Hopper solution, and it will work almost entirely!

People join, and leave clans at little cost.
Actually there is no cost?

What needs to be done is 10, maybe 20, gems included to join clans.

Gems are very important, and considered valuable.

Also, if you cannot afford to pay the ammount of gems needed, then you cannot join.

But you can keep invites, of course.

You can get up to, I believe, 6 gems a day? Maybe 5?

This solution will stop hoppers, motivate people to buy more gems, and let people understand the value of gems.

This solution will work!

You amazing friend,
Kevin Monette.

Too bad if you don't buy gems....:(

What's wrong with hoppers? Unload whatever troops on em to get fin or you could just not donate to them OR boot em.. Your problems solved there

Change it to you if you leave a clan you cannot joi. Another for 20 min and you need to donate before requesting

Just tell people to donate before requesting.

Sorry I'm 100% against this idea. Though the 20 min pause between joining clans (unless you're given an invite) I quite like. The whole gem cost is a little extreme. I often go around clans offering help and helping them build up. I am far from a clan hopper since I hardly ever even request troops. :eek:

So i needa wait 20mins when going to our feeder clan to help out? No. There's allllot of clan family's out thereand itd just ruin their clans. Hoppers are seriously not a big deal. There's a kick button for a reason!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ayyyyyema

What's wrong with hoppers?

---

The hoppers I have a problem with are the mid-term hoppers. The ones that join for 1-2 days, make the cut into your next clan war, then leave your clan during prep day or during battle day, before using up any of their attacks so that you are automatically 2 attacks short against the other clan (similar to earning an automatic two zero-star attacks).

These people are a nuisance and can mean the difference between a war win or loss in a close war.

Or there could be an option where if a hopper leaves , an elder of the clan the hopper leaves has the option to not let the hopper join any clan for one entire day.

Not a fan personally. My clan has a feeder and I am hopping to and from that and the main clan. This would kill my gems.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 00Neel

Or there could be an option where if a hopper leaves , an elder of the clan the hopper leaves has the option to not let the hopper join any clan for one entire day.

---

Easily abused.

The only problem with hopper is war, a better solution is just prevent new member from going to war, There is already a new tag in place. SC need to make them not participate in war.

But allow elder+/leader to promote new to simple member so the people you know can participate in war that starting.

Other than that you can just ignore hopper. If they ask without donating just make a rules and don't donate to them.

Any cost is detrimental to people that have family of clan that need to go around multiple clans and have legitimate reason to hop,

Also if your looking for a new clan and you find a bad clan full of rude people you shouldn't be force to stay because of some restriction or abnormal cost or any fear that they can bully you and prevent you from joining other clans

Terrible. Just terrible. Gems are far too valuable to be used in this manner.

With hoppers the game is less intriguing due to people so focused on filling their clans.
There are break off conversations, but they are usually about girls and sports.

If there are millions of players in clash of clans there will always be active hopper activity, but this will suppress clan leaving activity.

Clans will start growing, and rising among higher ranking clans. More top clans.

If you look up the definition of "clan" you will notice that clans are not supposed to be a 1-2 day maximum thing for everyone.
Hopping shouldn't be allowed because then how would this game carry on their name?
clash of clans.
clans..

I guess there are still clans? I am being over dramatic.

But people feelings get hurt when you become family with a member, then, they leave and curse members with explicate vulgar.

People, also, will advance faster due to better clans.
Better clans mean better troops, and better wars.
More choices for attacks in wars mean more loot.

I do not see any negativity in this idea.
These made up type of clans.. "Feeder clan" They do not make sense to me.

I guess change is nice, and exploring is good. But I see I have a very diverse way of seeing this.
But I higher consider this cause.

And 10-20 gems is such little cost.
Please support my cause.

thats stupid some people hop to get their donations up and how will you start a new clan thats stupid

It's not our problem, people doesn't want to stay in a clan, he want to go for another one, why punish them?

I look at this had a benefit towards all.

You guys look at it had benefits towards you self. Which I guess ins't bad. :p

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ayyyyyema

So i needa wait 20mins when going to our feeder clan to help out? No. There's allllot of clan family's out thereand itd just ruin their clans. Hoppers are seriously not a big deal. There's a kick button for a reason!

