Should only alow ppl to join 1 clan a day to slow down hoppers, or make it so they can be tagged as hoppers if reported by a certain number of clan leaders
Printable View
Should only alow ppl to join 1 clan a day to slow down hoppers, or make it so they can be tagged as hoppers if reported by a certain number of clan leaders
"Man I would love to see how my feeder clan is going, unfortunately I cannot go back to lead my main clan if I do because i must wait an entire day. Oh well. :/" Hoppers4Lyfe.Quote:
Originally Posted by tuttut
So, currently I am at war with my clan, a friend of my plays in the war with me as a guest (as he has itīs own clan). Our clan highest level dragon is lvl2, he just hopped to his own clan to get me lvl4 dragons in our clan casles in our base, why would I want to prevent hoppers???????Quote:
Originally Posted by tuttut
Hopping is fine if it helps your clan, and for the ones not helping your clan there are ways to solve it (donīt donate, kick, good leadership, etc.)
Sorry, canīt support these requests.
What u guys r describing is not even hopping so why even weigh in on discussion.
Because we are showing how your ideas may affect people who aren't hoppers negatively. It can also prevent the good hoppers who join a clan, help it out by donating troops, and then hop to another clan to share the love. You should more closely examine our posts before assuming what we have to say is of no value to your original post.Quote:
Originally Posted by tuttut
i'm a nice hopper and would find this extremely annoying. also, players looking for a clan would find this annoying too. they would have to stay 1 day in each clan before trying another one.
Well, okay, letīs not argue over what is or what is not considered a hopper.Quote:
Originally Posted by tuttut
Your request was to only allow players to join one clan a day, which would prevent what we have listed out and what you think should not be considered hopper. It seems we are in agreement than that your idea is not a solution.
Staying in clan for a whole day would give you time to properly judge a clans merits and also would force ppl to judge clans more closely before jumping in and out. The main problem with hoppers is the way they effect the clan wars by jumping out after a war has started. I think being able to tag ppl as habitiual hoppers would be benifical to all clans. And also if there your freinds comming and going fro ur clan then u wouldn't report them and there wouldn't be a problem.
Quote:
Originally Posted by tuttut
what if i'm looking for a clan, i read 12345's clan description and think it looks cool. so i join and then start getting insulted by the members, i would have to stay in that horrible clan for 1 whole day before being allowed to leave.
I like the idea! I think a 12 hour cooldown would work great!
If you abandon your clan during war 24 to 48 hour cooldown!
Whats so bad about hopper what do they hurt? They give free xp
I guess the issue can be solved easily xD
Fix a incremental cool down time like below
1 time hopping - 5 mins
2nd time hopping - 25 mins
3 rd time hopping - 125 mins
Everytime the time gets multiplied by 5
and set a limit that only 5 times a person can hop in a day
This will not affect the below people
1) people who hop to get good troops or help people in war
2) people who looking for a good clan around
You're ignoring the reasons people are giving why this wouldn't work.Quote:
Originally Posted by tuttut
We have a farm team, and a war team. Players come and go all the time (sometimes just to check in and say hello), so your suggestion would be a real problem for us. "Hoppers" are not a problem for well run clans. Just require new members to donate for a bit before requesting, or have them be spectators for a war before you let them participate. Bottom line is that well run clans don't need SC's help to deal with this issue.
Is this really necessary? "Hoppers" can still hop multiple times a day, so you haven't really solved anything.Quote:
Originally Posted by Rajag89
There are countless suggestions that I would rather see SC work on before this one.
Well that is just a starter idea which was given there and I am not a coc developer to sit develop the algorithm for whole damn thing.Quote:
Originally Posted by JohnnyBGood
they can even limit the number of hoppings per season or add a history log to profile just to count the number of times he hopped so far.
It might be easy for clans to predict the member with this details.
Gtg , I have to write programs for my office lol bye now
I am no hopper but certainly don't like this idea. I went to several different clans when I was looking for one I liked.
You are not forced to stay in the clan for a day. You can leave the clan you just can't join another one.Quote:
Originally Posted by HeavensFace
And in my opinion I dislike hoppers, good or bad.
What I think would prevent hoppers is if it cost a certain amount of loot to join a clan, maybe increasing with level or other point of measure in the game? Or the cost could go up with every time you join a clan, resetting every day or two days or season, or any mix in the middle.
Anouther Idea would be that if players had a history, (in the profile for example) of the clans they have been in and how long they stayed, how much they donated per season, an average, clan wars don. and history, and the like. This would be nice and would expose hoppers.
I think this idea should have its own thread!Quote:
Originally Posted by BACBAGAC
some people hop to just donate
1. What if a good player has trouble finding a good clan and needs to look around for a good long while before he finds it? Should he be branded a "hopper" by virtue of the information contained in his profile, and thus be excluded from well run clans that won't accept a new member with poor looking stats?Quote:
Originally Posted by BACBAGAC
2. I would like to see average donations per season in a person's profile.
3. Wars won? I think stars earned is more important than how many wars the person's clan/s won.
There are many ideas I would like to see implemented before these (opt-out button for wars, being able to see what kind of troop levels my clanmates have, etc.).
Hoppers are a way of life in CoC. I highly doubt any method to halt this is limited to what currently exists.
A lot of good ideas in this thread. I especially like the increased profile info to help spot the hoppers. Got to say no suprise to me that the hoppers r pro hoppin and everyone else that has to deal with it is against it lol. Btw if ur just searching for new clan it doesn't make u a hopper and this ideas wouldn't really effect you.
We all know this is a problem, but your solution is inadequate because it fixes one problem, but causes others as described earlier). You don't want an end to hoppers,and niether do most people, you just want an option in the clanwar to replace them. That way, it fixes one problem, but doesn't cause any.Quote:
Originally Posted by tuttut
Try to think of the pros and cons and other ideas before posting them?
Hopping is clearly allowed, otherwise SC will have countered it by now
Hoppers are great going around requesting troops giving out free xp.
If you abandon a clan while at war there is already a cooldown before you can join another war in another clan!Quote:
Originally Posted by sgc0286
Incorrect, my highest member in current war is a temp member, he hopped 3 times just today to get himself the best troops from his feederclan to smash the enemyīs number 1. Your proposal woudl have resulted in him not being able to do this for me.Quote:
Originally Posted by Rajag89
Now that is the first idea that kinda makes sense. It would need to be checked if this is okay for privacy regulations I guess but if legally possible, this absolutely makes sense ;) I think this idea deserves its own thread and I happily invite you to post it (sure I will be rating it good :-))Quote:
Originally Posted by BACBAGAC
Yeah it's called war eligibility. Annnnnnd if this still occurs welp dont start a war with unloyal clanmates!Quote:
Originally Posted by sgc0286
as for this idea, so stupid SORRY im being honest. Maybe for your lvl30 this is cool but no.
I mean im just lvl64 but frankly when i try to find a new home, it takes me a lot of clans to go in chat it up a lil get the vibe and decide. And mostly when i joinn i fill al requests (so you'd be happy for me as a hopper). Sorry no clan is as AWESOME and SOARING TO THE TOP 200 and frankly ACTIVE as they say. If I had to go into a new clan who "says" they a active then see a chat with each response an hour apart, KILL ME NOW!
Hey if you dont like hoppers CLOSE THE CLAN problem solved, NEXT
Nerf the hoppers, nerf the troops, nerf the walls, nerf the price of clans, why don't we just nerf the whole game so everyone can stop :rolleyes: