1000 and request 1100, and show -100. Meaning he's selfish?

Also there will allways be people showing negative or there will be no people showing positive.

Would be cool if it showed troops requested and troops donated. But the "net value" can give a wrong impression aswell

---

I second this as well. :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by koshi

hmm i dont really like the "net value"... doesnt really say much someon could donate like 1000 and request 1100, and show -100. Meaning he's selfish?

Also there will allways be people showing negative or there will be no people showing positive.

Would be cool if it showed troops requested and troops donated. But the "net value" can give a wrong impression aswell

---

Too many numbers will confuse players, especially kids. We just need 1 standard net calculation.

I don't really care for this anymore. Well I probably would have if I'm still the Clan Leader I guess. But I have given that position up to get away from the pressure and get to enjoy the game more.

Personally I know I donate more than I receive for several reasons.
1) I'm probably one of the most frequently online player in our clan, not that our clan is inactive, but because I get to play while I'm also working since I don't have a very busy job :o
2) I've been overflowing with elixir these past few weeks and have been cooking lvl 3 dragons before I log off some of which I donate some I use for a fun attack
3) Finally, I'm finding myself not using the CC troops in offense as frequently as I used to which was every chance I got. Now I only use them to bail me out, unless someone donated a dragon, or like atm I have a lvl 1 P.E.K.K.A. in my castle, I'd use it as soon as I decide to break the shield some level 50ish th9 noob gave me. ;)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by silentwill

I don't really care for this anymore. Well I would have if I'm still the Clan Leader I guess. Personally I know I donate more than I receive for several reasons.
1) I'm probably one of the most frequently online player in our clan, not that our clan is inactive, but because I get to play while I'm also working since I don't have a very busy job :o
2) I've been overflowing with elixir these past few weeks and have been cooking lvl 3 dragons before I log off some of which I donate some I use for a fun attack
3) Finally, I'm finding myself not using the CC troops in offense as frequently as I used to which was every chance I got. Now I only use them to bail me out, unless someone donated a dragon, or like atm I have a lvl 1 P.E.K.K.A. in my castle, I'd use it as soon as I decide to break the shield some level 50ish th9 noob gave me. ;)

---

Lol I feel like an extremist now... I don't even use my CC troops for offence, they are too important for protecting my resources

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Moseszator

Too many numbers will confuse players, especially kids. We just need 1 standard net calculation.

---

Then I would not like to see this change.