---

This might work if it were implemented along with my idea for sister clans (Link in my sig). Maybe if you made it so that it doesn't count it if you hopped clans if it is within your own family.

NO!!!!!!!!!!!!! HORRIBLE IDEA I AM NOT PAYING 20 GEMS TO GET IN A CLAN!!!!!!! NO DEFINITELY NOT!!!!! :mad::mad::mad:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DeathVillage

NO!!!!!!!!!!!!! HORRIBLE IDEA I AM NOT PAYING 20 GEMS TO GET IN A CLAN!!!!!!! NO DEFINITELY NOT!!!!! :mad::mad::mad:

---

I think you read it wrong, you have to pay to go BACK into a clan that you were recently "Hopping". In other words, you can't join a clan right after you left it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TurtleBandits

I think you read it wrong, you have to pay to go BACK into a clan that you were recently "Hopping". In other words, you can't join a clan right after you left it.

---

That makes no sense and is not what the OP says.

Hoppers are great anyway they give out free xp

Do those gems get lost in the game or go to the clan leader/distributed among the co-leaders?.. I wouldn't mind the last one

I say the gems go towards to top player/clans thing that the best players in the game get.
Has a reward or something. I dunno.
My ideas are in benefit for the players, and the company.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rakkscout

I say the gems go towards to top player/clans thing that the best players in the game get.
Has a reward or something. I dunno.
My ideas are in benefit for the players, and the company.

---

De Facto Gem Sharing. Leave and return intentionally to give players free gems.

This whole idea of requiring gems to join a clan is ludicrous.

We should all pretend like this thread never happened....

Good idea.
But I will restate that we receive 5 gems, minimal, a day.

I have nothing against hoppers. I'm not a hopper myself but I see people come and go all the time. Some of my clanmates will leave for another clan they have friends in for a few hours then return. I have no problem with that either.
Heck, I'm a clan war junky and a hopper just left after being saved to our war. Whatever... I know we'll still win because we don't need him.

Bottomline is hoppers do nothing to harm my gaming experience in anyway. I'm against any penalty towards hoppers.

Being the leader of a clan in a family where I have to jump from my clan to a feeder or main clan to help out, I wouldn't like to pay gems to help out my clanfam.. Especially since I save up for my builders. This is ridiculous.

i dont really like the idea. the old leader of my clan used to hop around a lot checking on the other two clans in the clan family, so what if the leader of the family had to hop around to check the family? wouldnt it be unfair to pay gems?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Rakkscout

People join, and leave clans at little cost.
Actually there is no cost?

What needs to be done is 10, maybe 20, gems included to join clans.

Gems are very important, and considered valuable.

Also, if you cannot afford to pay the ammount of gems needed, then you cannot join.

But you can keep invites, of course.

You can get up to, I believe, 6 gems a day? Maybe 5?

This solution will stop hoppers, motivate people to buy more gems, and let people understand the value of gems.

This solution will work!

You amazing friend,
Kevin Monette.

---

Delete this thread. Supercell will definitely use this idea, and CoC will get even less fun.
I swear, they may do something like this, with all of the gems involved...

No. Maybe when someone wants to leave the clan an elder/co/head needs to agree with this so they can leave. And there should also be a white and black losts for clans, and you can report a hopper, if they get several reports, they get a temp or perma ban from joining clans.
400th post

terrible idea.. people moving in-between feeder and sister clans have to pay gems.. i hope not

ps. Nothing wrong with hoppers. what you need is good clan management *simple

There is a compromise, allow the legitimate use of family clans and helping out. If someone leaves the clan there should be a penalty of not being able to use the cc troops they just took.to counteract, the leader / coleader to approve use of cc troops to leave the clan which would allow family clans to operate.
20min pause is enough time for the hopper to cook their troops and go to the next clan to take cc troops. and kudos to you for helping out clans

Very bad idea

Very bad idea, ruining the "sharks" of clash of clans(im not meaning like loan sharks). Without them, clash wouldnt be the same, just like without sharks in the oceans, the ocean wouldnt be the same.