Share Gems, Resources (Gold, elix, and dark elix) with clan mates?

I have an idea, It may or may not be popular but Some clan mates may not have disposable income to be able to purchase gems or may need help with borrowing or donations from friends of elixer or coins. I spend quite a lot on gems for myself, and often wish that I could send a few to friends in my clan to help them from time to time. it would be beneficial to share your stuff with clan mates on a request basis. all one would have to do is add a button on visit links to each clan mate to Donations, and allow us to donate Elixer Gold Dark Elixer, and even gems. I can say for certain, I would buy MORE gems if I could transfer some to clan mates who may not be as lucky as myself to be able to afford the gems. This would increase revenue for Clash of Clans and it would be a voluntary basis from the people donating, so it would be no problem that I can foresee with it... It would also push cooperation and more stable friendships within the game when people really are able to help each other in their clan beyond just a few troops here and there

this idea is ruled out by supercell, please read the stick before posting something that is ruled out

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JerrytheScary

this idea is ruled out by supercell, please read the stick before posting something that is ruled out

---

Really is too bad... I spend nearly 200 us dollars every couple weeks on gems... been getting frustrated trying to figure out how to help others, games getting lame... maybe take my money elsewhere then... sad if it comes to that but this game is boring if we cant help increase our clan mates potentials...

If you spend that much get help. Seriously

This is ruled out, It could be easily abused

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Btu2001

If you spend that much get help. Seriously

---

I wonder if supercell agrees with your mindset of needing help... hmmm... lol im a developer of another game in app stores I make enough money to do it easily... supercell could easily increase income from me if they did this... and its my choice to spend money on these games, what better way to send YOU better things, by feeding money into the game making the developers more inclined to add new cool things... or do you really think I need help? I feel sorry for you, obviously you dont understand how these games get bigger and better...

iTunes gift card

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lucas10

This is ruled out, It could be easily abused

---

It could easily be abused, Im curious how this could easily be abused? If someone voluntarily buys or gives resources away, it only makes it more likely they will spend more money of their own to replenish. How exactly can it be abused if it is voluntary? Im curious of ANY negative impact that this could have? I really would like to know, im not being sarcastic, just writing it off that it could be abused, is not enough I want to know HOW a voluntary action could be abused?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AxionXD

iTunes gift card

---

It would work if you know the people in real life and can get them the gift cards, however, as policy, you are not supposed to give any real life information to people on here that you really dont know. its unsafe, so who would be willing to give their real life info to receive a gift card? And electronically would work but still would require real life info released to give it online... but only if you are in the same country... if in my case I live in UK, and I want to support friends in USA, I cant buy them a UK gift card for use in USA, it wont work. So this wouldnt work in my case

I like this idea. It's a shame it's apparantley ruled out.

Whether you strongly believe in and understand your idea or not... this idea is ruled out by Supercells developers and is likely not going to happen... if ever. Now we just wait for a moderator to close this thread.

ehm, its ruled out for some reasons i dont know. no need to discuss it again i guess. but thumbs up for ur willingness to help other players.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Marc1923

I like this idea. It's a shame it's apparantley ruled out.

---

As a developer of another game in app store, I can tell you, i have been wrong about things I ruled out in the past, and all it took was enough people explaining how it would benefit the developer as well as the players. Right now, I am only hoping that Supercell does at least read this, Id like to see them respond what actually could occur that would be bad from it, I mean, I understand, gems may be a hard transfer, beings how that is a very large part of their income and may have a lot of coding blocking gem transfer even being possible, but elixer and gold can be transfered as easily as troops... its just a matter of a few lines of coding which if they really wanted I could help them with :-p regardless, I just wanted to get this seen, Id like to see actual reasoning why this wont work. I really cant see negative around it. I say if its to clanmates only, and voluntary sending, there is no abuse that could occur...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by scdaluz

I wonder if supercell agrees with your mindset of needing help... hmmm... lol im a developer of another game in app stores I make enough money to do it easily... supercell could easily increase income from me if they did this... and its my choice to spend money on these games, what better way to send YOU better things, by feeding money into the game making the developers more inclined to add new cool things... or do you really think I need help? I feel sorry for you, obviously you dont understand how these games get bigger and better...

---

Yes, SuperCell would ruin the game for a few thousand $ from you. People would have DOZENS of accounts donating them resources while CONSTANTLY staying online. Thats how it can be abused.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by scdaluz

As a developer of another game in app store, I can tell you, i have been wrong about things I ruled out in the past, and all it took was enough people explaining how it would benefit the developer as well as the players. Right now, I am only hoping that Supercell does at least read this, Id like to see them respond what actually could occur that would be bad from it, I mean, I understand, gems may be a hard transfer, beings how that is a very large part of their income and may have a lot of coding blocking gem transfer even being possible, but elixer and gold can be transfered as easily as troops... its just a matter of a few lines of coding which if they really wanted I could help them with :-p regardless, I just wanted to get this seen, Id like to see actual reasoning why this wont work. I really cant see negative around it. I say if its to clanmates only, and voluntary sending, there is no abuse that could occur...

---

Its abusable by having multi accounts. It is ruled. Please close this thread.

The abuse that could occur is: Players using multiple accounts to deliver gems/resources to themselves. Say you want an extra 250 gems... well all you need to do is make yourself a second account, build a castle, and donate gems to your main account.

No matter how hard you tried to make this thread.No matter how much you spend.This is ruled out and won't happen until supercell changes this.Were sorry

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Wafflesaregoodforyou

The abuse that could occur is: Players using multiple accounts to deliver gems/resources to themselves. Say you want an extra 250 gems... well all you need to do is make yourself a second account, build a castle, and donate gems to your main account.

---

It could be abused because multiple accounts, so attach donations to game center, require game center log on, problem solved. As I stated, this is to clan mates only and now, game center log on, wont work multiple accounts without a great deal of work and getting raided inbetween because of having to log off GC from one account and log onto another... it wouldnt leave room for abuse... and as I stated gems dont need to be included alone, resources would be fine, still require log on GC and problem and abuse stopped.

So that is debunked... any other abuse possibilities?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by scdaluz

It could be abused because multiple accounts, so attach donations to game center, require game center log on, problem solved. As I stated, this is to clan mates only and now, game center log on, wont work multiple accounts without a great deal of work and getting raided inbetween because of having to log off GC from one account and log onto another... it wouldnt leave room for abuse... and as I stated gems dont need to be included alone, resources would be fine, still require log on GC and problem and abuse stopped.

So that is debunked... any other abuse possibilities?

---

Please stop, the idea is ruled out, leave it it at that.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by scdaluz

It could be abused because multiple accounts, so attach donations to game center, require game center log on, problem solved. As I stated, this is to clan mates only and now, game center log on, wont work multiple accounts without a great deal of work and getting raided inbetween because of having to log off GC from one account and log onto another... it wouldnt leave room for abuse... and as I stated gems dont need to be included alone, resources would be fine, still require log on GC and problem and abuse stopped.

So that is debunked... any other abuse possibilities?

---

There's no amount of work some people aren't going to go through to tilt the table to their direction. GC or G+ ties are not enough as creating new accounts is too easy and the abuse would find a way no matter what obstacles you or SC lays in its path

As others have said, this is currently ruled out. Please see the sticky.