Idea for inactive and clan war drop outs

Printable View

July 21st, 2014
Cory19750103

Idea for inactive and clan war drop outs

We have all had it happen...declare war and somebody doesn't participate, either don't attack or quit the clan leaving unused attacks for your war...others have suggested an 'opt out of war' option that would mess with the matching system....so what I am proposing is really quite simple...in the case of a hopper: you have two villages, your main and a war village, allow a leader, co or elder to essentially take control of the war village and use the available attacks, they would use their own elixir, gain extra war win bonus but be restricted to the level/capabilities of the village they took over....in other words my village is maxed th 10 and I take over a th 7 war village, I would only have th 7 troops, spells etc to work with...essentially this allows a clan to recover when hoppers hit mid-war.... Now in the case of inactive players during the war the same can be done if they still have 2 attacks left within say 3 hours of the end of the war.

Just to clarify: just because MY troops are maxed, doesn't mean I will be able to field maxed troops...I can only produce and field exactly what is available to the inactive or hopper.
July 22nd, 2014
BigDarrick

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cory19750103

We have all had it happen...declare war and somebody doesn't participate, either don't attack or quit the clan leaving unused attacks for your war...others have suggested an 'opt out of war' option that would mess with the matching system....so what I am proposing is really quite simple...in the case of a hopper: you have two villages, your main and a war village, allow a leader, co or elder to essentially take control of the war village and use the available attacks, they would use their own elixir, gain extra war win bonus but be restricted to the level/capabilities of the village they took over....in other words my village is maxed th 10 and I take over a th 7 war village, I would only have th 7 troops, spells etc to work with...essentially this allows a clan to recover when hoppers hit mid-war.... Now in the case of inactive players during the war the same can be done if they still have 2 attacks left within say 3 hours of the end of the war.

Just to clarify: just because MY troops are maxed, doesn't mean I will be able to field maxed troops...I can only produce and field exactly what is available to the inactive or hopper.

I am going to have to say no to this for a couple of reasons. As someone who has played for 18-19 months, I have a lot more experience than a TH 7 guy that just hopped out. Part of the war experience is everyones diverse attack strategies, good/bad and indifferent. As frustrating as it is to watch some of my guys attack lol....it is work in progress for me and my co-leaders to make us better and help our clan grow. It certainly would not be fair to the opposing clan.

And I can't tell you how many times I have had clan mates come in and attack in the last 3 hours. We had almost ten attacks today (out of 80) alone. They would have been pretty upset if I hijacked their attacks.
July 22nd, 2014
Cory19750103

Quote:

Originally Posted by BigDarrick

I am going to have to say no to this for a couple of reasons. As someone who has played for 18-19 months, I have a lot more experience than a TH 7 guy that just hopped out. Part of the war experience is everyones diverse attack strategies, good/bad and indifferent. As frustrating as it is to watch some of my guys attack lol....it is work in progress for me and my co-leaders to make us better and help our clan grow. It certainly would not be fair to the opposing clan.

And I can't tell you how many times I have had clan mates come in and attack in the last 3 hours. We had almost ten attacks today (out of 80) alone. They would have been pretty upset if I hijacked their attacks.

I agree to an extent... However this IS a social game and during some of our wars several of our members are at my home sharing ideas and strategies, often a more experienced player does an attack for a less experienced player, how is this any different? If we have and can do it so do others...my clan is small 17 members...6 of them live under the same roof...several others in the same town, Perhaps this would only truly work for hoppers...