Better Way for Revenging your Base!

Printable View

July 25th, 2014
purp906

2 Attachment(s)

Better Way for Revenging your Base!

Hey Clash Community,

I believe it's safe to say that everyone has been attacked by hundreds of different players. I don't know about all of you guys/girls but after every time i get attacked I do these couple steps:
1.) I review how much i lost or gained
2.) what I can improve on
3.) finally, I see if I can destroy the person who attacked me in the first place.

When I get my troops ready and decide to revenge my base typically two messages pop up "Cant Attack, player has active shield" or "Cant Attack, Player is Online".
(pictures Below)
Attachment 54625
Attachment 54626

Now when the player is online, it's okay, usually within 10-15 minutes the player gets offline and you can go about revenging your base.

when the player has an active shield you really don't have the slightest idea of when that players shield will be disabled.

My idea is to implement how many hours are on the persons shield when you decide to revenge your base.
so for example:

the person you wish to revenge on has an active shield, so you will get get a little red message saying
"Can't Attack, Player has Active Shield!"

with having the amount of time left on their shield the message would look like this

(lets say the player has a 7 hour shield left)

"Can't Attack!, Player has 7 hours Active Shield"

thanks for reading you guys and I look forward to your opinions on this, if you want to check out my base on the game look up "ANEMALS" in the clan search, my name is ED on the game.

thanks again,

eddie
July 25th, 2014
johnnybro1234

This is a simple yet great idea!
July 25th, 2014
QuantumChief

Something like this has been ruled out because it has something to do with privacy I guess.
July 25th, 2014
Giovannatta

Yessss

I like it a lot!
July 25th, 2014
purp906

oh, well hopefully it's different enough to not be ruled out haha. but thanks for the info, this was my first "blog" so i hope i didn't butcher it lol

Quote:

Originally Posted by QuantumChief

Something like this has been ruled out because it has something to do with privacy I guess.
July 25th, 2014
AxionXD

Another terrible revenge idea.

The easier you make it to revenge someone, the easier it will be for other to revenge you.

So unless you are a terrible raider and rely on quantity rather than quality, I can understand why you need all the hand holding you are requesting.

But any decent player who raids well and gets great loot will have a lot of enemies out there.

The revenge system is fine the way it is.
July 26th, 2014
purp906

how is this making it so terrible. it will just show how long their shield is up so you don't have to randomly keep checking. I don't revenge often but if i can take the guy who attacked me, of course im going to try and get some of my resources back. this has nothing to do with hand holding, it's far from it. it will just show how long their shields up. it won't tell you, for example, what troops are in the clan castle and how you should attack the base to win. now that's hand holding. the idea that I emplied is far from hand holding... I disagree with you.

Quote:

Originally Posted by AxionXD

Another terrible revenge idea.

The easier you make it to revenge someone, the easier it will be for other to revenge you.

So unless you are a terrible raider and rely on quantity rather than quality, I can understand why you need all the hand holding you are requesting.

But any decent player who raids well and gets great loot will have a lot of enemies out there.

The revenge system is fine the way it is.
July 26th, 2014
luk3namop

Quote:

Originally Posted by AxionXD

Another terrible revenge idea.

The easier you make it to revenge someone, the easier it will be for other to revenge you.

So unless you are a terrible raider and rely on quantity rather than quality, I can understand why you need all the hand holding you are requesting.

But any decent player who raids well and gets great loot will have a lot of enemies out there.

The revenge system is fine the way it is.

Axion, from what I remember you were more respectful and nicer than this. You seem to be shooting down a lot of half decent ideas instead of helping them out. I was like that once, all you have to do to get a better feeling towards the forums as a whole (idiots, repeat threads, ruled out ideas, trolls) is take a 7-10 days break from the forums. When you get back you will feel better I promise. By the way not trying to be rude I'm just letting you know what I think I see and how I've fixed it.

As for this idea, it isn't terrible but I would have to agree that the current revenge system is just fine. What I do is if I'm ready to revenge a base I check on it every time I finish a raid or if I'm listening to music after every song. I've caught 40 of my last 50 revenges with their shields down no problem.
July 26th, 2014
purp906

thanks for taking the logical approach Luk3 and yes some people may think differently but this forum is specifically for ideas, new ideas. I thought my idea was worth sharing so I posted it. I didn't intend to start an argument, that was brought up entirely from axion.

Quote:

Originally Posted by luk3namop

Axion, from what I remember you were more respectful and nicer than this. You seem to be shooting down a lot of half decent ideas instead of helping them out. I was like that once, all you have to do to get a better feeling towards the forums as a whole (idiots, repeat threads, ruled out ideas, trolls) is take a 7-10 days break from the forums. When you get back you will feel better I promise. By the way not trying to be rude I'm just letting you know what I think I see and how I've fixed it.

As for this idea, it isn't terrible but I would have to agree that the current revenge system is just fine. What I do is if I'm ready to revenge a base I check on it every time I finish a raid or if I'm listening to music after every song. I've caught 40 of my last 50 revenges with their shields down no problem.
July 27th, 2014
AxionXD

Quote:

Originally Posted by luk3namop

Axion, from what I remember you were more respectful and nicer than this. You seem to be shooting down a lot of half decent ideas instead of helping them out. I was like that once, all you have to do to get a better feeling towards the forums as a whole (idiots, repeat threads, ruled out ideas, trolls) is take a 7-10 days break from the forums. When you get back you will feel better I promise. By the way not trying to be rude I'm just letting you know what I think I see and how I've fixed it.

As for this idea, it isn't terrible but I would have to agree that the current revenge system is just fine. What I do is if I'm ready to revenge a base I check on it every time I finish a raid or if I'm listening to music after every song. I've caught 40 of my last 50 revenges with their shields down no problem.

I understand and i usually am better than this but this is the second thread of the same topic.

Revenging doesn't need fixing.

There is is no reason to mess with it. If you mess with it, if you make it easier to revenge, you will become easier to revenge. How difficult is that to understand?

I've caught plenty of revenges that deserved to be revenged and I've been revenged. If I were revenged everytime I got a nice 500k raid, id never have loot and neither would any of you. The balance of revenge is fine and doesn't need modification.

I promise you, if they made revenge easier, you'd have as much outrage as the king nerf, loot reduction and ghosting has gotten.